Improved robustness of parallel imaging in 3D multi-slab diffusion imaging using an adapted FLEET approach
Wenchuan Wu1, Karla L Miller1, Benedikt A Poser2, and Peter J Koopmans1

1FMRIB, Nuffield Department of Clinical Neurosciences, University of Oxford, Oxford, United Kingdom, 2Maastricht Brain Imaging Center, Department of Cognitive Neuroscience, Maastricht University, Maastricht, Netherlands

Synopsis

In this work, we developed and evaluated a method for reducing motion sensitivity of auto-calibration data for parallel imaging in 3D MRI, with application to high-resolution diffusion imaging at ultra-high field. With the proposed Slice-FLEET method, we successfully achieve high resolution (1mm isotropic) diffusion MRI with high SNR and high b values.

Purpose

To develop and evaluate a method for reducing motion sensitivity of auto-calibration data for parallel imaging in 3D MRI, with application to high-resolution diffusion imaging at ultra-high field.

Introduction

3D multi-slab acquisition can achieve high isotropic-resolution DWI with optimal SNR efficiency1,2. Using single-shot EPI for each kz partition, 3D multi-slab DWI can be as fast as conventional 2D multi-slice DWI. In this case, in-plane parallel undersampling is necessary to reduce TE and T2* blurring, especially at ultra-high-field. GRAPPA auto-calibration data for EPI are typically acquired in a segmented manner for a matched echo spacing with the imaging scans, and it has been shown that GRAPPA reconstruction in 2D EPI is significantly improved by the recently proposed FLEET method3: all segments of a given slice are acquired in immediate succession to minimise motion and respiration induced phase corruptions between segments. It has also been shown that FLEET-like ACS acquisition improves reconstruction in single-slab 3D EPI4. We therefore expect that FLEET-ACS will also benefit GRAPPA reconstruction for 3D multi-slab EPI. In this work, we implemented several possible versions of FLEET for 3D multi-slab EPI DWI, to determine how to best acquire FLEET-ACS data. In vivo results show that “slice-by-slice FLEET” provides the best reconstruction compared with other methods, enabling high-SNR DWI at 1mm isotropic resolution with a high b value of 2000s/mm2.

Design and Implementation

Three possible FLEET-ACS schemes for use with 3D multi-slab imaging are depicted in Fig.1, along with the expected benefits of different approaches. These can broadly be characterised as: FLEET-like (exciting slabs aligned to the centre of the subsequent multi-slab imaging data with fully kz phase-encodes), slab-FLEET (FLEET-like without kz phase-encodes) and slice-FLEET (using 2D multi-slice acquisitions corresponding to all slices' locations in the imaging volume). Long acquisition times required by the FLEET-like method might undermine the goal of reduced motion sensitivity, and this option was not considered further.

We implemented and compared four methods for ACS acquisition: spin-echo single-shot (SSH) EPI, conventional spin-echo multi-shot (MSH) EPI, Slab-FLEET and Slice-FLEET. SSH and conventional MSH based methods excite the same slab as in imaging scan and one set of 2D ACS data was acquired for each slab. Slab-FLEET: for each image slab, the FLEET-ACS scan excites a slab aligned to the centre of the imaging data, but using a thinner-slab excitation to reduce signal loss due to intra-voxel de-phasing. Slice-FLEET: for each image slab, the FLEET-ACS scan acquires a set of ACS data for each slice. With thin-slice excitation, the intra-voxel de-phasing could be minimised and local coil sensitivity can be better captured.

