Marjolein Bulk1, Walid M. Abdelmoula1, Linda M. van der Graaf1, Mark A. van Buchem1, Pieter Voorn2, Jouke Dijkstra1, and Louise van der Weerd1,3
1Radiology, Leiden University Medical Center, Leiden, Netherlands, 2Department of Anatomy and Neurosciences, VU University Medical Center, Amsterdam, Netherlands, 3Human Genetics, Leiden University Medical Center, Leiden, Netherlands
Synopsis
Investigating the histological correlates of MRI
contrasts in patients with Alzheimer’s disease (AD) will give more insight into
the pathological correlates of T2* and SWI. Using 7T MRI and histology of
post-mortem brain tissue we showed that the frontal cortex of AD patients has a
different imaging phenotype compared to non-demented controls, which spatially
correlates to changes in iron deposition and grey matter myelin organization
Most importantly, within the AD group the early-onset AD patients are
distinguishable on MRI from the late-onset AD patients, and these differences
are mirrored in the underlying pathology of these AD subtypes. PURPOSE
In a previous study differences in cortical appearance
in patients with Alzheimer’s Disease (AD) were assessed in vivo1 and the
nature of these changes were investigated histologically2. A diffuse
hypointense band was found on MRI in the frontal lobes of AD patients (57% of
cases), but not in controls. Histological correlation showed colocalization of
the diffuse band with iron and myelin2. Differences between patients with an
early disease onset (EOAD, before age 65) and patients with a late disease
onset (LOAD, after age 65) are previously reported, including a more rapid
cognitive decline3 and a more severe post-mortem pathology4 in EOAD
patients. Even differences on MRI have been found: increased cortical phase
shifts suggesting increased iron accumulation are reported for EOAD compared to
LOAD patients5. However, less is known about the origin of these differences
on MRI and the involved pathology.
Therefore, this study investigated the correlation
between ultra-high field MRI and AD pathology in the frontal cortex to further
investigate the role of iron and myelin on MRI contrast and their changes in
subsets of AD patients, containing EOAD and LOAD patients.
METHODS
Post-mortem tissue samples of the frontal
cortex, containing the medial frontal gyrus, from LOAD patients (N=10), EOAD patients (N=11) and non-demented controls (N=13) were obtained
from the Netherlands Brain Bank. Ultra-high field MRI scans were made on a 7T horizontal bore Bruker system
equipped with a 23mm volume coil and Paravision 5.1 imaging software (Bruker
Biospin, Ettlingen, Germany). MGE scans were acquired from
each brain sample with TR=75.0ms, TE=12.5, 23.2, 33.9 and 44.6ms, FA=25° at 100µm isotropic resolution with 20 signal averages. The acquired
magnitude images were assessed using pre-defined criteria based on previous 7T
MRI studies of the human cortex to define normal and abnormal cortex, including
the presence of cortical layers, focal hypointensities, and a
diffuse hypointense band
2. Using the
scoring criteria and values (Figure 1), a total score was
calculated with maximum of 8/8 indicating an abnormal cortex and minimum
score of 0/8 indicating a normal cortex. All samples have been scanned, but
analysis has only been completed in a sub-set (numbers mentioned in the
respective figures). The same brain samples as used for MRI were used for
histology; consecutive sections were stained for myelin, iron, Aβ, tau,
microglia, and astrocytes. After
automatic non-linear registration of the histological images to the MRI images
using elastix
6, the correlation between MRI and histology was determined using
spatial correlation of the pixels intensities but after normalizing all images
using histogram equalization. Additionally, the myelin architecture of layer IV
of the frontal cortex was investigated using light microscopy and quantified
using standardized stereological techniques (MCID Core Digital Imaging Software)
7.
RESULTS
The AD subjects showed differences on MRI and histology compared to non-demented control subjects. AD subjects were more frequently scored as
abnormal on MRI, characterized by the presence of hypointensities and absence
of cortical layers. Moreover, a diffuse hypointense band was frequently found in AD subjects, but
not in controls. Both AD groups were scored higher than controls, but EOAD
subjects were more affected than LOAD subjects (Figure 2,3 first panel).
Correlation analysis showed that the diffuse hypointense band on MRI
correlated most with an increased band-shaped intensity in the iron and myelin
staining (Figure 3,4). The diffuse band showed less spatial correlation
with the Aβ, tau, microglia or astrocyte staining. Further analysis of the
myelin staining showed that the myelin architecture in layer IV of the frontal
cortex of non-demented control subjects was characterized by an organized
raster-like structure with myelin fibers transversing all cortical layers and intracortical
fibers running parallel to the cortical layers (Figure 5). In LOAD subjects
already more disorganization compared to non-demented controls was found,
noticeable as a less clear raster-like structure and less fibers transversing
all cortical layers. In EOAD subjects the myelin architecture was
completely changed compared to non-demented control; the myelin
architecture showed a messy, disorganized structure characterized by crowded
reticular fibers. Stereometric analysis of the fiber trajectories showed
significant differences between all three groups.
DISCUSSION
& CONCLUSION
Using MRI, we can clearly distinguish different subtypes of AD. These differences
in imaging phenotype distinguishes the EOAD from the LOAD patients,
which is mirrored in the histology and underlying pathology, mostly in
differences in myelin and iron organization. Clinically, it is increasingly
recognized that AD is a heterogeneous disease with multiple underlying
mechanistic causes. The roles of iron
and myelin integrity in the disease process are however poorly understood, and
SWI could play a crucial role in classifying subtypes of AD for further
mechanistic studies.
Acknowledgements
No acknowledgement found.References
1. van
Rooden, S., et al., Cerebral amyloidosis:
postmortem detection with human 7.0-T MR imaging system. Radiology, 2009. 253(3): p. 788-96.
2. Nabuurs,
R.J.A., et al., Detection of cortical
changes in Alzheimer's disease at ultra-high field MRI. In preparation.
3. Mendez,
M.F., Early-onset Alzheimer's disease:
nonamnestic subtypes and type 2 AD. Arch Med Res, 2012. 43(8): p. 677-85.
4. Cho,
H., et al., Amyloid deposition in early
onset versus late onset Alzheimer's disease. J Alzheimers Dis, 2013. 35(4): p. 813-21.
5. van
Rooden, S., et al., 7T T(2)*-weighted
magnetic resonance imaging reveals cortical phase differences between early-
and late-onset Alzheimer's disease. Neurobiol Aging, 2015. 36(1): p. 20-6.
6. Klein,
S., et al., elastix: a toolbox for
intensity-based medical image registration. IEEE Trans Med Imaging, 2010. 29(1): p. 196-205.
7. Popescu,
V., et al., What drives MRI-measured
cortical atrophy in multiple sclerosis? Mult Scler, 2015.