Beatriz Dionisio Parra1,2, Nicolas Hehn1, Xin Liu1,2, Matthew Middione3, Anne Menini1, Darius Burschka2, Florian Wiesinger1, and Ana Beatriz Solana1
1GE Global Research, Munich, Germany, 2TUM (Technical University Munich), Munich, Germany, 3GE Healthcare, California, CA, United States
Synopsis
Three novel fMRI pulse sequences are evaluated together with simultaneous EEG
acquisition, with the aim to reduce the induced EEG Gradient Artifacts (GA),
increase the spatio-temporal resolution of fMRI and reduce the acoustic noise during
scanning: sinusoidal GE- EPI,
multiband blipped-CAIPI and single shot T2-prep RUFIS.
Remarkable results were found for the T2-prep RUFIS
sequence, with a significantly reduced gradient artifact amplitude, high temporal resolution and low acoustic noise level, providing eminent advantages to this multimodal technique.
PURPOSE
Simultaneous EEG-fMRI
studies are mainly based on standard GE-EPI sequences, due to its high speed
and contrast sensitivity. However, alternative fMRI sequences with higher
temporal resolution, using multi-slice4, or reduced
acoustic noise, using minimal switching pulse sequences1,2,3 can
provide eminent advantages to this technique, improving the fMRI
spatio-temporal resolution, the EEG signal’s quality by reducing the gradient
induced artifact, and potentially the multimodal combination of EEG and BOLD signals.
In this work, three novel
fMRI pulse sequences are evaluated together with simultaneous EEG acquisition, with
the aim to reduce the induced EEG Gradient Artifacts (GA), the acoustic noise
during scanning and to increase the fMRI spatio-temporal resolution. These sequences are: a) a modified
GE-EPI with sinusoidal readout 1, b) a T2-prepared
RUFIS (Rotating Ultrafast Imaging Sequence) 3 and c)
a Multiband blipped CAIPI 4. Additionally, technical tests are performed in order to ensure
the instrumentation and patient safety 5.
METHODS
A spherical water phantom, with a 32-channels EEG BrainCap (Brainproducts, Munich, Germany), was
imaged in a 3.0T MR750w system (GE
Healthcare, Waukesha, WI), using a standard GE-EPI, followed by the three
proposed sequences.
The acquisition parameters for the GE-EPI and GE-EPI with
sinusoidal readout were as follows: FA = 90°; 3x3x3 mm full coverage with 40
slices, TR = 3000ms and TE = 30ms. For Multiband blipped-CAIPI only TR = 1500ms
was modified (with multiband factor = 2). Finally, singleshot smoothed
trajectory T2-prep RUFIS was run with the following parameters: FA = 3º, 3x3x3 mm, TET2prep = 80ms, 380 spokes per segment/shot, defining a
spiral trajectory in a 3D sphere and rotating 120º in each shot (TRshot = 1s).
Scan time for each sequence was 6 minutes.
Four different tests were performed in this study: 1) Specific Absorption
Rate (SAR) of each sequence was estimated over 6 seconds and 6 minutes
acquisition. 2) EEG electrode’s temperature was measured during
scanning using MR compatible and calibrated equipment with two fluoroptic
probes: one placed on Fz channel and the second monitoring the equilibrium
temperature as reference. 3) Induced gradient EEG artifacts (GA) were
analyzed off-line, comparing the artifact pattern and amplitude for every sequence using Brain Vision Analyzer 2.0. 4)
Acoustic noise measurements were performed with a Bruel and Kjaer Type 4189 calibrated microphone placed inside the
head coil. A-weighted average [LAeq dB(A)] and peak [Lpeak dB]
sound pressure levels were measured during 20 seconds for each sequence and ambient
noise.
RESULTS
1) Specific Absorption Rate: SAR measurements were similar for GE-EPI (avg=0,15 W/Kg;
peak=0,28 W/Kg ) , modified GE-EPI (avg=0,15 W/Kg ; peak=0,29 W/Kg ) and
multiband sequences (avg=0,17 W/Kg; peak=0,34 W/Kg). Slightly higher SAR
values were observed for the T2-prep RUFIS sequence (avg=0,26 W/Kg; peak=0,53
W/Kg), but still within safety limits.
2) EEG electrode’s temperature: Temperatures were considerably stable during all the
sequences, without observing significant increments during the 6 min acquisition. The highest temperature values
were found for the multiband blipped-CAIPI sequence (Tavg=15,22ºC ±
0,13ºC; Tpeak=15,53ºC), but remained below the manufacturer
recommended limits.
3) Induced gradient artifacts: Similar GA patterns were observed for the GE-EPI,
modified GE-EPI and multiband sequences, while T2-prep RUFIS showed a
smoother pattern with significantly reduced amplitude (>10 times minor with
respect to the GE-EPI induced GA). (Figure1)
4) Acoustic noise: Up to 121,2 dB were registered for the standard GE-EPI sequence, being
close to the human pain level (≈120 dB). Measurements during the multiband
sequence resulted in a similar outcome. The noise level was reduced in a mean
of 6,1 dB(A) for the sinusoidal GE-EPI, due to its flatter
gradient switching. Remarkable results were achieved for the T2-prep
RUFIS sequence, showing an overall noise reduction of 38,3 dB(A) with respect
the GE-EPI, which corresponds to only 6,1 dB(A) over the ambient noise inside
the scanner. All measurements are summarized in Figure 2.
DISCUSSION
This study guarantees the instrumentation and patient safety for
simultaneous EEG-fMRI acquisitions using three novel pulse sequences:
sinusoidal GE EPI, multiband blipped-CAIPI and single shot T2-prep RUFIS.
T2-prep RUFIS sequence revealed highly beneficial
characteristics for the multimodal technique, not only for the reduced gradient
artifact, which can significantly improve the EEG quality 6, but also
for high temporal resolution, achieved by applying advanced reconstruction techniques for volume
reconstruction per shot 2, and low acoustic noise level presented. Auditory,
resting-state and sleep studies can particularly benefit from this sequence. On
the other hand, multiband fMRI sequences can achieve higher temporal resolution
and high spatial resolution acquisitions with a whole brain coverage in ≈500ms,
providing a promising solution for a better interrelation of EEG and BOLD
signals.
Acknowledgements
No acknowledgement found.References
1. Schmitter,
S. et al. Silent echo-planar imaging for auditory FMRI. Magn. Reson.
Mater. Physics, Biol. Med. 21, 317–325 (2008).
2. Solana, A.B., et al. T2-prepared single-shot
RUFIS: A novel fMRI paradigm for silent and distortion free fMRI, OHBM (2015)
3. Solana, A. B., et al. Quiet and
distortion-free, whole brain BOLD fMRI using t 2 -prepared RUFIS. Magn. Reson. Med. (2015).
4. Setsompop,
K. et al. Blipped-controlled
aliasing in parallel imaging for simultaneous multislice echo planar imaging
with reduced g-factor penalty. Magn.
Reson. Med. 67,
1210–24 (2012).
5. BrainAmp
MR. Operating and Reference Manual for use in a MR environment. Version 016,
57-58 (2014).
6. Mullinger, K. J., et al. Improved
artifact correction for combined electroencephalography/functional MRI by means
of synchronization and use of vectorcardiogram recordings. J. Magn. Reson. Imaging 27, 607–616 (2008).