Experimental Methods

Three healthy subjects were scanned on a Siemens 7T scanner with 32ch RX Nova coil. Scan parameters: FOV 210×210×117mm3, matrix size 204×204,14 slabs,10 slices/slab, slice thickness 1.03mm, 20% slab overlap, in-plane GRAPPA 3, partial Fourier 6/8, echo-spacing 0.82ms, BW 1442 Hz/pixel, TE/TR=71/2600ms, b=0,1000,2000 s/mm2. For SSH, conventional MSH and Slab-FLEET, GRAPPA kernels calibrated from ACS data were applied to all kz partitions. For Slice-FLEET, the GRAPPA kernel for each slice was calculated separately and a Fourier transform along kz was applied before GRAPPA reconstruction. We acquired Slab-FLEET ACS with different slab thicknesses (100%,50%,20%,10%), and Slice-FLEET ACS with 1× and 2× imaging slice thicknesses (relative to the final reconstructed 3D volume).

Results

Fig.2 compares GRAPPA reconstructions using different ACS-acquisition methods. SSH reconstructions show residual aliasing and strong noise amplification because the distortions are not matched. While the distortions are matched in the conventional MSH method, the phase error between in-plane segments can be large, leading to aliased reconstructions. Slab-FLEET improves on this, although the choice of slab-thickness is a problem: if it is thin (10%-20%) the performance at the boundary slices degrades, as the kernel does not capture the local coil sensitivities well enough. If a thick slab is used (50%-100%), stronger noise amplification can be seen, particularly in the DWI images (red ellipses). Slice-Fleet works well in all scenarios, with a slightly better performance for the 2x slice thickness version (boundary slice of the b=0 image). Fig.3 shows a DWI image at the slab centre (b=2000 s/mm2), also demonstrating the SNR improvement in Slice-FLEET over Slab-FLEET.

Discussion and conclusion

The SNR efficiency of 3D multi-slab DWI makes this method attractive, but data quality is easily compromised by poor-quality ACS data. We have adapted the FLEET-ACS approach for accelerated 3D multi-slab reconstruction, and demonstrate less residual artefacts and increased SNR compared to the typical ACS schemes. We find that slice-by-slice FLEET-ACS provides the highest SNR and lowest residual artefacts, as was here illustrated in application to high-resolution high-b-value 3D multi-slab diffusion imaging at 7T.

Acknowledgements

This work was supported by the Initial Training Network, HiMR, funded by the FP7 Marie Curie Actions of the European Commission (FP7-PEOPLE-2012-ITN-316716), and the Wellcome Trust.

References

[1] Engstrom M, Skare S. Diffusion-weighted 3D multislab echo planar imaging for high signal-to-noise ratio efficiency and isotropic image resolution. Magn Reson Med 2013;70:1507–1514.

[2] Frost R, Miller KL, Tijssen RH, Porter DA, Jezzard P. 3D multi-slab diffusion-weighted readout-segmented EPI with real-time cardiacreordered K-space acquisition. Magn Reson Med 2014;72:1565–1579.

[3] Polimeni, J. R., Bhat, H., Witzel, T., Benner, T., Feiweier, T., Inati, S. J., Renvall, V., Heberlein, K. and Wald, L. L. (2015), Reducing sensitivity losses due to respiration and motion in accelerated echo planar imaging by reordering the autocalibration data acquisition. Magn Reson Med. doi: 10.1002/mrm.25628

[4] Ivanov D, Barth M, Uludag K, Poser BA. Robust ACS acquisition for 3D echo planar imaging. In: Proceedings of the 23th Scientific Meeting, International Society for Magnetic Resonance in Medicine, Toronto, p 2059; 2015

Figures

Fig. 1. Illustration and comparison of different FLEET schemes for 3D multi-slab imaging.

Fig. 2. Comparison of GRAPPA reconstructions using different ACS acquisition methods. (a). b = 0 images (b). Diffusion-weighted images with b = 1000 s/mm2. In both figures, top row is a centre slice of one slab, bottom row is a boundary slice of the same slab.

Fig. 3 Comparison of GRAPPA reconstruction using Slab-FLEET with 50% slab thickness (left) and Slice-FLEET with 1X slice thickness (right). b = 2000s/mm2. Zoomed-in region specified by the yellow rectangle is shown on the top right corner.



Proc. Intl. Soc. Mag. Reson. Med. 24 (2016)
3224