Synopsis
Neuromyelitis
optica (NMO) severely affects the optic nerves and spinal cord and shares features
with multiple sclerosis (MS). Ongoing diffuse neurodegeneration, however, is
thought to be absent in NMO between relapses. We collected cervical cord mcDESPOT
at baseline and one-year follow-up in patients and matched controls. While
there were no significant changes in controls and MS patients, the NMO group
showed a loss of cord volume, decrease in T1 and increase in myelin
water fraction. We hypothesize that continuing atrophy in lesioned areas reduces
the amount of damaged tissue relative to healthy tissue, and is responsible for
the observed changes.Introduction
Neuromyelitis
optica (NMO) is a rare inflammatory disease primarily targeting the optic
nerves and spinal cord, with limited brain volvement. Its clinical features
and relapsing course resemble that of relapsing-remitting multiple sclerosis
(MS), although the underlying pathological mechanisms differ. In particular, there
is no progressive phase in NMO, and current evidence suggests that neurodegeneration
is absent between attacks. In a previous investigation, no evidence of ongoing diffuse cerebral
damage was found using MRI relaxometry and atrophy measures
1. In the
current study, we extended these evaluations to the cervical spinal cord, using multi-component
relaxometry to evaluate changes in atrophy and quantitative parameters of
tissue damage at baseline and one year in NMO patients versus MS patients and
controls.
Methods
13 anti-aquaporin-4
antibody-positive NMO patients (median age 45 (range 27-76)), 13
relapsing-remitting MS patients (38 (22-62)), and 17 age-matched healthy
controls (54 (19-76)) were scanned at baseline. Patient groups had equivalent disease
durations (NMO: median 60 months (12-186); MS: 54 (24-156)). A subset of 8 NMO,
11 MS patients and 14 controls was scanned again after one year. All but one
NMO and one MS patient in the follow-up group had a history of transverse
myelitis. A multi-component driven equilibrium single pulse observation of T
1/T
2
(mcDESPOT) protocol was acquired on a Siemens Verio 3T scanner over the whole
cervical cord with 0.9x0.9x1.8 mm voxels
2. Images were registered
with FSL-FLIRT, segmented using the Spinal Cord Toolbox
3, and analysed
voxelwise with a three-pool model
4 to calculate the myelin water
fraction (f
M) and T
1 (related to total water content). Median
f
M and T
1 were obtained along the cervical cord from C1
to C7. Cord volume (CV), normalized by length and including lesioned areas, was
measured on a T
1-weighted spoiled gradient echo image from the mcDESPOT
protocol. Non-parametric statistics were used to compare groups at baseline,
and change in metrics over time; mean percentage difference between groups or percentage change ±
standard deviation are reported.
Results
BASELINE (Fig. 1): Compared to controls, NMO patients had lower
CV (-12.4±12.4%, p=.002), lower fM (-11.3±9.2%, p=.004) and higher T1
(+11.0±12.7%, p=.002); the MS group had lower fM (-14.0±13.0%, p=.001)
and higher T1 (+8.2±11.0%, p=.01). There were no significant
differences between patient groups.
LONGITUDINAL (Fig. 2): At
one-year follow-up, controls were stable in all measures (all p≥.2). MS
patients showed a loss of cord volume (-1.4±3.2%, p=.2), reduction in
fM (-2.1±11.8%, p=.2) and increase in T1 (+4.4±10.3%, p=.3) (all non-significant). The NMO group showed a
significant decrease in CV (-5.1±4.6%, p=.02), an increase in fM (+6.6±8.3%,
p=.04) and a decrease in T1 (-2.4±2.5%, p=.04).
Discussion
Cross-sectional
analysis showed, as expected, lower volume & f
M and elevated T
1
in both patient groups compared to controls
(see Fig. 3 for example maps). Over the one-year observation
period, cord atrophy was seen in the NMO group, but not detected in the MS group. Given
that focal cord pathology is known to be more severe in NMO, we hypothesize
that the volume decrease is the result of continuing atrophy following
transverse myelitis. The NMO group also displayed significant longitudinal
changes in f
M and T
1, which were in the opposite
direction to the (non-significant) changes in the MS group. Decrease in T
1 is likely due to the loss of
tissue volume; where cystic lesions shrink, the amount of necrotic tissue
diminishes, leaving a greater relative amount of healthy tissue and producing a
lower median T
1 value over the cord, which may also explain the
observed increase in f
M. Alternatively, the increase in f
M
could result from a drop in total water content (f
M being a ratio of
myelin to total water). Finally, though less likely given the time frame for
follow-up, the increase in f
M could reflect ongoing repair, which
would be consistent with the hypothesis that progression is absent in NMO.
Conclusion
The observed
changes are consistent with what is known about the pathology of NMO. The decrease
in cord volume can be attributed to residual damage from lesions. Changes in T
1
and f
M are linked with the volume loss, most likely at lesion sites.
Thus, shrinkage of lesioned tissue leads to changes in median values calculated
over the whole cervical cord. While
evidence of disease progression has been previously demonstrated in the MS
cord, these results suggest this is not the case in NMO and lend evidence to the current theory that subclinical
progression is not a feature of the disease. Further work will look at segmenting
lesioned from healthy tissue in order to separate the effects of lesion
evolution from changes in normal-appearing tissue.
Acknowledgements
We thank the MRI technologists for assistance with data collection, and participants for contributing to this study.References
1. Matthews
L, Kolind S, Brazier A, et al. Imaging surrogates of disease activity in neuromyelitis
optica allow distinction from multiple sclerosis. PLoS ONE. 2015; 10(9): e0137715.
2. Kolind,
SH, & Deoni, SC. Rapid three-dimensional multicomponent relaxation imaging
of the cervical spinal cord. MRM. 2011;65(2):551-556.
3. Cohen-Adad J, De Leener B, Benhamou
M, et al. Spinal Cord Toolbox: an open-source
framework for processing spinal cord MRI data. Proceedings of the 20th Annual
Meeting of OHBM, Hamburg, Germany. 2014:3633.
4. Deoni SCL, Matthews L,
& Kolind, SH. One component? Two components? Three? The effect of including
a nonexchanging “free” water component in multicomponent driven equilibrium
single pulse observation of T1 and T2. MRM. 2013;70(1):147-54.