Synopsis
In this study the decoupling efficiency of in vivo 13C MRS measurements of glycogen levels was assessed. Due to SAR restrictions and surface coil
decoupling field inhomogeneity, this study showed that short TR coupled spectroscopy provides improved SNR and better defined spectral parameters for fitting, whereas
decoupled spectra reduces the number of averages in the same timeframe and runs
the risk of varying residual coupling constants across a large field of view with inhomogeneous B2
Background
13C MRS provides a well-validated method of measuring
invivo glycogen levels [1]
offering significant advantages over invasive techniques. However, sensitivity
is low due to low natural abundance of 13C (~1%) and gyromagnetic
ratio (~1/4 1H). This is overcome by acquiring from a large volume
using surface coils with many averages [2, 3].
1H decoupling increases sensitivity by collapsing
the coupled peak[3]. However, an
inhomogeneous field (B2) may leads to partial
decoupling with a residual coupling constant Jr = JΔω/γB2 [4]. Furthermore, increased
power leads to greater repetition times (TR) and reduced signal averaging. The
aim of this study was to explore these effects to optimize acquisition protocol
for invivo 13C glycogen
MRS.
Methods
A Philips Acheiva 3T system was used with a Pulseteq 13C
surface coil (glucose experiment – 12cm single loop, glycogen experiments – 8cm
single loop) with 1H quadrature decoupling. All spectra were phase
corrected and line broadened. Phantom data was fitted using AMARES
in jMRUI and Invivo spectra were
analysed using lsqcurvefit in Matlab
with coupled peaks defined as two Lorentzians of equal linewidth and amplitude,
and decoupled peaks as one Lorentzian.
Investigating Jr = JΔω/γB2: A 13C labelled glucose vial was used to
provide large SNR and uniform and 13C MRS acquired, first varying
the decoupling frequency (Δν) at constant power (fig 1), and then varying with broadband decoupling (1024datapoints,
7kHz bandwidth, TR ~3500ms, 48averages).
Decoupling
efficiency: A
1.4l natural abundance 200 mM glycogen phantom was used to calculate T1 from TR varying MRS (256 datapoints, bandwidth
= 8kHz, 2000 averages, TR = 56, 100, 200, 300 and 500ms). Fully recovered MRS
was then acquired non-decoupled (TR=300 ms, 2048datapoints, 2000averages,
time = 9:55) and under 3 decoupling regimes for comparison: (1) minimum
decoupling, same averages as non-decoupled (TR=400 ms, 1024 datapoints, 3 μT
WALTZ decoupling, 2000 averages, time =13:20) , (3) maximum decoupling, same
scan time as non-decoupled (TR=7083 ms, 1024 datapoints, 20μT WALTZ decoupling,
84 averages, time =10:09), and (4) a compromise between min and max decoupling,
same scan time as non-decoupled (TR=600ms, 1024 datapoints, 5μT narrow band
decoupling centred at glycogen, 1000 averages, time = 10:01).
Invivo
scanning: In order to test the feasibility of fitting
invivo coupled spectra, 3 consented subjects
were scanned with no decoupling at short TRs (300ms) over a 20 minute time
frame (4000 averages). Decoupled spectra were also acquired for: Subject 1 –
maximum broadband WALTZ decoupling, = 20 μT (TR = 5000ms, 248 averages); Subject 2
– medium broadband WALTZ decoupling, = 9 μT (TR = 2000ms, 600 averages); Subject 3
– low narrow band decoupling, = 5 μT (TR = 505ms, 2400 averages).
Results
Investigating Jr: Figure 1 and
2 shows residual J coupling at varying frequency and confirming the linear relationhsip , but showing that spectra
at varying were too complicated to fit. In larger samples
containing inhomogeneities the net spectra would consist
of a sum of these spectra.
Decoupling
efficiency: Glycogen
T1 was 45 ms, allowing full recovery at TR>225
ms. Figure 2 shows the glycogen fitting for each decoupling regime. In the case
of no decoupling, a coupling constant = 176 Hz was measured and the total SNR on the
fit was 3.23 (fig 2a). No peak was found for maximum decoupling (fig 2b). For
minimum decoupling multiple overlapping peaks were seen (fig 2c) and best fitting
was achieved using 6 peaks giving an overall SNR of 1.3. Finally, medium
decoupling gave a single peak (fig 2d)with SNR = 2.61
Invivo scanning: Non-decoupled spectra gave well resolved
glycogen peaks with average linewidth = 143
± 7 Hz and = 168 ± 3 Hz. The peak areas were 1.5 a.u, 1.1
a.u and 0.7 a.u. for subject 1, 2 and 3 respectively (fig 3) with an SNR of
2.2, 1.6 and 1.1. All decoupling methods produced spectra in the same
acquisition time where the glycogen peak could not be fitted due to low overall
SNR.
Conclusions
The factors explored in this study should
be considered for
invivo protocol.
Given that
invivo decoupling of the
liver relies on B
2 over a large FOV, field inhomogeneities will
give rise to varying B
2 appearing as a blurred peak, detrimentally
affecting fitting. T
1 of glycogen is very short which means that small
TRs should be used for high SNR, but decoupling prevents this
invivo due to increased SAR. Coupled
spectra also include more prior knowledge into peak fitting algorithms making fitting easier (equal
linewidth, amplitude and known coupling). Therefore we conclude that
decoupling is not optimum for measuring liver glycogen at 3T.
Acknowledgements
No acknowledgement found.References
1 Taylor, R., I. Magnusson, D.L. Rothman, G.W. Cline,
A. Caumo, C. Cobelli, and G.I. Shulman. Direct assessment of liver glycogen
storage by C-13 nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy and regulation of
glucose homeostasis after a mixed meal in normal subjects. Journal of Clinical Investigation, 1996, 97(1), 126-132;
2 Stephenson, M.C., E. Leverton,
E.Y.H. Khoo, P.S. M., L. Johansson, J.A. Lockton, E.J. W., P. Mansell, P.G.
Morris, and I.A. Macdonald. Variability in fasting lipid and glycogen contents
in hepatic and skeletal muscle tissue in subjects with and without type 2
diabetes: a 1H and 13C MRS study. NMR in Biomedicine, 2013, 26(1518 - 1526;
3 Bawden, S.J., M.C. Stephenson, E.
Ciampi, K. Hunter, L. Marciani, R.C. Spiller, G.P. Aithal, P.G. Morris, I.A.
Macdonald, and P.A. Gowland. A Low Calorie Morning Meal Prevents the Decline of
Hepatic Glycogen Stores: A Pilot invivo 13C
Magnetic Resonance Study. Food and
Function, 2014, 5(9), 2237 - 2242;
4 Ernst, R.R. Nuclear
Magnetic Double Resonance with an Incoherent Radio-Frequency Field. Journal of Chemical Physics, 1966,
45(10), 3845-&;