Juan D. Sánchez-Heredia1, Esben Søvsø Szocska Hansen2,3, Christoffer Laustsen2, Vitaliy Zhurbenko1, and Jan H. Ardenkjær-Larsen 1
1Department of Electrical Engineering, Technical University of Denmark, Kgs Lyngby, Denmark, 2MR Research Centre, Department of Clinical Medicine, Aarhus University, Aarhus, Denmark, 3Danish Diabetes Academy, Odense, Denmark
Synopsis
In this study we evaluate the different active decoupling
schemes that can be used to drive an Rx-only coil, in order to determine the
optimal design for 13C MRI at 3T. Three different circuit schemes
are studied: two known ones (with regular series and parallel tuning
respectively), and a novel one which we found to be optimal for this case. The
circuits have been cooled to 77K to reduce coil noise. Preliminary tests with
the preamplifier cooled to 77K for reduction of noise figure, are also reported.Purpose
Hyperpolarized Metabolic
13C MR has
attracted a lot of attention in the latest years, e.g. due to its potential to
be used for early indication of disease
1. The lower Larmor frequency
of
13C entails lower coupling to the sample, which leads to less
sample noise for physically small coils. This emphasizes the effect of losses
in the lumped elements used for tuning/matching/decoupling, which can easily
become dominant for coils with low resistance.
In this study we propose a new active decoupling
scheme which provides lower losses than traditional designs. A loop coil with
50 mm diameter (2.3 mm copper wire, L≈95 nH) is chosen as a detector, since it
is a convenient size as building block in coil arrays. The coils are connected to
a low input impedance preamplifier, which allows for coil decoupling schemes
when used in an array coil
2.
Methods
Fig. 1 depicts the three Rx-Only circuit schemes studied:
- Coil 1: series tuned coil with segmented tuning
capacitor, widely used because it allows preamp decoupling schemes.
- Coil 2: parallel tuned coil with two balanced matching capacitors, and an
active decoupling trap formed with one of the tuning capacitors.
- Coil 3: newly proposed parallel tuned coil with a balanced matching network, where
one of the matching capacitors is split and used to create a trap together with
the tuning capacitor (opening the loop at the test frequency). The non-split
matching capacitor is also used to create an additional trap which effectively
breaks the ground path of the loop and improves the decoupling.
The preamplifier (WanTCom
model WMA32C) has a nominal input impedance of 3 Ω and a measured noise figure (NF) at room-temperature
of 0.8 dB at 32.13 MHz. It is not rated for low temperatures.
Results
The three coils described above
were first simulated using CST. Capacitor losses are modelled using its
Equivalent Series Resistance (ESR). Capacitors from the CHB series (TEMEX
Ceramics, France) were used. We found that capacitors ranged between 22 and 470
pF had an ESR of about 20 mΩ, while capacitors of 1000 pF and higher had about
40 mΩ.
The coils were fabricated and characterized on the
bench. Then they were connected to a clinical scanner (GE Signa 3T), and images
at room temperature were taken using a spherical phantom with 30 mm diameter
and filled with
13C enriched bicarbonate. The results obtained are
summarized in the upper part of Table 1. The measurements agree very well with
the simulations, which shows that the model used for the capacitors is good and
that the losses in the circuitry are dominated by the ESR of the capacitors.
Also the SNR results obtained at the scanner are consistent, and show
proportionality to the Q-factor.
The effect of capacitor losses
is even more relevant if the coils are cooled. Simulations and bench measurements
with the coils cooled to 77K have been performed, and are shown in Table 1. In
this case, we considered for the simulations that the ESR of the capacitors was
reduced to half when cooled down to 77K, which showed good agreement with bench
measurements. Bench measurements with the preamp cooled to 77K show that, under some conditions, can provide a NF of 0.1 dB at the test
frequency.
Discussion
The results obtained show that for some MRI experiments at lower
frequencies, the decoupling circuit can have a very important effect on the
total losses. We found that, when the coil resistance is very low, the losses
of the resonator can easily be dominated by the ESR of the tuning capacitor[s].
In this case, it is advantageous to close the loop with only one capacitor, such
that the resistance added to the resonator is minimized. To prevent the loop from
short-circuiting the DC decoupling circuit, an extra matching capacitor needs
to be added, and used to create the tuned trap activated by the decoupling
signal. However, since this capacitor is already out of the resonator itself,
the current flowing through it is low. The results obtained here show that,
depending on the balance between loop, circuit and sample losses, adding
segmenting capacitors may be counterproductive in some cases.
Conclusion
A novel circuit scheme for receive-only RF coils is
proposed, which reduces significantly the coil losses for coils with very low
resistance. For
13C at 3T a 20% SNR improvement was obtained at room
temperature (compared to traditional schemes). At 77K the Q more than doubles
and the NF of the preamplifier reduces to 0.1 dB.
Acknowledgements
No acknowledgement found.References
1. Ardenkjær-Larsen, Jan H., et al. "Increase in
signal-to-noise ratio of> 10,000 times in liquid-state NMR." Proceedings
of the National Academy of Sciences 100.18 (2003): 10158-10163.
2. Roemer, Peter B., et al. "The NMR phased array." Magnetic
resonance in medicine 16.2 (1990): 192-225.