Arni Nutting1, Amos Varga-Szemes2, Shahryar Chowdhury1, Davide Piccini3, and Anthony Hlavacek1
1Pediatrics, Medical University of South Carolina, Charleston, SC, United States, 2Radiology, Medical University of South Carolina, Charleston, SC, United States, 3Lausanne, Switzerland
Synopsis
We performed a
retrospective review of studies obtained using a prototype, self navigated,
free breathing 3D SSFP sequence. Scans were reviewed for diagnostic sensitivity of
coronary artery origin, diagnostic quality, and were graded for the severity of
respiratory or cardiac motion or blood pool inhomogeneity. A diagnostic scan was
obtained in 80.7% of cases. Blood pool inhomogeneity was common but very rarely
affected diagnosis. The greatest factor affecting diagnostic ability was
cardiac motion. We concluded that self-navigated 3D sequences can
provide excellent sensitivity in diagnosing coronary origins with
significant
time savings compared to diaphragm navigated sequences.Background
This
prototype, self navigated, free breathing 3D sequence (SNFB3D) [1] acquires
continuous ECG-segmented radial views of the heart with 100% scan efficiency
and without the need of a diaphragmatic beam-navigator [2]. This negates the
time expense of obtaining cardiac images only within a range of diaphragmatic
positions. The acquisition follows a spiral phyllotaxis pattern for the
distribution of the 3D radial readouts [3]. The reconstructed image is
respiratory motion corrected based on the automated detection of the inferior-superior
motion of the left ventricular blood pool. Acquisition times are typically 5-6
minutes and the duration of the scan is known prior to scanning.
Purpose
This is a
retrospective review to determine the sensitivity of the SNFB3D in diagnosing coronary artery origins. Additional grading of the images was performed to quantify the quality of images obtained and to attempt to describe some factors affecting
image quality.
Methods
Our
pediatric cardiac MR team performs all pediatric, and almost all, adult
congenital MRs obtained at our center. Studies performed between 2/14 and 7/15
were reviewed. Self-navigated 3D datasets were acquired in 109 studies in 107
patients (average age 20 years, range 0.1 to 58.5 years). Protocol parameters
of the fat-saturated, T2-prepared imaging sequence were set as
follow: TR/TE 3.1/1.56ms, FOV (220mm)
3, matrix 1923,
voxel size (1.15mm)
3, RF excitation angle 90°, and receiver
bandwidth 898Hz/pixel. Studies were reviewed by a single pediatric
cardiologist. For a scan to be considered diagnostic it must unambiguously
display the origins of the left main (LMC), left anterior descending (LAD), and
right coronary (RCA) arteries. Diagnostic quality was subjectively graded based
on an adaptation of a previously described grading scale [4] (1 = non-diagnostic,
2 = sufficient for diagnosis but with considerable blurring and reduced vessel
sharpness, 3 = good quality with minor blurring and mildly reduced vessel
border sharpness, and 4 = excellent quality without significant blurring and
with sharp vessel borders). The ability of the sequence to freeze cardiac and
respiratory motion was subjectively graded (1= motion affecting diagnosis, 2 =
motion but not affecting diagnosis, 3 = no significant motion). Respiratory
motion was graded based on the sharpness of the dome of the diaphragm and the
internal mammary arteries. Cardiac motion was based on the sharpness of cardiac
structures. Homogeneity of the intracardiac blood pool was subjectively graded
(1 = inhomogeneity affecting diagnosis to 5 = no significant inhomogeneity).
The ability to identify the origins of the RCA, LMC, LAD, circumflex (Cx),
first diagonal (DIA), and posterior descending (PD) coronaries in addition to
coronary dominance (DOM) was determined. Chi square or Fisher’s exact test were
used to determine a relationship between a non-diagnostic scan and cardiac or
respiratory motion, or inhomogeneous cardiac blood pool.
Results
A diagnostic study was obtained in 80.7% of scans. Of diagnostic scans, image quality was 33.0% sufficient (grade 2),
44.3% good (grade 3), and 22.7% excellent (grade 4). Coronary dominance could be determined in 57.8% of scans. Ability to identify the
origin of individual coronary segments was LMC - 87.2%, LAD - 84.4%, RCA - 84.4%, CX - 79.8%, PD - 53.2%, and DIA -
28.4%. Percentages of scans falling within each subjective category for cardiac and repsiratory motion and for blood
pool inhomogeneity are presented in figure 1. Obvious blood pool inhomogeneity was common but diagnosis was possibly affected in only 6 scans. The greatest factor affecting diagnostic ability was cardiac motion
(P<0.01).
Conclusions
Self-navigated 3D sequences can provide excellent sensitivity in diagnosing coronary origins with
significant time savings compared to diaphragm navigated sequences. The ability to freeze cardiac motion remains a
major determinant to image quality and diagnostic sensitivity.
Acknowledgements
The "work in progress" (prototype) sequence was provided by Siemens International. No additional funding
was provided for these studies.References
[1] Piccini D, Monney P, et al. Respiratory self-navigated post-contrast
whole-heart coronary MR angiography: initial experience in patients. Radiology.
2014; 270:378-386.
[2] Ehman RL, McNamara MT, et al. Magnetic resonance imaging with respiratory
gating: techniques and advantages. Am J Roentgenol.
1984; 143:1175-1182.
[3] Piccini D, Littmann A, et al. Spiral phyllotaxis: the natural way to
construct a 3D radial trajectory in MRI. Magn Reson Med. 2011; 66:1049-1056.
[4] Kim WY, Danias PG, et al. Coronary magnetic
resonance imaging for the detection of coronary stenosis. NEJM. 2001; 345(26):1863-1869.