Corey Cruttenden1, Jennifer M. Taylor2, Xiao-Hong Zhu2, Yi Zhang2, Hannes M. Wiesner2, Anders Asp3, Erin Larson3, Wilson Yu3, Rajesh Rajamani1, Mark Thomas3, Esther Krook-Magnuson3, and Wei Chen2
1Mechanical Engineering, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, MN, United States, 2Center for Magnetic Resonance Research (CMRR), University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, MN, United States, 3Neuroscience, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, MN, United States
Synopsis
Carbon nanotube optrodes are under development for
simultaneous optogenetics, neural recording, and fMRI BOLD signal acquisition. First-generation
devices demonstrate capability in combining optogenetic stimulation and neural
recording in vivo, but in vitro MR-images reveal severe
susceptibility artifacts generated by terminal silver leads. New devices utilize
carbon fiber wires in place of silver. Initial in vitro images of the second-generation device show a
dramatic reduction of image artifacts, indicating that BOLD
signal should be obtainable around the optrodes. The new devices will enable the
combination of the aforementioned techniques, providing a platform for novel brain investigations.Motivation and
Introduction
There has been a recent push for neuroimaging technological
development to enhance our understanding of brain function. One approach is to
combine several modalities such as electrophysiology and functional MRI (fMRI) to
obtain simultaneous data with high temporal and spatial resolution, providing new
insights into brain mechanisms. We could further incorporate
targeted stimulation techniques such as optogenetics, and observe stimulus-induced
electrophysiological
responses and neuromodulation. However, there
are several technological challenges involved in merging techniques. For
example, placing a metallic neural recording electrode in the region of
interest would likely compromise fMRI due to severe susceptibility artifacts,
in particular, at high field.
Here we present carbon nanotube (CNT) optrodes that will
enable the simultaneous acquisition of local field potentials (LFP) and fMRI BOLD
signals in response to optogenetic stimulation. These devices can stimulate
photosensitive ion channels by transmitting light through a fiber optic core,
and subsequently record the LFP responses from a conductive CNT electrode on
their surface. Further, the materials used in probe fabrication introduce
minimal susceptibility artifacts in MR images, and therefore should enable
simultaneous, co-located fMRI mapping.
Methods
CNT optrodes were prepared by bonding polymer-clad optical
fibers into ceramic ferrules. The bonded devices were treated with a
layer-by-layer nanoscale assembly method to improve adhesion1. Multi-walled
CNTs were oxidized for dispersion in water1, and then drop cast onto
the devices. Terminal leads were attached and the CNT optrodes
were insulated with polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS). Finally, device tips were
polished for effective optical transmission.
In vitro imaging was
performed in a 9.4T Agilent animal scanner with a single loop RF surface
coil to examine magnetic susceptibility effects. CNT optrodes
were positioned in phantoms (agar 2% wt. in DI water) for scanning
with T1-weighted gradient echo (GEMS) and T2-weighted
fast spin echo (FSEMS) imaging sequences. Magnetic susceptibility effects were
quantified by comparing affected image hyper/hypo-intense
area to the true device cross-sectional area.
Tungsten optrodes were prepared for electrophysiology
comparison by bonding tungsten micro-wire electrodes to optical probes.
The protocol was similar to that of Armstrong et al.2.
Neural activity was recorded from a mouse expressing CaMKII-ChR2-EYFP.
The mouse was anesthetized and a CNT optrode was implanted in the nucleus
accumbens, with a tungsten optrode placed in contralateral
nucleus
accumbens for signal quality comparison. An optical stimulation
paradigm with ON and OFF epochs was delivered while electrical activity was
recorded at 30 kHz with a Cerebus neural recording system (Blackrock
Microsystems, UT). Data was post-processed with custom MATLAB code.
Results and Discussion
Our previous work to combine neural recording and fMRI in
rats (unpublished data) indicates that the BOLD signal can
be obtained around implanted CNT electrodes that do not introduce
significant susceptibility artifacts. In vitro
scans of our first-generation optrodes indicate minimal susceptibility
artifacts generated by all materials used except for silver terminal
connections (see Fig. 1). Although these artifacts would be located above the
skull, their severity could compromise the fMRI BOLD
signal. To overcome this issue, we are using carbon fiber wire bonded to the device with a conductive polymer interface of poly(3,4-ethylenedioxythiophene)-poly(styrenesulfonate)
(PEDOT:PSS) and epoxy for mechanical support. An example second-generation
optrode is presented in Fig. 2. As expected, in vitro scans of the carbon fiber wire (Fig. 3) indicate minimal
magnetic susceptibility issues3 compared to the silver wire. Whereas
a 649% increase in affected area was observed around the silver wire, a modest
55% increase was observed with the carbon wire, suggesting substantially less
field distortion. Based on our prior experience and the results of others3,4,
the second-generation optrodes should enable in vivo BOLD signal acquisition around the implanted devices.
Preliminary analysis of bilateral electrophysiology data indicates
similar signal quality between the CNT device and the tungsten control,
verifying the utility of the CNT optrode for neural recording. Spontaneous LFP activity
covering
the alpha (8-13 Hz), beta (14-25 Hz)5, and higher
frequency (25-500 Hz) bands under anesthesia is
presented in Fig. 4 for comparison.
Conclusions and Future Directions
Our prototype CNT optrodes are fabricated with atypical
materials that reduce susceptibility artifacts in MRI. Initial
in vitro scans and
in vivo neural recordings indicate the potential to combine fMRI,
electrophysiology, and optogenetics. While recently developed carbon fiber
optrodes were used to combine the aforementioned techniques
4, the use
of a conductive CNT coating directly on the optical fiber will enable us to
pattern multiple recording sites along a single optrode. Combining these
modalities will provide a platform to selectively excite or inhibit populations
of neurons and subsequently investigate brain function, functional and
effective connectivity, and neural-vascular coupling with excellent spatial and
temporal resolution.
Acknowledgements
This work is supported in part
by the Institute for Engineering in Medicine (IEM) Group Grant at the
University of Minnesota, the University of Minnesota MnDrive RSAM Initiative
Grant, the University of Minnesota MnDrive Brain
Conditions Initiative Grant, NIH grants RO1 NS057560, RO1
NS070839, R24 MH106049, P41 EB015894, P30 NS076408, R00 NS087110,
NSF grant
DGE-1069104, and the W.M. Keck Foundation.References
[1] Yu X, Rajamani R, Stelson K, and Cui T.
Active control of sound transmission through windows with carbon nanotube-based
transparent actuators. IEEE Trans. Control Syst. Technol. 2007;15(4):704-714.
[2] Armstrong C, Krook-Magnuson E, Oijala M, and
Soltesz I. Closed-loop optogenetic intervention in mice. Nat.
Protoc. 2013;8(8):1475-1493.
[3] Dunn JF, Tuor UI, Kmech J, et al. Functional Brain Mapping at 9.4T Using a New MRI-Compatible
Electrode Chronically Implanted in Rats. Magn. Reson. Med. 2009;61(1):222-228.
[4] Duffy BA, Choy M, Chuapoco MR, et al. MRI compatible optrodes for
simultaneous LFP and optogenetic fMRI investigation of seizure-like afterdischarges.
NeuroImage. 2015.
[5] Iaizzo PA, “Introduction to Neurophysiology” in Neural
Engineering. Ed. He B. Springer. 2013.