Mario Amend1, Tadashi Watabe2, André Thielcke1, Bernd J Pichler1, and Hans F Wehrl1
1Department of Preclinical Imaging and Radiopharmacy, Werner Siemens Imaging Center, Eberhard Karls University, Tuebingen, Germany, 2Department of Nuclear Medicine and Tracer Kinetics, Osaka University Graduate School of Medicine, Osaka, Japan
Synopsis
Functional and
metabolic processes during brain activity are still not fully understood. We
established a novel protocol to image rat brain activation in a single scanning
session, enabling optimal comparison of PET/fMRI data. Performing activation
and baseline scans in one single scanning session is challenging due to the
half-life (here [18F]FDG: 109.8 min) and decay time of PET-tracers. Applying
[18F]FDG-PET and BOLD-fMRI, spatial
and quantitative correlations but also mismatches between the glucose
proportional PET and the fMRI activation data were found. Our results provide
the basis for further studies of brain function and point towards the
complementary nature of PET/MR.Purpose
Combined PET/MR,
utilizing functional positron emission tomography (PET) and functional magnetic
resonance imaging (fMRI), is an ideal tool to study functional and metabolic
processes in the brain.
1 Here, we study rat brain function in
response to a barrel-field stimulus using simultaneously [
18F]FDG-PET, tracing changes in glucose metabolism,
and functional MRI (fMRI) using the blood oxygen level dependent (BOLD) effect,
assessing hemodynamic changes. A major criterion of preclinical brain
activation studies applying functional imaging is the exact correlation of
baseline and stimulation scans. Such a protocol could be also useful for human
studies.
2 The purpose of this study was to establish a novel protocol
to measure baseline as well as stimulation intervals using [
18F]FDG-PET
and BOLD-fMRI in one single scanning session. Thus, influences such as
anesthesia depth, animal condition etc. could be eliminated to prevent
confounding factors. Furthermore, the comparison of the results was expected to
indicate similarities and differences of both modalities depicting the
complementary nature of PET and fMRI.
Methods
PET/MRI was performed on a 7 T small animal scanner
with a 300 mT/m gradient system and a 2 x 2 rat brain receive coil combined with small
animal PET insert. Male lewis rats (n = 4, 352 ± 5 g) were anesthetized (20
mg/kg/h α-chloralose and 1 mg/kg/h Pancuroniumbromide i.v.) and body temperature
stabilized at 37.0 ± 0.5° C. During the measurements, animals were
artificially ventilated (60 1/min, regular air). Blood glucose levels were
measured before and after the scans. Besides anatomical images EPI BOLD sequences
(TE: 18 ms, TR: 2000 ms, Voxel size: 0.5×0.25×1.25 mm
3, FoV 32×32 mm,
slice thickness: 1 mm, 8 slices) were acquired. Simultaneously to an 80 min EPI BOLD
scan, rats were continuously infused with [
18F]FDG (dose
at infusion start 111 ± 7.4 mBq) i.v. and PET images
were recorded. Four electrical stimulation intervals (3 mA, 3 Hz) of the left
whisker pad were applied at 20-30 min, 40-45 min, 55-65 min and 75-80 min. Data
were analyzed using statistical parametric mapping (SPM12, GLM) and region of
interest analysis (PMOD).
Results
We found
spatial and quantitative correlations between the PET and the fMRI activation data.
According to a stimulation of the left whisker pad the fMRI analysis revealed
significant BOLD signal (p ≤ 0.05; T = 25.11) in the contralateral (cl) barrel-field
cortex S1BF. PET data showed also significant activation (p ≤ 0.05; T = 2.22)
and a spatial shift of the activation centre compared to BOLD data (Euclidean
distance = 2.48 mm). BOLD data revealed also ipsilateral S1BF activation in the
left hemisphere and PET data pointed out additional activation centres in the cerebellum
and cortical regions (
Fig. 1). The
PET time activity curve showed higher [
18F]FDG uptake (ca. 20%
increase of PET signal) in the contralateral S1BF compared to the control ROI (
Fig. 2). Presence of the BOLD effect
was confirmed before and after simultaneous PET/MR scans (
Fig. 3). Venous blood glucose levels showed no significant
difference pre and post [
18F]FDG-infusion (pre: 125.25 mg/dL, post:
101.25 mg/dL, p = 0.15) (
Fig. 4).
Discussion
Here, we report
a spatial correlation but also in some areas discrepancies between brain activation
measured by PET and BOLD-fMRI. The shift between peak activation centres of the
same region can be explained by the fact, that T2* BOLD-fMRI results rather from
the venous space, whereas [
18F]FDG uptake occurs mainly in cellular
areas. However, the additional regions observed in [
18F]FDG-PET
indicate a more complex mismatch between the two techniques, which could stem
from the complex nature of the BOLD-fMRI response as an interplay of complex
factors such as changes in oxygen consumption, blood flow and volume. Advantages
of this study compared to the data available so far are simultaneous PET and MR
scans as well as baseline and activation periods in one single scanning session.
Conclusion
To our
knowledge, this is the first small animal study reporting a novel animal scan
protocol to allow spatial and quantitative correlation of PET and fMRI
activation within one single scanning session. The established protocol has
clear evidence for the characterization of functional and metabolic changes
during brain activation on the basis of a stable experimental setup, since
baseline and activation measurements were conducted at the exact same conditions.
This paves the way also to studies using different metabolic tracers and is
ultimately transferable to clinical settings.
Acknowledgements
Supported by: University of Tuebingen, fortuene: 2209-0-0References
[1]: Wehrl HF et al., Nature Med.
2013
[2]
Villien et al., NeuroImage 2014