Michael Simonson1, Peng Wang2, Christopher Brace1,2,3, and Walter Block1,2,3
1Biomedical Engineering, UW - Madison, Madison, WI, United States, 2Radiology, UW - Madison, Madison, WI, United States, 3Medical Physics, UW - Madison, Madison, WI, United States
Synopsis
Monitoring microwave ablation with thermometry could extend
the application of this clinical procedure into territories where greater
control is necessary to protect healthy tissue, such as the spine. MRI
thermometry could also provide useful insights to generate and validate new thermal
models based on the fundamentally different mode of dielectric heating utilized
by microwave ablation. We present here a
platform consisting of 1) a high power MR compatible microwave ablation system
based on a FDA-approved design, 2) real-time applicator guidance during applicator
insertion and 3) high frame rate MR thermometry and tissue monitoring.Purpose:
Microwave thermal
ablation (MWA) has been experiencing rapid clinical adoption in cancer therapy
due to its advantages relative to RF ablation. 2,3
MWA can generally create larger lesions with less invasiveness and more control
than RF ablation as it generates heat based on a special case of dielectric
heating instead of electrical conductivity.
MWA applicator (probe) insertion has been predominantly guided by
ultrasound and the effects of its therapy have been monitored with limited
thermocouple measurements and occasionally intraoperative CT. As the models of thermal therapy delivery
have been largely developed using RF ablation, an opportunity exists for MRI
thermometry to provide the experimental basis for new models that account for
MWA’s fundamentally different method of heat generation. Therefore, we present a feasibility study of a
MR compatible MWA system based upon a FDA-approved commercial design with
real-time applicator guidance during insertion and high frame rate MR
thermometry.
Methods:
Proposed is a scheme to characterize
and demonstrate the use of Magnetic Resonance (MR) in imaging Microwave Thermal
Ablation (MWA). Generating tissue ablation is
achieved by using a MR-compatible microwave applicator modeled after the
Neuwave (Madison, WI) CertusPR clinical applicator but constructed
from copper components. The prototype applicator is consistent with power and
frequency of the clinically used Neuwave technology. 4,5 A 2.45 GHz microwave
generator (Cober Muegge LLC, CT) was used as the power source with the
MR-compatible applicator. Power was carried by a coaxial cable extended
approximately 3 m from the MR console room to the scanner. All experiments were
performed with excised bovine liver tissue and the applicator was inserted to
the tissue horizontally and parallel to the bulk magnetic field.
The MR imaging was performed on a GE
HDx 1.5 T scanner with 8-Ch cardiac coil (GE Healthcare, Waukesha, WI). A 3
minute time sequence of stacks of 2D T1-weighted spin echo images was first
used to monitor the ablation zone with each individual acquisition requiring 30
seconds. Imaging parameters include: 14 ms TE, 1150 ms TR, 1 mm slice thickness, 26
cm by 14 cm FOV, 192 x 192 matrix.
Real-time MRI was also utilized to
monitor the applicator’s insertion and then quantitatively map the ablation
zone temperature using the MR Proton Resonance Frequency (PRF) method. A 2D fast gradient-echo spiral imaging
sequence with 5 interleaves with the temporal resolution of 150 ms (TE = 13 ms,
TR = 30 ms, slice thickness = 5 mm, FOV = 32 cm, acquisition matrix = 140 x
140) provided on the RTHawk platform (HeartVista, CA) was used for both
purposes.
Results and Discussion:
The high-powered (85W) microwave
ablation system was able to quickly ablate a large teardrop-shaped zone.2,
3 Progression of this zone over a three minute ablation period can be
seen in Figure 1. Encouragingly, the T1-weighted SE images in Figure 1
correlate well with the gross ablation regions of approximately 28cc observed
via dissection in Figure 2.
Real-time imaging of over 6 frames
per second (fps) provides visualization of the insertion of the microwave
applicator was able to be tracked throughout insertion, as shown in Figure 3. Quantitative
thermal mapping of the formation of the ablation zone, also at over 6 fps, is
presented in Figure 4. Phase wrapping within the ablation zone can be observed
50-60 seconds after heating has started near the very hot center of the
ablation zone. The large temperature
increases possible with microwave ablation require more attention for an
accurate dynamic range of the temperature map.
Currently microwave ablation
applicators are guided with one modality while other modalities provide quite
limited monitoring capabilities during and after ablation. An MRI system outfitted with high
performance, real-time capabilities offers an opportunity to guide applicator
insertion and quantitatively map temperature in the same setting. The high PRF performance makes this an ideal
tool for generating insight to augment the limited models for predicting the
progression of microwave ablation zones today.
Conclusion:
We have demonstrated the feasibility
of a MR compatible microwave ablation system based on currently FDA approved
ablation technology. Our results demonstrate that rapid MRI guidance and
monitoring provides an opportunity to expand the applications of microwave
ablation into other body regions that require greater precision and
control. MRI also presents a capable
window for augmenting and validating future, more accurate models of microwave
ablation.
Acknowledgements
This
research is based on work supported by a Wisconsin State Economic Engagement
and Development Research Program grant. The authors would like to thank Miles
Olson and Jim White from UW-Madison Medical Physics for his contributions of
time and resource.References
[1] Dong J, Zhang L, Li W, et al. 1.0 T
open-configuration magnetic resonance-guided microwave ablation of pig livers
in real time. Scientific
Reports. 2015;5:13551.
[2] Chiang
J, Wang P, Brace CL. “Computational Modelling of Microwave Tumour Ablations.” International
journal of hyperthermia. 2013;29(4):308-317.
[3] Brace, Christopher L., et al.
"Pulmonary Thermal Ablation: Comparison of Radiofrequency and Microwave
Devices by Using Gross Pathologic and CT Findings in a Swine Model 1." Radiology 251.3;(2009): 705-711.
[4] “Certus
140 – 2.45 GHz Ablation System – Probe Specifications”. Neuwave Medical. ,
<http://www.neuwave.com/images/pdfs/Probe.pdf> Accessed on 1 Sept 2015.
[5] Bertram, John M. et al. “A Review of
Coaxial-Based Interstitial Antennas for Hepatic Microwave Ablation.” Critical
Reviews in Biomedical Engineering. 34(3); (2006). 187-213.