Tim Klasen1, Carsten Höltke1, and Cornelius Faber1
1Department of Clinical Radiology, University of Münster, Münster, Germany
Synopsis
Heteronuclear
proton MRI is a recent method for MRI cell tracking and opens up the
possibility for Multicolor MRI when using different Ln-DOTMA complexes. Here,
we compare UTE and CSI as readout with regard to SNR efficiency, sensitivity
towards temperature changes and performance in separating resonance lines from
different Ln-DOTMA complexes at 9.4 T. UTE readout provides faster image
acquisition and higher SNR efficiency than CSI. CSI on the other hand is
insensitive to temperature changes. Multicolor MRI was possible with both
readout schemes. Further studies will use these methods for in vivo cell
tracking experiments.Introduction
Heteronuclear
proton MRI (also Highly Shifted Proton MRI) is a recent method for MRI cell
tracking [1]. Similar to fluorine MRI, direct detection of distinct cellular
populations can be realized using different Ln-DOTMA complexes to label cells.
DOTMA provides a NMR resonance line which is highly shifted, depending on the
lanthanide used, and can be separated from the water line (Fig. 1). The
detected DOTMA signal has extremely short relaxation times [2], which allows
for efficient signal amplification by paramagnetic relaxation enhancement, but
also requires ultra-fast readout such as ultrashort echo time (UTE) to avoid
relaxation losses. The method enables multicolor MRI, as resonance lines of
different Ln-DOTMA complexes are separated (Fig. 1). The chemical shifts of
these lines are sensitive against temperature changes [2], potentially causing
problems for UTE acquisition. An alternative readout is Chemical Shift Imaging
(CSI), also minimizing relaxation losses and enabling acquisition of different
Ln-DOTMA complexes in one scan for efficient multicolor MRI. Yet, longer TR as
compared to UTE reduces the SNR of CSI. Here, we compare UTE and CSI as readout
for Heteronuclear Proton MRI in terms of SNR, sensitivity towards temperature
changes and performance in separating resonance lines from different Ln-DOTMA
complexes.
Methods
MRI was performed
at 9.4T at constant temperature (21°C ). Ln-DOTMA complexes were dissolved in
pure water: Tm-DOTMA (Macrocyclics, Texas, USA) 10 mM and 50 mM, Tb-, and
Dy-DOTMA (synthesized in-house) 10 mM. The DOTMA methyl resonance was observed
at -45,+25,+30 kHz for Tm-,Tb-,Dy-DOTMA respectively, in accordance with [2].To
assess the SNR 2D and 3D experiments for both, UTE and CSI, were performed with
Gaussian excitation pulse with narrow bandwidth (EB: 2kHz) in order to excite
only methyl resonances of Tm-DOTMA (offset: -45kHz, 21°C ) and not water,
varying acquisition bandwidth (AB : 3.2–25kHz), minimum TR, Ernst angle
excitation and 400x400µm³ (4-mm slice)/781x781x781µm³ resolution.
Since
the chemical shift changes due to temperature changes are known [2], we
assessed the effects of temperature variation by keeping temperature constant
and simulating chemical shift changes by gradually shifting 1) the frequency of
the excitation pulse while leaving the acquisition window centered to Tm-DOTMA
peak, and 2) the acquisition window with on-resonant excitation of Tm-DOTMA. AB was 25kHz.
For
multicolor MRI, UTE was performed with narrow excitation pulses (2kHz) to excite
only one resonance. CSI used broad excitation pulses (6kHz) to excite both, Dy-
and Tb-DOTMA.
Results
Minimum
scan time was substantially different for CSI and UTE read out, 169s, versus
12s (for 20kHz AB) for a full 3D data set. CSI resulted in undistorted image
without artifacts for all acquired AB . SNR decreased exponentially with larger
AB. For UTE, SNR was strongly dependent on AB and reached a maximum at 20kHz,
almost four times higher than CSI. For AB below 10kHz, blurring artifacts were
observed in UTE images (Fig. 2).
Since
narrow excitation pulses were used for both UTE and CSI, temperature shifts may
result in incomplete excitation. This effect was mimicked by shifting the
excitation frequency at constant temperature. For both CSI and UTE, this
resulted in a sensitivity profile reflecting the pulse shape, and for UTE resulting
in 20% SNR loss for a shift corresponding to ± 3°C (Fig. 3A). For UTE
temperature changes had a second effect: Shifting the resonance away from the
center of the acquisition window, which we mimicked by shifting the acquisition
window, resulted in increasing artifacts. A 20 % SNR loss was observed at a
frequency shift corresponding to ±5°C (Fig. 3B) Frequency offset in the acquisition
window had no effects on CSI.
Multicolor
MRI was possible with both readout schemes. Dy- and Tb-DOTMA could be separated
in both CSI (Fig. 4) and UTE (Fig. 5). SNR of Dy-/Tb-DOTMA was 16.8/10.5 for
UTE and 8.0/6.6 for CSI.
Conclusions
For
heteronuclear proton MRI, UTE readout provides faster image acquisition and
higher SNR than CSI. Even for multicolor MRI measurements with different
Ln-ions, two separate UTE acquisitions provide higher SNR than a single CSI
measurement for Tm- and Dy-DOTMA. For Tb-DOTMA similar SNR efficiencies were
observed. However, UTE is prone to temperature shift-induced artifacts, which
may occur due to high duty cycle of the MR sequence. CSI on the other hand is
insensitive to temperature changes because broad excitation pulses can be used,
which do not compromise the ability to separate resonance lines in CSI. For
future in vivo cell tracking measurements, however, temperature effects appear
less important, since the body temperature of the subject counteracts potential
MR-induced warming.
Acknowledgements
No acknowledgement found.References
1. Schmidt R, Nippe N, Strobel K, et al. Highly shifted proton MR imaging: cell tracking by using direct detection of paramagnetic compounds. Radiology 2014;272(3):785-795
2. Hekmatyar SK, Hopewell P, Pakin SK, et al. Noninvasive MR
Thermometry Using ParamagneticLanthanide Complexes of
1,4,7,10-Tetraazacyclodoecane-α,α',α'',α'''-tetramethyl-1,4,7,10-tetraacetic
acid (DOTMA4–). Magnetic Resonance in Medicine 2005;53(2):294-303