Jiayu Zhang1, Taous Meriem Laleg1, Stephanie Bogaert2, Rik Achten2,3, and Hacene Serrai2,3
1Computer, Electrical and Mathematical Sciences and Engineering, King Abdullah University of Science and Technology (KAUST), Thuwal, Saudi Arabia, 2Department of Radiology, University Hospital of Gent, gent, Belgium, 3University of Gent, Gent, Belgium
Synopsis
A magnetic resonance imaging denoising method based upon the spectral analysis of the shrodinger operator is proposed.The method called semi-classical signal analysis SCSA, employs an adaptive filter to represent the MRI image as a set of useful vectors and others representing noise. The separation between signal and noise vectors is achieved using a soft and efficient threshold. Method validation is achieved on anatomical brain images acquired with low signal to noise ratio. The obtained results demonstrate that the SCSA is efficient in reducing noise while preserving image details necessary for accurate image diagnosis.Introduction
Reduction of acquisition time has been a major target in Magnetic
Resonance Imaging (MRI). It allows measuring accurately dynamic and
functional changes in diagnostic studies. Several techniques are currently used
to reduce acquisition time (e.g: parallel imaging (PI)). However, high
speed MRI suffers from low signal to noise ratio (SNR), which makes difficult
clinical data analysis. Several denoising methods, attempting to filter out
noise from the acquired MRI images has been proposed to improve MR image
quality
1,2. In this study, we propose a new denoising technique, which
we refer to Semi-Classical Signal Analysis (SCSA)
3. This method has
the advantage to employ adaptive vectors derived from the Schrödinger operator
to decompose the MRI image into a sum of squared eigenfunctions and uses a soft
threshold to separate between useful image coefficients and those belonging to noise.
The SCSA method has been successfully applied in MRS data denoising for
accurate data quantification
4.
Material and Methods
Experiments are performed
on one healthy male subject, on a 3T scanner (MAGNETOM Tim-Trio, Siemens
Healthcare) equipped with a 32-channel head coil for signal reception. Turbo
Flash sequence is used with the following parameters: TR/TE = 250/2.46 ms;
matrix, 256x256 resolution and 33 contiguous slices; FOV: 220mm; voxel size:
0.9x0.9x3 mm3; flip angle:10; and receiver bandwidth set to 320 Hz/pixel. To
reduce SNR, Two sets of data are acquired: one with Nex =2, considered as an
original data set (see images below), and the second set with Nex = 1, and PI
acceleration factor set to 2, taken as noisy data set.
The proposed
method uses the discrete spectrum of the Schrodinger operator, consisting of the computed negative
eigenvalues, to reconstruct the image $$$V_2$$$ as follows,
\begin{equation}
V_2(x,y)=
\left(\frac{h^{2}}{L^{cl}_{2,\gamma}} \displaystyle \sum_{k=1}^{K_{h}}
\left(-\mu_{k,h} \right)^{\gamma}\psi^{2}_{k,h}(x,y)\right)^{\frac{1}{1+\gamma}},
\end{equation}
where $$$\gamma>0$$$ (in this study $$$\gamma=4$$$) and $$$L^{cl}_{2,\gamma}$$$ is given by:
\begin{equation}
L^{cl}_{2,\gamma}=\frac{1}{2^{2}\pi}\frac{\Gamma(\gamma+1)}{\Gamma(\gamma+2)},
\end{equation} $$$\Gamma$$$ refers to the standard Gamma function. Moreover, $$$\mu_{k,h}$$$ and $$$\psi_{k,h}$$$ denote the negative eigenvalues with $$$\mu_{1,h} <
\cdots <\mu_{K_{h},h}< 0,
K_{h}$$$ is a finite number of negative eigenvalues,
and associated L2-normalized eigen functions of the operator $$$\mathcal{H}_{2,h}\left(V_{2}\right)$$$ such that:
\begin{equation}
\mathcal{H}_{2,h}(V_2)\,\psi_{k,h} =
\mu_{k,h}\,\psi_{k,h}, \quad k=1,\cdots,K_h
\end{equation}
where, \begin{equation}
\mathcal{H}_{2,h}(V_{2})= -h^{2}\Delta-V_{2},
\end{equation}
with $$$\Delta=\frac{\partial^{2}}{\partial
x^{2}}+\frac{\partial^{2}}{\partial y^{2}} $$$. An efficient algorithm to reconstruct the MRI image
using the SCSA has been proposed in reference 3 where the 1D SCSA is run on the
rows and the columns of the image and then the squared L2-normalized
eigenfunctions of these 1D problems are combined using a tensor product
approach. The parameter h plays an important role in the SCSA. When h
decreases, the approximation
improves3. However in the de-noising process, it is recommended to
retain the eigenfunctions belonging to the signal and discard those
representing noise. The SNR is computed as in reference 2.
Results and discussion
Figure 1 shows a brain image selected from the original
(SNR =43.41) and noisy (SNR = 34.2) sets above, and the reconstructed SCSA
image, where a significant increase in SNR has been obtained (SNR = 47.6). In
figure 2, the middle of the images in Figure 1
is zoomed, showing that SCSA preserves the contrast of the image while
reducing noise contribution. As mentioned above, SCSA relies on the choice of
h. By increasing this parameter, we
observe an SNR increase, but with image blurring effect, whereas when
h decreases, less SNR increase is obtained, but the image details are
preserved. An optimal choice of the value of
h, which is strongly linked to the SNR, has to be determined. One
approach is to locally vary its value across the processed image given the SNR
value of the same image location.
Conclusion
As shown, the SCSA method is powerful in
significantly reducing noise while preserving image information. This allows
for reduction of acquisition time to achieve high performance dynamic and
functional MR studies. Better performance of the method is achieved by spatially
varying the value of h as function of the SNR across the image. Preliminary
results are encouraging.
Acknowledgements
No acknowledgement found.References
1)
Erturk MA,
et al, IEEE Trans. Biomed. Eng.,vol.60(6), pp.1556-1562,2013.
2)
Islam A., IEEE Trans. Biomed. Eng.
,vol 60(11) pp.3204-3215,2013.
3)
Kaisserli Z et al. Digital
Sign. Processing. J.,
40 (C), 2015, 80-87
4) Laleg T.M et al. ISMRM, 2015