Synopsis
Conjoint relaxation and
susceptibility tensor imaging (CRSTI) uses both magnitude- and phase-derived
tensor data to compute susceptibility-based tractography in magnetically anisotropic tissues. CRSTI reduces image
artifacts that appear in traditional susceptibility tensor imaging by taking
advantage of mutual eigenvector data in relaxation and susceptibility tensors. We
present an efficient conjoint tensor estimation algorithm and demonstrate improved
susceptibility-based tractography in myofibers, renal tubules, and axon fiber
bundles. As susceptibility imaging is sensitive to both microstructure and
cellular content, CRSTI is a potential tool for studying disease in tissues
throughout the body.Purpose
Susceptibility tensor imaging (STI) can probe tissue
microstructure and cellular content
1,2,
but is limited by incomplete or incorrect phase information. As a result, STI noticeably
differs from DTI when used to map fiber orientations in the brain
3
and heart
4. By including R
2*
information, one study showed that these differences can be mitigated to
improve susceptibility-based fiber tractography in the heart using conjoint relaxation
and susceptibility tensor imaging (CRSTI)
4. This work presents a fast
and effective CRSTI algorithm that improves STI tractography in not only the
heart, but also the kidney and brain.
Methods
Organ specimens were excised from adult, male C57BL/6 mice. One
mouse was perfusion fixed with 50 mM Gd-HP-DO3A in 10% buffered formalin4. The chambers of the heart
were then perfused with agarose gel that solidified before the organ was
excised. A second mouse was perfusion fixed with 10% buffered formalin5. The kidney was excised and
immersed in formalin overnight. A third mouse was perfusion fixed with 50 mM of
Gd-HP-DO3A in 10% buffered
formalin following a procedure described by
Johnson et al.6 The head was removed with the
brain intact and immersed in formalin overnight. All three specimens were
stored in a solution of 2.5 mM Gd-HP-DO3A in 10 mM phosphate-buffered saline
prior to scanning. MRI data was acquired from each organ using
the protocols in Table 1.
Normalized phase data were
calculated from the multi-orientation GRE image data using iHARPERELLA7. Susceptibility and
relaxation tensors were calculated using MATLAB’s LSQR algorithm with
mean-value regularization8 and constraints on high
spatial frequencies3.
The susceptibility tensor ($$${\bfχ}$$$) was
reconstructed by inverting the susceptibility-phase relationship2. A second-order relaxation
tensor ($$${\bf R}$$$) was fit to the apparent R2*
observed in each subject orientation4. R2* is smallest in
the direction parallel to the long axis of axons9,
myofibers4, and renal tubules, so the
orientation of these structures is indicated by the minor eigenvector of $$${\bf R}$$$. In $$${\bfχ}$$$, orientation is indicated by the major eigenvector in myofibers
and axon fiber bundles2,10,
and by the minor eigenvector in the renal tubules5. To estimate a set of shared
eigenvectors ($$${\bf Q}$$$), a CRSTI algorithm was
implemented to eigendecompose a weighted combination of $$${\bfχ}$$$ and $$${\bf R}$$$: $${\ttν{\bfχ}–{\bf R}={\bf Q}(ν{\bfΛ_χ}–{\bfΛ_R}){\bf Q}^T}$$ Here, ν (Hz) attempts to assign equal weight to the susceptibility and relaxation tensors, and $$${\bfΛ_χ}$$$ and $$${\bfΛ_R}$$$ are diagonal matrices of the eigenvalues of $$${\bfχ}$$$ and $$${\bf R}$$$, respectively. Relaxation is defined as –$$${\bf R}$$$, and the sign of ν is selected to ensure that the major eigenvector of $$${\bf Q}$$$ aligns with the tissue structure orientation. Tractography was then performed on the STI, CRSTI, and DTI data using Diffusion Toolkit and TrackVis11.
Results
The proposed CRSTI algorithm improved susceptibility-based
tractography in each organ. As similarly demonstrated in an earlier study
4, the mouse heart tractography
data (Fig. 1) show that CRSTI fiber orientations are more consistent with DTI compared
to traditional STI. In the kidney tractography data (Fig. 2), CRSTI yielded improvements over STI
that were most obvious in the medullary regions, where susceptibility and
diffusion anisotropy were greatest. STI tractography exhibited the greatest
differences from DTI in the mouse brain (Fig. 3). CRSTI corrected the
orientation and improved the continuity of axon fiber tracts throughout the white matter regions of the brain, particularly in the corpus callosum, cerebellum, and anterior commissure.
