Mahmud Mossa-Basha1, Haining Liu1, Dan S. Hippe1, Niranjan Balu1, Jie Sun1, Dean Shibata1, and Chun Yuan1
1Radiology, University of Washington Medical Center, Seattle, WA, United States
Synopsis
Intracranial arterial calcification evaluation has shown increasing importance in the literature based on associations with current and future stroke events, dementia and cognitive decline. We hypothesize that the proton-density image, SNAP Ref, that is generated with Simultaneous Non-contrast Angiography and intraPlaque hemorrhage (SNAP) can more adequately assess calcifications compared to 3D TOF MRA relative to the reference standard, thin slice CTA.Introduction
There has been increased
attention paid to intracranial vascular calcifications, with evidence that
there is associated increased association with prior and future cerebrovascular
ischemic events and development of dementia(1-4). Thin slice CT imaging is the reference standard
for detection of calcification, however considering increasing concerns over
radiation exposure, the value of MR imaging for this evaluation can be
seen. Typically when MR is employed for
the evaluation of calcifications, time-of-flight (TOF) MRA is employed. Simultaneous Non-contrast Angiography with
intraPlaque hemorrhage (SNAP)(5)
is a slab selective phase sensitive inversion recovery technique that produces
a bright blood MRA and heavily T1 weighted inverted image for detection of
intraplaque hemorrhage. Notably, SNAP
sequence contains a proton density (PD) weighted reference acquisition (Ref)
without tissue suppression for phase sensitive reconstruction, which is usually
discarded. This Ref image generated from SNAP provides an opportunity for the
evaluation of atherosclerotic plaque outer wall boundary and wall
calcifications. This study sought to
evaluate the ability of SNAP Ref images to detect intracranial artery wall
calcifications as compared 3D time of flight (TOF) MRA relative to the
reference standard, thin slice CTA.
Materials and Methods
Imaging Protocol and
Analysis
After IRB approval, the radiology
database was reviewed for consecutive subjects with thin-slice (.625 mm) CT or
CTA, TOF MRA and SNAP imaging of the brain scanned on 3 Tesla Philips Ingenia
MRI system (Philips Healthcare, Best, the Netherlands). A new SNAP Ref image (Ref2) was generated by
weighted addition of SNAP MRA and SNAP Ref. The parameters of each MR sequence are
shown in Table 1. A blinded review was
performed by a board certified neuroradiologist, with consecutive Ref2 sequences
reviewed in random order, followed by randomized review of 3D TOF MRA and
finally thin slice CTA images in consecutive days. The intracranial arterial segments that were
evaluated individually include: cavernous,
ophthalmic, supraclinoid and terminal carotid artery segments, M1 middle
cerebral, A1 anterior cerebral, P1 posterior cerebral arterial segments on the
right and left and the basilar artery.
Statistical methods
Sensitivity and
specificity for detecting calcification per vessel was computed for SNAP and
TOF-MRA using CT as the reference standard. Overall agreement with CT was
assessed using unweighted Cohen’s kappa and linearly weighted Cohen’s kappa for
both SNAP and TOF-MRA. Agreement was assessed for presence/absence of
calcification per vessel and calcification size category per vessel (none,
<50% circumferential involvement and >50% circumferential involvement)
based on previously established evaluation(6).
Diagnostic performance and agreement metrics were compared between SNAP and
TOF-MRA using the non-parametric bootstrap, to account for potential dependence
between vessels from the same subject.
Results
11 subjects were imaged.
143 segments were reviewed on each modality (basilar artery and bilateral
cavernous carotid, supraclinoid carotid, carotid terminus, A1 and M1 segments).
14 segments were not evaluable on all modalities (5 basilar arteries, 4
cavernous segments, 4 opthalmic segments and 1 supraclinoid segment), leaving
129 segments available for analysis.
Of the 11 subjects, 7 had calcification
identified in at least one intracranial segment on CT. Of the 129 vessels
evaluated, 19% had calcification by CT, 22% by SNAP and 13% by TOF-MRA (Table 2).
Using CT as the reference standard, SNAP
had higher sensitivity (75.0% vs. 29.2%, p=0.01) and similar specificity (89.5%
vs. 90.5%, p=0.8) compared to TOF-MRA (Table 3). SNAP also had higher overall agreement
with CT for calcification presence/absence (kappa: 0.60 vs. 0.22, p=0.01) and calcification
size categories (weighted kappa: 0.61 vs. 0.20, p=0.008) than TOF-MRA.
Discussion and Conclusion
In this study, the
feasibility of utilization of Ref2 images for the evaluation of intracranial
calcifications is shown. In comparison
to the typically used 3D TOF MRA, Ref2 more accurately depicted intracranial
arterial calcifications. When combined
with the MRA and intraplaque hemorrhage images generated by SNAP, this
technique can potentially provide first line luminal and vessel wall imaging
information.
Acknowledgements
No acknowledgement found.References
1. Bos D, Portegies ML,
van der Lugt A, et al. Intracranial carotid artery atherosclerosis and the risk
of stroke in whites: the Rotterdam Study. JAMA neurology 2014;71(4):405-11.
2. Bos D, van der Rijk
MJ, Geeraedts TE, et al. Intracranial carotid artery atherosclerosis:
prevalence and risk factors in the general population. Stroke; a journal of
cerebral circulation 2012;43(7):1878-84.
3. Bos D, Vernooij MW,
de Bruijn RF, et al. Atherosclerotic calcification is related to a higher risk
of dementia and cognitive decline. Alzheimer's & dementia : the journal of
the Alzheimer's Association 2015;11(6):639-47
e1.
4. Bos D, Vernooij MW,
Elias-Smale SE, et al. Atherosclerotic calcification relates to cognitive
function and to brain changes on magnetic resonance imaging. Alzheimer's &
dementia : the journal of the Alzheimer's Association 2012;8(5 Suppl):S104-11.
5. Wang J, Bornert P,
Zhao H, et al. Simultaneous noncontrast angiography and intraplaque hemorrhage
(SNAP) imaging for carotid atherosclerotic disease evaluation. Magnetic
resonance in medicine 2013;69(2):337-45.
6. Koton S, Tashlykov V,
Schwammenthal Y, et al. Cerebral artery calcification in patients with acute
cerebrovascular diseases: determinants and long-term clinical outcome. European
journal of neurology : the official journal of the European Federation of
Neurological Societies 2012;19(5):739-45.