Devasuda Anblagan1,2, Maria C Valdés Hernández1, Stuart J Ritchie2,3, Benjamin S Aribisala1,2, Natalie A Royle1,2, Iona F Hamilton1, David A Dickie1, Susana Muńoz Maniega1, Mark E Bastin1,2, Ian J Deary2,3, and Joanna M Wardlaw1,2
1Centre for Clinical Brain Sciences, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh, United Kingdom, 2Centre for Cognitive Ageing and Cognitive Epidemiology, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh, United Kingdom, 3Department of Psychology, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh, United Kingdom
Synopsis
We tested whether there were coupled changes in
hippocampal volume, T1, MTR, FA and MD and three broad cognitive domains (Verbal
Memory, Working Memory, and Speed) in a large sample of community-dwelling
non-demented adults at 73 and 76 years of age. Hippocampal
volume, FA, MTR and T1 declined from age 73 to 76, while MD increased with age.
Higher baseline MD was correlated with steeper cognitive decline in all three
cognitive measures, but individuals with higher MD increases (i.e. more
apparent deterioration in tissue integrity) also tended to show increases in
Working Memory.Introduction
Aging
is associated with declining cognitive function in cross-sectional studies, but
few studies have tested for longitudinal change in hippocampal structure or
integrity. Cellular changes following aging, such as neuronal degeneration and
synaptic loss, can be investigated using quantitative MRI measurements such as
longitudinal relaxation time (T1), magnetization transfer ratio (MTR),
fractional anisotropy (FA) and mean diffusivity (MD). T1 is related to brain
tissue water content, while MTR measures the quantity of bound water protons
present in the brain tissue. FA and MD are scalar indices obtained from the
diffusion tensor (DT), with FA signifying the directionality dependence of
water molecules when subjected to cellular boundaries within a tissue, and MD representing
overall magnitude of water diffusion. MTR and FA are reduced and T1 and MD are increased
in many pathologies, attributed to demyelination. We tested whether there were
coupled changes in hippocampal volume, T1, MTR, FA and MD and three broad
cognitive domains (Verbal Memory, Working Memory, and Speed) in a large sample
of community-dwelling non-demented adults at 73 and 76 years of age.
Methods
A large cohort of human
participants from Lothian Birth Cohort 1936 completed tests of Verbal Memory
(WMS-III
UK Logical Memory and Verbal Paired Associates), Working
Memory (WMS-III
UK Spatial Span, WAIS-III
UK Digit Span
Backward and Letter-Number Sequencing) and Speed (WAIS-III
UK
Digit-Symbol Substitution, Symbol Search, and tests of Choice Reaction Time and
Inspection Time) at mean age 73 (n =
731) and 76 (n = 488) years
1. From this cohort, 655 underwent
brain MRI scans at age 73 years and 469 were scanned at age 76 years on a 1.5T
GE clinical scanner as described previously
2. Hippocampi were
segmented on T1-weighted volumes using an age-relevant template and FSL tools
plus manual editing. T1 maps were obtained from FSPGR sequences and MTR maps
from signal intensities with and without an MT pulse
2,3; these maps
were previously registered to T2-weighted volumes using FSL-FLIRT. DT-MRI data
were preprocessed using FSL (http://www.ndcn.ox.ac.uk/divisions/fmrib/),
constructing FA and MD maps. Hippocampal binary masks were mapped (Fig. 1) so
that median values of T1, MTR, FA and MD within the hippocampal masks were obtained.
As baseline hippocampal measures were
significantly correlated with multiple cognitive measures
4, we
used latent change score modeling to model cross-wave change in each of the
hippocampal measures alongside change in latent factors of Verbal Memory,
Working Memory, and Speed, each indicated by multiple cognitive scores.
Results
Hippocampal
volume declined from age 73 to 76 (
r =
−0.389,
p < 0.001), as did FA (weakly:
r = −0.057,
p < 0.001), and MTR (though non-significantly;
r = −0.173,
p = 0.113); MD increased with age (
r = 0.657,
p < 0.001),
although unexpectedly T1 showed significant age-related decline (
r = −0.216,
p < 0.001). We tested all associations between levels and
changes of the hippocampal measures and levels and changes of the three
cognitive measures. There were few correlations between baseline hippocampal
measures and cognitive change, with the exception of those shown in Fig. 2:
higher baseline MD was correlated with steeper cognitive decline in all three
factors. Unexpectedly, hippocampal MD showed (marginally significant) coupled
change with Working Memory, such that individuals with higher MD increases (i.e.
more apparent deterioration in tissue integrity) also tended to show increases
in Working Memory (
r = 0.178,
p = 0.041).
Conclusion
We found that hippocampal
integrity assessed using MD was significantly associated with all measures of
cognitive ability investigated here. The age related decline of T1 may result
from partially restored mechanisms of plasticity and altered hippocampal
neuronal ensembles
5, although inaccurate partial volume error on
small hippocampal structures is possible.
Acknowledgements
No acknowledgement found.References
[1]
Deary, I.J. (2007), BMC Geriatrics 7: 28; [2] Wardlaw, J.M. (2011), Int J Stroke 6(6): 547–559; [3] Armitage, P.A. (2007), MRI. 25(3): 303-310; [4] Aribisala, B.S.
(2014), Cortex 53: 34-44; [5] Burke, S.N (2006), Nat Rev Neurosci 7.1: 30-40.