Discussion and Conclusion
CRSTI is able to compensate for inadequate phase information by including eigenvector data from $$${\bf R}$$$4. This is possible because R2* in a set of parallel cylinders is positively correlated with the magnetic susceptibility difference between the objects and the surrounding medium12. Hence, the anisotropy of $$${\bfχ}$$$ engenders anisotropy in $$${\bf R}$$$13, and the two tensors share an eigenvector corresponding to the orientation of the cylindrical tissue structure. Though not necessary for CRSTI, contrast agents can also be used to enhance the inherently anisotropic component of $$${\bf R}$$$ in organs with capillaries that align with the tissue structure14, such as the heart15 and kidney16.
Susceptibility-based tensor mapping is useful for studying the organized molecular sources of susceptibility contrast and anisotropy in the heart, kidney, and brain. This technique is made more robust by conjoint tensor estimation, which requires no additional scan time since phase and relaxation data can be acquired simultaneously. By simplifying the shared eigenvector optimization problem4, this particular CRSTI algorithm requires very little computational overhead. The efficiency and chemical sensitivity of this technique make CRSTI a potential tool for studying disease in a variety of magnetically anisotropic tissues throughout the body.
Acknowledgements
The authors wish to thank G. Allan Johnson, PhD, Gary Cofer,
MS, and Yi Qi, MD, for their assistance in this study. All imaging was performed at the Center for In
Vivo Microscopy of Duke University This work was supported in part by the
National Institutes of Health through NIBIB P41 EB015897, T32 EB001040, NIMH
R01 MH096979, Office of the Director 1S10ODO10683-01, and NHLBI R21 HL122759,
and by the National Multiple Sclerosis Society through grant RG4723.References
1. Xie L, Dibb R, Gurley SB, Liu C,
Johnson GA. Susceptibility tensor imaging reveals reduced anisotropy in renal
nephropathy. 2015; Proceedings of the 23nd Annual ISMRM, Toronto, Canada. p
463.
2. Liu C.
Susceptibility tensor imaging. Magn Reson Med 2010;63(6):1471-1477.
3. Liu C,
Li W, Wu B, Jiang Y, Johnson GA. 3D fiber tractography with susceptibility
tensor imaging. Neuroimage 2012;59(2):1290-1298.
4. Dibb
R, Liu C. Whole-heart myofiber tractography derived from conjoint relaxation
and susceptibility tensor imaging. 2015; Proceedings of the 23nd Annual ISMRM,
Toronto, Canada. p 287.
5. Xie L,
Dibb R, Cofer GP, Li W, Nicholls PJ, Johnson GA, Liu C. Susceptibility tensor
imaging of the kidney and its microstructural underpinnings. Magn Reson Med
2014;73(3):1270-1281.
6. Johnson
GA, Cofer GP, Gewalt SL, Hedlund LW. Morphologic phenotyping with MR
microscopy: the visible mouse. Radiology 2002;222(3):789-793.
7. Li W,
Wu B, Liu C. iHARPERELLA: and improved method for integrated 3D phase
unwrapping and background phase removal. 2015; Proceedings of the 23nd Annual
ISMRM, Toronto, Canada. p 3313.
8. Li X,
van Zijl PCM. Mean magnetic susceptibility regularized susceptibility tensor
imaging (MMSR-STI) for estimating orientations of white matter fibers in human
brain. Magnetic Resonance in Medicine 2014;72(3):610-619.
9. Cherubini
A, Peran P, Hagberg GE, Varsi AE, Luccichenti G, Caltagirone C, Sabatini U,
Spalletta G. Characterization of white matter fiber bundles with T2*
relaxometry and diffusion tensor imaging. Magn Reson Med 2009;61(5):1066-1072.
10. Dibb R,
Xie L, Liu C. Magnetic susceptibility anisotropy of the myocardium. 2014;
Proceedings of the 22nd Annual ISMRM, Milan, Italy. p 627.
11. Wang R,
Benner T, Sorensen AG, Weeden VJ. Diffusion Toolkit: A Software Package for
Diffusion Imaging Data Processing and Tractography 2007; Proceedings of the
15th Annual ISMRM, Berlin, Germany. p 3720.
12. Yablonskiy
DA, Haacke EM. Theory of NMR signal behavior in magnetically inhomogeneous
tissues: the static dephasing regime. Magn Reson Med 1994;32(6):749-763.
13. Lee J,
van Gelderen P, Kuo LW, Merkle H, Silva AC, Duyn JH. T2*-based fiber
orientation mapping. Neuroimage 2011;57(1):225-234.
14. Vignaud
A, Rodriguez I, Ennis DB, DeSilva R, Kellman P, Taylor J, Bennett E, Wen H.
Detection of myocardial capillary orientation with intravascular iron-oxide
nanoparticles in spin-echo MRI. Magn Reson Med 2006;55(4):725-730.
15. Greenbaum
RA, Ho SY, Gibson DG, Becker AE, Anderson RH. Left ventricular fibre
architecture in man. British heart journal 1981;45(3):248-263.
16. Hook
JB. Toxicology of the kidney: Raven Press; 1981.