Synopsis
Abnormal choline metabolism with increased levels of
phosphocholine (PC) driven by overexpression of choline kinase α is considered
a hallmark of cancer. For the first time, we show that glioma cells with the
IDH1 mutation reprogram choline metabolism differently. Using 13C-MRS
to quantify [1,2-13C]-choline flux to PC in IDH1 mutant cells from
two genetically engineered glioma models, we show that reduced PC synthesis is characteristic
of mutant IDH1 cells. Furthermore, reduced PC synthesis is driven by down-regulated
choline kinase α expression. Our study points to unusual reprogramming of
choline metabolism in IDH1 mutant glioma cells, pointing to novel therapeutic
opportunities. Introduction
Elevated phosphocholine (PC) levels and increased expression
of choline kinase, the enzyme catalyzing PC synthesis from choline, have been
reported in most types of cancer and are often considered hallmarks of the
disease
1. Interestingly however, in cells that express the
isocitrate dehydrogenase 1 (IDH1) mutation – a recently discovered driver
mutation in low-grade gliomas
2 – we and others have found that PC levels
are reduced when compared to IDH1 wild-type cells
3,4,5. The goal of
the current study was therefore to understand the underlying mechanism for the
drop in PC in IDH1 mutant cells. We used
13C-magnetic resonance
spectroscopy (MRS) to monitor the metabolism of [1,2-
13C]-choline
and quantify choline flux to PC in two genetically engineered glioma models
expressing wild-type or mutant IDH1. We also investigated the expression of choline
kinase and the ubiquitous choline transporter SLC44A1. Our results indicate
that PC synthesis is reduced in IDH1 mutant cells in both of our models, and
that this drop is associated with reduced expression of choline kinase α,
pointing to a unique pattern of metabolic reprogramming that is associated with
the IDH1 mutation.
Methods
U87
and NHA cell lines expressing IDH1 wild-type (U87IDHwt/NHAIDHwt) or mutant (U87IDHmut/NHAIDHmut)
enzyme were generated as described
3. Cells were cultured in DMEM with
10% fetal bovine serum. MRS studies were performed on a 600-MHz Bruker Avance spectrometer
using a broadband probe and an MR-compatible cell perfusion (bioreactor) system
6.
Cells were perfused for 48h with DMEM in which choline was replaced with [1,2-
13C]-choline
(56μM). Proton-decoupled
31P spectra were acquired using a 30° pulse,
3s relaxation delay and 1024 scans to confirm cell viability and quantify PC levels.
Proton-decoupled
13C spectra were acquired in 2h blocks using a 60° pulse,
6s relaxation delay and 2400 scans. Peak integrals were quantified using Mnova,
corrected for saturation and NOE and normalized to cell number and to a metabolite
of known concentration (1.59mM inorganic phosphate for
31P spectra
and 5mM 1-
13C-glucose for 13C spectra). Assuming that PC is
generated primarily by choline phosphorylation, the kinetics of PC build-up were
expected to follow the equation
13CPC(t)=A (1-e
-kt) where
13CPC represents
13C-labeled PC at time point t, A
represents the final
13C-labeled pool of PC and k is the
pseudo-first-order rate constant for choline kinase
7. GraphPad Prism
was used to fit the build-up of the
13C-labeled PC peaks as a
function of time. Enzyme expression was determined using western blotting for SLC44A1
(Abcam) and for choline kinase α and β (Sigma-Aldrich) with GAPDH (Cell
Signaling) as loading control. All experiments were performed in triplicate
(n=3) unless otherwise mentioned and significance assessed using an unpaired Student’s
t-test with p<0.05 considered significant.
Results
31P-MRS data (Fig. 1) was used to quantify total PC
levels (1.4±0.3 fmol/cell in NHAIDHwt, 0.5±0.2 fmol/cell in NHAIDHmut, 1.9±0.3
fmol/cell in U87IDHwt and 1.1±0.2 fmol/cell in U87IDHmut) confirming our
previous findings that PC levels were reduced in IDH1 mutant cells.
13C-MRS
of live cells perfused with [1,2-
13C]-choline showed simultaneous
build-up of two
13C-labeled PC doublets, corresponding to [1-
13C]-PC
and [2-
13C]-PC, over the course of 48h (Fig. 2A&2B). As
expected, the concentration of [1,2-
13C]-choline (56μM) was below detection.
Fig. 3A illustrates the kinetic fit to
13C-labeled PC build-up in the
NHA model, and the goodness of fit (R
2=0.94 for NHAIDHwt and R
2=0.87
for NHAIDHmut) confirmed that PC was generated primarily from exogenous
13C-labeled
choline. This was further confirmed by comparison of the steady-state
13C-labeled
PC pool (determined from the kinetic fit) to the total PC pool (determined from
the
31P spectra), which indicated that the two were within
experimental error (Fig. 3B&3C). Furthermore, the kinetic data indicated
that the pseudo-first-order rate constant for choline kinase was significantly reduced
by 49±11% (n=3, p<0.05) in NHAIDHmut cells relative to NHAIDHwt (Fig. 4A)
and by 39±9% (n=2) for U87IDHmut cells relative to U87IDHwt (Fig. 4B). Western
blotting showed a significant decrease in choline kinase α expression in IDH1
mutant cells compared to IDH1 wild-type (43±5%, p < 0.005 in the NHA model
and 29±10%, p<0.05 in the U87 model, Fig. 5A&5B), whereas choline kinase
β (Fig. 5C&5D) and choline transporter SLC44A1 (Fig. 5E&5F) were
comparable. Collectively, these results mechanistically link the MRS-detectable
reduction in PC levels to reduced choline-derived PC synthesis and decreased
expression of choline kinase α in IDH1 mutant cells.
Conclusions
Our MR findings and associated studies point to an unexpected
metabolic reprogramming in IDH1 mutant cells. Reduced PC synthesis mediated by down-regulated
choline kinase α expression provides a unique metabolic biomarker and potential
therapeutic target in IDH1 mutant glioma cells.
Acknowledgements
NIH R01CA172845, NIH R01CA154915, NIH R21CA161545 and UCSF
Brain Tumor Loglio Collective.References
1) Glunde et al., Nat Rev Cancer, 11:835-48, 2011. 2) Yang
et al., Clin Cancer Res, 18:5562-5571,
2012. 3) Izquierdo-Garcia et al., PLOS ONE, 10:e0118781, 2015. 4) Reitman et
al., PNAS,108:3270-3275, 2011. 5) Esmaeili et al., Cancer Research,
74:4898-4907, 2014. 6) Brandes et al. Breast Cancer Research 12, R84, 2010. 7) Ronen et al., Biochimica et
Biophysica Acta, 1095:5-16, 1991.