Synopsis
The
inclusion of a dipolar reservoir in the existing two pool model for MT allowed interpreting
the inhomogeneous MT (ihMT) signal as a dipolar order effect -characterized by
a relaxation time T1D - within
motion restricted molecules.
In
this study, we demonstrate that an ihMT signal can actually be evidenced in any
component with non-trivial T1D
value. Adjustment of the dual frequency irradiation efficiency by increase of Δt, the repetition rate of
consecutive saturation pulses, filters the signal of shorter T1D components.
This provides a means to realize T1D-weighted
imaging, a new source of MR contrast between tissues.Purpose
To use inhomogeneous Magnetization Transfer (ihMT) to realize dipolar relaxation time (
T1D) weighted imaging, a new MR contrast.
Introduction
The
inclusion of a dipolar reservoir in the existing two pool model for MT allowed interpreting
the inhomogeneous MT (ihMT) signal as a dipolar order effect - characterized by
a relaxation time
T1D - within
motion restricted molecules
1. Comparing saturation of dual frequency
irradiation (MT
+- image), with the less efficient saturation of
single frequency irradiation (MT
+ image) allowed revealing dipolar
order effect in tissues that have a nonzero
T1D. The large fraction of the semi-solid, bound magnetization with
long
T1D values was
responsible for the higher ihMT signal obtained in myelinated structures
1
and hence for the apparent specificity of ihMT for myelin
2,3. In
this study, we demonstrate that an ihMT signal can actually be evidenced in any
component with non-trivial
T1D
value. Adjustment of the dual frequency irradiation efficiency by increase of Δt, the repetition rate of
consecutive pulses, filters the signal of shorter
T1D components.
This provides a means to realize
T1D-weighted
imaging, a new source of MR contrast between tissues.
Materials and Methods
IhMT experiments were
performed at 11.75T (vertical MR system, Bruker, AV 500WB, transmit/receive
volume coil: ∅
2cm, length 3cm) on hair conditioner (containing lamellar liquid crystal
structures
4,
LLC),
agarose (
agar 2% and 4%), and
in vivo, on
mouse (n=4, temperature 37±1°C). A 2D single-slice single-shot
RARE sequence (TR/TE=3.4s/1.82ms, slice thickness=1mm, FOV=25x25 mm and mtx=64x64)
combined with a pulsed ihMT preparation
3 was used. Single frequency
irradiation (Fig. 1a) was realized with a long train of Hann-shaped RF pulses
(length,
PW, frequency
f=+8kHz for MT
+ image,
f=-8kHz for MT
- image), repeated every
Δt for a total saturation time
τ, overall depositing a total energy
of saturation
ETR.
Pulsed-dual frequency irradiation (MT
+- image) at identical
ETR value and achieved by alternating
the frequency offset every other pulse from
+8kHz
to
–8kHz (Fig. 1b) was used for LLC,
agar
and mouse experiments. Additionally,
a strategy using cosine-modulated Hann-shape pulses for dual-frequency
irradiation (Fig. 1c) was also tested
in vivo.
Values of saturation parameters are reported in table 1.
IhMTR
values, defined as the ihMT signal (MT
++MT
--2MT
+-)
divided by the unsaturated M
0 image, were measured in LLC, agar and in brain internal capsule white
matter (
IC), cortical gray matter (
GM) and muscle area (
Mu). The contrast between IC and GM and
between IC and Mu was evaluated by measuring the ratio of their ihMTR values.
Results
Different intensities of ihMTR and changes with
Δt were obtained in LLC (
T1DLLC~270ms,
measured using the model developed in (1)) and agar2% (
T1Dagar2%~2.3ms) and 4% (
T1Dagar4%~2.6ms)
(Fig. 2). High ihMTR values in LLC
(ihMTR
LLC=31.5%,
Δt=1.3ms) were only little
affected by
Δt increase (ihMTR
LLC=28.5%,
Δt=6.3ms), whereas low agar ihMTR values obtained for
Δt=1.3ms (ihMTR
agar2%=1.25%, ihMTR
agar4%=1.85%) were
divided by almost two for
Δt=3.3ms (ihMTR
agar2%=0.65%,
ihMTR
agar4%=0.95%) and tended toward zero for
Δt=5.3ms (ihMTR
agar2%<0.4%, ihMTR
agar4%<0.6%).
In vivo pulsed dual-saturation results
show an increase
of ihMTR with decreasing
Δt in all structures. For
instance, for
Δt decreasing from 3.3ms to 1.3ms, the relative ihMT
signal increase was similar in IC and GM (~+20%)
due
to close
T1D values (
T1DIC=5.9ms,
T1DGM=5.2ms) and
was greater in Mu (+55%,
T1DMu=2.1ms). This resulted in a constant IC/GM contrast but a loss of IC/Mu contrast with
decreasing
Δt
(Fig.
3, left, plots and images).
Compared
to pulsed-dual saturation, the use of cosine-modulated pulses allowed quasi-instantaneous dual
saturation. This led to significant and
Δt-independent increase of ihMTR values in all structures: +22% in IC
(ihMTR
IC~6% vs 4.8%), +30% in GM (ihMTR
GM~3.5% vs 2.7%)
and +65% in Mu (ihMTR
Mu~3% vs 1.8%).
This
signal increase was however accompanied by important loss of IC/Mu contrast
(-60%) (Fig. 3 right, plots and images),
consistent with minimal
T1D-weighting.
Discussion
For pulsed-dual saturation, increasing
Δt filters the ihMT signal
of shorter
T1D components
(e.g. agar) with little effect on the signal of long
T1D components (e.g. LLC). This filtering strategy
allowed performing
T1D-weighted
imaging, which can be used
in vivo to
enhance the specificity of ihMT and reinforce its contrast for
longer
T1D tissue. Hence,
ihMTR maps at
Δt=3.3ms showed high specificity
for WM (
T1DMu<Δt<T1DWM)
compared to that at
Δt=1.3ms (
Δt <T1DMu<T1DWM), however, at the cost of a slight decrease in sensitivity (ihMTR
IC=4.7%
for
Δt=1.3ms vs 4.0% for
Δt=3.3ms). Conversely, short
T1D component (e.g. Mu) ihMT signal can
be revealed using faster dual saturation approaches such as cosine-modulated
pulses. This strategy could enable the study of ihMT
in other tissues than brain.
Conclusion
T1D-weighted imaging, a new source of
MR contrast between tissues, can be realized with ihMT.
Acknowledgements
Support from the A*MIDEX
grant (n°ANR-11-IDEX-0001-02) funded by the French Government
"Investissements d'Avenir" programReferences
1. Varma G, et al. J. Magn. Reson. 2015;260:67–76.
2. Varma G, et al.
Magn.
Reson. Med. 2015;73:614–622.
3. Girard OM, et al.
Magn. Reson. Med. 2015;73:2111–2121
4. Malyarenko DI, et al. Magn. Reson. Med. 2014;72:1427–1434