Synopsis
Based on the observation that anatomic and functional
connectivity measures in multiple sclerosis (MS) are correlated, but not highly
correlated, we propose to combine these metrics into an imaging based measure
of disease progression. We show that this metric is sensitive to disease
progression in a cohort of MS patients over a time period of one year.Purpose
Sensitive outcome measures are required to test
novel therapies designed to target neurodegeneration in MS. The MS Functional Composite
(MSFC)
1, developed to address the
shortcomings of the EDSS by assessing ambulation, but also upper extremity
function, cognition (information processing speed), and vision, may also be
insensitive to neurodegeneration-related changes over short follow-up
intervals. An alternative method
involves neuroimaging. We have previously shown that functional connectivity
using resting-state fMRI (rs-fMRI) and anatomic connectivity using DTI are
related in the transcallosal motor pathway and along the memory pathway
connecting hippocampus (Hipp) to posterior cingulate (PCC).
2,3 We
propose a combined metric incorporating anatomic and functional connectivity
along these pathways as a potential biomarker of disease progression in MS.
Methods
AIFCI:
Our metric, called the anatomic impairment functional connectivity index
(AIFCI), is constructed as an analogy to the MSFC. The AIFCI is the sum of z-scored measures of pathway-dependent DTI and
RS-fMRI measures. Transverse diffusivity (TD), based on Lowe et al.3, is a good measure of
anatomic connectivity in the pathways of interest here. Two systems are
assessed: the motor system and the episodic memory system.
Motor AIFCI measure
The motor AIFCI is calculated according to equation 1 in Figure 1. <fc>, σcpop
and <TD>pop, and σRDpop can be either population or sample means and
standard deviations for RS-fMRI and TD in the transcallosal motor pathway. The AIFCI
metric is constructed such that the measure will decrease with increased
disability.
Memory AIFCI measure
Because the PCC-AMTL pathway is intrahemispheric
and bilateral, the memory AIFCI measure is constructed to be sensitive to
memory pathway impairment in either hemisphere. It is constructed by first
z-scoring each hemisphere measure according to equation 2 in Figure 1.
The AIFCI is then calculated by combining the component Z’s according to equation 3 in Figure 1.
Data
Acquisition: Nine MS patients were scanned at 4 time-points over one year in an IRB approved protocol (age: 51.44±6.6, 1 male, EDSS:
4.06±1.6). Data were acquired on a Siemens TIM Trio 3T MRI scanner
(Erlangen, Germany) using a 12-channel receive-only head array. HARDI data were
acquired4 (TE/TR=102/7700msec, 128x128x48
matrix, FOV=256x256x96mm), 71 b=1000 sec/mm2, and 8 b=0. Resting state scan: 132
repetitions of 31-4mm thick axial slices acquired with TE/TR=29ms/2800 ms,
128x128 matrix, 256mm x 256mm FOV, receive bandwidth=1954Hz/pixel.
Data analysis
The analysis proceeded as described in
reference 2. We measure anatomic and
functional connectivity in the transcallosal motor pathway (SMC), right
hemisphere posterior cingulate-hippocampal pathway (RH PCC-AMTL), and left
hemisphere posterior cingulate-hippocampal pathway (LH PCC-AMTL) in all 9
subjects.
Seed region
definition
Seed regions for the SMC pathway are
defined as the 9-voxel in-plane region centered on the maximum activated voxel
in a finger tapping fMRI study performed in the same scan session. We define
the seed region in each of the right and left hemisphere PCC by selecting a
finite region in each hemisphere proximal to retrosplenial cortex and use the
InstaCorr7 based method (see ref 3).
Fiber
tracking
Using the seed and target regions
defined above, probabilistic fiber tracking is performed on each study2. Pathway dependent diffusion measures are
calculated using the track density map, the scalar diffusion values, and a
white matter mask. The result is a pathway TD for every subject.
Functional connectivity
The RS-fMRI metric,
fc, calculated as: Right and left hemisphere
SMC, hippocampal and PCC ROI’s are defined using method described above. A
reference timeseries is calculated from the arithmetic average of the nine pixels centered on the seed voxel.
The cross correlation is calculated between r/l hemisphere SMC, RH PCC-AMTL, and LH PCC-AMTL. The result is a correlation for each of the three
pathways. The cross correlation is converted to a Student t. This is fc.
Results
Figure 2 shows the evolution of rs-fMRI and
transverse diffusivity across the four time-points measured and the three
pathways. Figure 3 shows the combined measures for each of the pathways and the
total combined AIFCI. A repeated measures anova indicates a significant change
in AIFCI over time with p<0.01, supporting our hypothesis that our combined
measure is sensitive to disease progression over time.
Discussion and Conclusion
Based on
prior observations of the relationship of anatomic and functional connectivity
measures in MS, we propose a combined connectivity metric that assesses
connectivity in motor and cognitive pathways. In a study performed over 4
time-points across an interval of one year in 9 MS patients, AIFCI shows a
significant and systematic decline over that interval. This suggests that
combined imaging-based metrics of anatomic and functional connectivity may be
sensitive biomarkers for disease progression in MS.
Acknowledgements
This study was supported by a grant from the National Multiple Sclerosis Society.References
1.
Rudick, RA, Cutter, G, Reingold, S: The multiple sclerosis functional
composite: a new clinical outcome measure for multiple sderosis trials. Multiple sclerosis (Houndmills, Basingstoke,
England), 8, 359-65, (2002).
2. Lowe, MJ, Beall, EB, Sakaie, KE, Koenig, KA,
Stone, L, Marrie, RA, Phillips, MD: Resting state sensorimotor functional
connectivity in multiple sclerosis inversely correlates with transcallosal
motor pathway transverse diffusivity. Human
brain mapping, 29, 818-27,
(2008).
3. Lowe, MJ, Koenig, KA, Beall, EB, Sakaie, KA,
Stone, L, Bermel, R, Phillips, MD: Anatomic connectivity assessed using pathway
radial diffusivity is related to functional connectivity in monosynaptic
pathways. Brain connectivity, 4, 558-65, (2014).
4. Reese, TG, Heid, O, Weisskoff, RM, Wedeen,
VJ: Reduction of eddy-current-induced distortion in diffusion MRI using a
twice-refocused spin echo. Magn Reson Med,
49, 177-82, (2003).
5. Jones, DK, Horsfield, MA, Simmons, A: Optimal
strategies for measuring diffusion in anisotropic systems by magnetic resonance
imaging. Magn Reson Med, 42, 515-25, (1999).
6. Smith, SM, Jenkinson, M, Woolrich, MW,
Beckmann, CF, Behrens, TE, Johansen-Berg, H, Bannister, PR, De Luca, M,
Drobnjak, I, Flitney, DE, Niazy, RK, Saunders, J, Vickers, J, Zhang, Y, De
Stefano, N, Brady, JM, Matthews, PM: Advances in functional and structural MR
image analysis and implementation as FSL. Neuroimage,
23 Suppl 1, S208-19, (2004).
7. Cox, RW, Hyde, JS: Software tools for
analysis and visualization of fMRI data. NMR
Biomed, 10, 171-8, (1997).