Paola Valsasina1, Maria Assunta Rocca1, Laura Vacchi1, Alessandro Meani1, Mariaemma Rodegher2, Vittorio Martinelli2, Giancarlo Comi2, Andrea Falini3, and Massimo Filippi1
1Neuroimaging Research Unit, San Raffaele Scientific Institute, Vita-Salute San Raffaele University, Milan, Italy, 2Department of Neurology, San Raffaele Scientific Institute, Vita-Salute San Raffaele University, Milan, Italy, 3Department of Neuroradiology, San Raffaele Scientific Institute, Vita-Salute San Raffaele University, Milan, Italy
Synopsis
In this
study, we investigated
behavioral and functional MRI (fMRI) correlates of a N-back task in 72 patients
with multiple sclerosis (MS). We found a load-dependent
alteration of executive network recruitment, varying according to the disease
phenotype. Increased recruitment of frontal regions was associated to the early
phase of MS. Conversely, the modulation of regions belonging to the default
mode network was more evident in patients with long-lasting disease and was related
to the global cognitive profile, suggesting an increased need of cognitive
resources to cope with task-demand.Background and Purpose
According to the load theory, an active mechanism of
cognitive control is involved in maintaining current task goals and reducing
additional processing of irrelevant information.
Based on this, increasing task difficulty may lead
to a higher recruitment of cognitive resources [1]. The
N-back is a task with increasing task difficulty and working memory request,
which has been used in MS patients for the assessment of working memory and
processing speed deficits [2-3].
In
this study, we used a N-back working
memory task with different levels of cognitive
load to: 1) assess behavioral and fMRI abnormalities during this task in MS
patients in comparison to healthy controls (HC); 2) identify alterations of
recruitment of the N-back network across the various stages of the disease; 3)
investigate the correlation between fMRI abnormalities and clinico-behavioural
measures (including cognitive scores), as well as structural MRI damage.
Methods
A
N-back fMRI task was administered to 72 right-handed MS patients and 24 age-
and gender-matched HC. There were 12 clinically isolated syndromes (CIS), 38 relapsing-remitting
(RR), and 22 secondary progressive (SP) MS. The N-back had four levels of
increasing difficulty (from 0 to 3 back), presented in a block design with a
random order; stimuli
were letters and subjects had to respond by pressing the MRI-compatible
response box button when the letter matched the target. Dual-echo turbo spin echo and high-resolution 3D
T1-weighted scans were also obtained from all study subjects for lesion and
volumetric analysis, respectively. Cognitive assessment was performed by using the Brief Repeatable
Battery of Neuropsychological Tests (BRB-N) [4]. Based on the scores
obtained by the patients at each BRB-N test, a global cognitive score (GCS) was
calculated. Regions
showing load-dependent activations/deactivations with increasing task difficulty
(0- to 3-back and load contrasts) were modelled using SPM8. SPM8 and ANOVA models, adjusted for age and sex,
were used to perform between-group comparisons of fMRI activations. SPM8 and
multivariate regression analyses were used to assess correlations with
behavioral (accuracy, reaction time), clinical (Expanded Disability Status
Scale score, disease duration, GCS, attentive domain score), and structural MRI
(T2 and T1 lesion volumes, normalized grey, white and brain volumes) variables.
Results
Compared to HC, MS patients
had worse task performance and brain atrophy. All groups activated fronto-parietal
and cerebellar regions and deactivated areas part of the default-mode network
(DMN) (Figure 1 A-D). Compared to HC, MS patients had higher recruitment of the
right parietal cortex and fronto-mesial areas during low cognitive load
conditions as well as decreased recruitment of posterior regions during higher
load conditions (Figure 1 E-F). The analysis of the load contrast showed that,
compared to HC and RRMS, CIS patients had increased activations of anterior
brain areas and right hippocampus, and decreased recruitment of the left postcentral
and superior temporal gyrus (STG). SPMS patients showed decreased activation of
left putamen when compared to RRMS (Figure 2). Worse performance at the attentional
domain correlated with lower right precuneus recruitment, whereas higher global
cognitive score was related to decreased deactivations of the right STG. No
correlation was found between fMRI abnormalities and structural MRI measures.
Conclusions
Load-dependent
alterations of executive network recruitment occur in MS patients and vary
according to disease phenotype. Increased recruitment of frontal regions was
associated to early phase of MS. Conversely, the modulation of regions
belonging to the DMN was more evident in patients with long-lasting disease and
appeared to be related to the global cognitive profile, suggesting an increased
need of cognitive resources to cope with task demand.
Acknowledgements
Partially
supported by a grant from Italian Ministry of Health
(GR-2008-1138784/GR-2009-1529671) and Fondazione Italiana Sclerosi Multipla
(FISM2012/R/8).References
[1]
Lavie N. Curr Dir Psychol Science 2010;19:143-148.
[2]
Parmenter B., et al. J Int Neuropsychol Soc 2007; 13:417-423.
[3]
Rocca M.A., et al. Hum Brain Mapp 2014;35:5799-5814.
[4]
Rao S.M., et al. Neurology 1991;41:685-691.