Amy McDowell1, Natalia Petrova1, Irene Vavasour2, David Thomas3, Daniele Carassiti1, Marc Miquel4, Shannon Kolind2, and Klaus Schmierer1,5
1Neuroscience and Trauma, Queen Mary University of London, London, United Kingdom, 2University of British Columbia, Division of Neurology, Department of Medicine, Vancouver, BC, Canada, 3Neuroimaging Analysis Centre, Department of Brain Repair and Rehabilitation, London, United Kingdom, 4Clinical Physics, Barts Health Trust, London, United Kingdom, 5Department of Neurology, Barts Health Trust, London, United Kingdom
Synopsis
Evidence obtained from post mortem
multiple sclerosis (MS) brain suggest that ‘myelin water fraction’ (MWF)
acquired using the CPMG sequence is strongly associated with myelin. However, relaxation times differ
significantly between brain and spinal cord (SC), a key area of the clinical
manifestations of MS. We investigated the histological correlates of MWF in post mortem MSSC. Good separation of the
short T2 components, and correlation between MWF and myelin content
detected using immunohistochemistry were observed.Purpose:
Myelin water imaging using a 32-echo Carr-Purcell-Meiboom-Gill (CPMG) spin-echo
sequence involves the separation of the signal from different water
environments within a voxel based on their transverse relaxation times. We
aimed to validate myelin water fraction (MWF) maps derived from this technique
using formalin-fixed
post mortem
spinal cord of people with MS (pwMS) and healthy control cord in order to compare
MWF with corresponding histological indices of myelination.
Introduction:
An accurate MR measure of myelin in multiple sclerosis (MS) has long
been sought and would be valuable in disease monitoring and evaluation of
disease modifying therapies. Commonly used MR indices of spinal cord damage
such as cord volume may underestimate the true degree of pathological changes
significantly [1]. Myelin water imaging was first demonstrated in human brain
in vivo by MacKay et al. [2], and analysed using a non-negative least-squares (NNLS) algorithm. Subsequently,
MWF obtained from T
2 decay curve studies in fixed
post mortem brain was found to scale
with optical density of Luxol fast blue, suggesting MWF may be a useful measure
of myelination
in vivo [3]. However, other parts of the CNS significantly affected by MS, such as
the spinal cord, have not been investigated.
Methods:
Three formalin fixed spinal cords from
pwMS (1 male, 2 female; age 67-87 years; disease duration 8-44 years; duration
of fixation 995-1309 days) and one control (male; age 89; duration of fixation
1320 days) were dissected into 10 cm samples and placed into universal tubes (diameter:
1.5cm). MS spinal cords were imaged on a 3T Philips Achieva using a 3D CPMG
sequence (32 echoes, TE n × 10.26ms, TR 1000ms, 0.6×0.6×2mm3 matrix,
20 slices). The control cord was imaged using parameters 32 echoes, TE n × 10ms, TR 3000ms, 0.6×0.6×2mm3 matrix, 21 slices). MWF water maps were
calculated using the NNLS algorithm with stimulated echo correction [4], using bounds of 5 – 30ms for short T
2
and 30 – 300ms for intermediate T
2 values. Cords were dissected into blocks of 5mm thickness, processed for
embedding in paraffin, and sections stained for Myelin Basic Protein (MBP). Focal
areas of complete myelin loss were identified as demyelinated lesions in the
white (WML) and grey matter (GML).
Results:
Figure 1B shows an example curve of the signal decay in one pixel as a
function of the echo time. Although the distribution of T
2 showed
shortened values relative to previous
in vivo
studies (short T
2, 10 – 30ms, intermediate T
2, 70 –
1000ms [3]), the two components considered to be associated with myelin and
intra/extracellular water are resolved (Fig 1C). Figure 2 shows matched MBP
stained histological sections, T
2-weighted MR images from the first
echo and MWF maps.
Good visual match was achieved between MBP stained sections and myelin
water maps. MRI-derived MWF values are shown in Figure 3. Average values in the
white and grey matter of the control cord were 41.9±3.8% and 17.9±2.6%
respectively. However, myelin values in the lesional areas are close to zero as
expected. There was no statistical difference between NLWM and control WM
(P-value 0.31).
Discussion:
Despite significant shortening of T
2, good separation of the short
T
2 component and good quality MWF maps were achieved using fixed
post mortem spinal cord of pwMS and
controls. The lack of a statistically significant
difference between NLWM and control WM as well as between NLGM and control grey
matter may be due to the small sample size in this pilot study. Acquisition of
a larger dataset and correlation of this promising MR index of myelin is
underway, as is correlation with other histological indices (e.g. axonal count).
Acknowledgements
We thank Richard Reynolds, Djordje Gveric, and their
team at the Multiple Sclerosis Society of Great Britain & Northern Ireland
MS Tissue Bank (based at Imperial College London) for providing the samples
used in this study. Also, Matthew Clemence (Philips Healthcare) for his
scientific support. This work has been supported by Barts Charity (grant code
468/1506). KS has been supported by a Higher Education Funding Council for
England Clinical Senior Lectureship.References
[1] Carassiti D, et al. "The relationship between
axonal loss and demyelination in the MS spinal cord," presented at the
ECTRIMS, Boston, 2014. [2] MacKay A, et al. "In vivo visualization of
myelin water in brain by magnetic resonance," Magn Reson Med, vol. 31, pp. 673-7, Jun 1994. [3] Laule C, et al.
"Myelin water imaging of multiple sclerosis at 7 T: correlations with
histopathology," Neuroimage, vol.
40, pp. 1575-80, May 1 2008. [4] Prasloski T, et al. "Applications of
stimulated echo correction to multicomponent T2 analysis," Magn Reson Med, vol. 67, pp. 1803-14,
Jun 2012.