Deepti Upadhyay1, Uma Sharma1, Govind Makharia 2, Prasenjit Das3, Siddharth Datta Gupta3, and Naranamangalam R Jagannathan1
1Department of NMR & MRI Facility, All India Institute of Medical Sciences, New Delhi, India, 2Department of Gastroenterology and human Nutrition, All India Institute of Medical Sciences, New Delhi, India, 3Department of Pathology, All India Institute of Medical Sciences, New Delhi, India
Synopsis
This study illustrates the
potential of proton NMR based metabonomics in determining biomarkers for
assessing severity of villous abnormality in patients with celiac disease (CeD).
CeD patients with Grade 3c showed significantly higher concentration of
pyruvate, alanine and succinate compared to Grade 3b patients, suggesting more
impaired oxidative phosphorylation in Grade 3c compared to Grade 3b patients. Increased
acetoacetate in Grade 3c compared to Grade 3b patients indicated utilization of
ketone bodies by intestinal mucosa for energy generation. Higher level of creatine seen in Grade 3c
patients may probably be related to increased intestinal dysbiosis compared to
Grade 3b patients.Purpose
To
investigate the potential of proton (
1H) nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR)
spectroscopy in characterization of different Marsh Grades of villous atrophy
in intestinal mucosal biopsies of
patients with Celiac disease (CeD).
Methodology
Total
24 patients (mean age 28.3 ± 8.2 years) were recruited. An informed consent was
taken and the study was approved by Institute Ethics Committee. All patients
were treated according to standard regimen. Diagnosis of CeD was made on the
basis of European Society of Pediatric Gastroenterology Hepatology and
Nutrition which included combination of clinical manifestations, celiac
specific serological markers and histological abnormalities. Modified
Marsh-Oberhuber classification was used for histopathological evaluation of
biopsies. Grade 0 corresponded to normal histology, while Grade 1 referred to
increase of intraepithelial lymphocytes (IEL); Grade 2 corresponded to
increased IELs along with crypt hyperplasia. Grade 3 referred to increased IELs
along with crypt hyperplasia and variable degrees of villous atrophy. A further semi-quantitative sub-typing of the
villous atrophies was performed as follows: Grade 3a denoted mild villous
atrophy; Grade 3b denoted moderate villous atrophy while Grade 3c denoted total
villous atrophy. Of 24 patients, 4 were with Grade 3a, 8 with Grade 3b and 12
with Grade 3c. Small intestinal mucosal biopsies
(5-6 bits) were collected at the time of endoscopy and water soluble
metabolites were extracted using perchloric acid extraction. The resultant lyophilized
powder was dissolved in deuterium oxide and sodium trimethyl-silyl-[2, 2, 3,
3-H
4] was used as chemical shift reference.
1H one dimensional and two dimensional
total correlation spectroscopy NMR experiments were performed at 700 MHz
(Agilent, U.S.A.). Each 1D spectrum was integrated and intensities for various
peaks corresponding to different metabolites were determined using VnmrJ
software (Agilent, Technologies). Partial least squares-discriminant analysis
(PLS-DA) was performed on integrated intensities using Unscrambler 10.2 (CAMO
Software, Oslo, Norway).
Results &
Discussion
This
is the first study
B
to our knowledge that demonstrated differences
in metabolic profile of intestinal biopsy of CeD patients with different Marsh
Grades. Comparison of metabolic profile of Grade 3a patients could not be done
as number of patients was less. PLS-DA plot showed clear distinction between
CeD patients with Grade 3c and Grade 3b (Fig. 1). Statistical models from
PLS-DA analysis showed the cumulative explained variance of (R
2) of
0.95 and cross validated predictive fraction (Q
2) of 0.83. The
corresponding loading plot suggested that metabolites; alanine, pyruvate,
succinate, creatine and acetoacetate contributed for the distinct clustering of
the Grade 3c and Grade 3b patients (Fig. 2). The levels of these metabolites
were higher in CeD patients with Grade 3c compared to patients with Grade 3b. In
a previous study, significantly higher concentrations of isoleucine, leucine,
aspartate, succinate and pyruvate compared to controls were reported
1.
Abnormalities in glycolysis, Kreb’s cycle (energy deficiency) and amino acid
metabolism contributing to villous atrophy were suggested
1. Thus, higher
levels of several metabolites seen in Grade 3c patients compared to Grade 3b
indicated a relation between degree of severity of villous atrophy and
metabolic abnormalities. Higher levels of pyruvate seen in patients with Grade
3c compared to Grade 3b suggested more impairment in utilization of pyruvate
for energy generation. Further, raised alanine level suggested that pyruvate
may be converted to alanine by transamination in Grade 3c patients compared to
Grade 3b patients. Additionally, higher level of succinate in the Grade 3c
patients compared to Grade 3b patients further supported decreased oxidative
phosphorylation. Further our results showed higher level of acetoacetate in
Grade 3c patients compared to Grade 3b patients suggesting the use ketone bodies
as energy fuel. Since, the energy derived through oxidations of ketone bodies was
less compared to carbohydrate oxidation; the intestinal mucosa in Grade 3c
patients was more energy deprived compared to Grade 3b patients. The energy
produced from the oxidation of ketones may not be sufficient for rapid turnover
of enterocytes which is required to maintain normal villous length,
2 thereby leading to severe villous
atrophy as seen in Grade 3c patients. Moreover,
elevated level of creatine was observed in Grade 3c patients compared to Grade
3b. In general, creatine is degraded by
intestinal bacteria, thus, elevated creatine level may be because of reduced
bacterial degradation suggesting that imbalance of gut microflora was more
pronounced in Grade 3c patients. These
metabolic abnormalities may probably contribute to severe villous atrophy seen in
Grade3c patients.
Conclusion
Present NMR metabonomics study provides an insight into the
biochemical changes associated with the different mucosal histological grades. Metabolites
like pyruvate, alanine and succinate may have potential to serve as biomarker/s
for assessment of villous abnormality.
Acknowledgements
The
authors thank the Department of Biotechnology, Government of India for the
financial assistance.References
(1)
Sharma U, Upadhyay D, Mewar S et al. Metabolic abnormalities of
gastrointestinal mucosa in celiac disease: An in vitro proton nuclear magnetic
resonance spectroscopy study. J Gastroenterol Hepatol.2015;30(10):1492-1498; (2) Blachier F, Boutry C, Bos C, et al.
Metabolism and functions of L-glutamate in the epithelial cells of the small
and large intestines. Am J Clin Nutr. 2009;90(3):814S-821S.