Synopsis
Management
of renal cell carcinomas (RCCs) is reliant on imaging, which cannot reliably differentiate malignant RCCs from benign renal tumors. RCCs
exhibit increased glycolysis, resulting in elevated lactate production. This can
be used to differentiate RCCs from benign renal tumors using the hyperpolarized
13C MRI, a molecular imaging technique that can measure real-time
dynamic pathway-specific metabolic fluxes. Our aim was to investigate the pyruvate-to-lactate
flux in living patient-derived renal tissues using hyperpolarized [1-13C]pyruvate.
We have shown that rapid lactate efflux is a distinguishing feature of clear
cell RCCs (which comprise 90% of all RCCs), and can be detected using hyperpolarized
[1-13C]pyruvate. Aim
The incidence of renal
tumors has risen dramatically in the last 20 years, largely due to the
increased utilization of imaging with incidental discovery of many localized
tumors. Management of renal tumors relies heavily on imaging. For these
localized tumors, current imaging techniques cannot distinguish approximately
20% of the tumors that are benign from the malignant renal cell carcinomas
(RCCs). As such, localized tumors are most commonly treated by surgery, leading to
more than 10,000 unnecessary operations for benign tumors every year in the
U.S. alone. RCCs
exhibit increased glycolysis (aka Warburg effect), resulting in elevated
lactate production. This key feature may be used to differentiate RCCs from
benign renal tumors using the hyperpolarized carbon-13 (HP
13C) magnetic
resonance (MR), a powerful molecular imaging technique that can measure
real-time dynamic pathway-specific metabolic fluxes. The purpose of this study
was to investigate the pyruvate-to-lactate flux in living patient-derived renal
tumor tissues using HP [1-
13C]pyruvate.
Methods
Renal
tissues were obtained from patients undergoing nephrectomy for renal tumors (4
benign tumors, 10 clear cell RCC, ccRCC, and 12 normal renal tissues from the
nephrectomy specimen that were not involved by tumors. Cores of 8mm diameter
were obtained and further sliced into 300 -350 micron thick slices (optimal
thickness to allow maximal oxygen and nutrient diffusion) and cultured as
previously described
1. 4-5 tissue slices (~60-80 mg of primary
tissue) were perfused in a 5mm MR-compatible bioreactor with reduced sample
mass requirements
2. The bioreactor is a custom-designed 3D
perfusion system which provides a physiological setting for the tissues, and
which has been shown to facilitate the metabolic characterization of
hyperpolarized substrates metabolism
3. NMR data were acquired on a narrow-bore 11.7T
Varian INOVA (125MHz
13C) equipped with a 5mm broadband probe. 31P
spectra were obtained to monitor tissue viability (via quantification of βNTP) during the bioreactor experiment. HP
13C
MR was acquired dynamically (10° pulses, 3 s interval for 300 s) following
injection of 0.75 mL of 4mM of [1-13C] pyruvate in the tissue slices.
Additionally, some slices were incubated with [3-
13C] pyruvate on a
rotating plate
4, and [3-
13C]lactate in the media
were quantified using high resolution NMR (Bruker 800MHz) over a period of 6-8
hours. Tissue staining, including H&E, and monocarboxylate transporters
(MCT), was performed on all the slices and a clinical pathologist classified
and graded the tissue slices. mRNA expression levels of MCT4 (MCT isoform responsible
for lactate transport) and LDH-A (lactate dehydrogenase , isoform A) and the enzyme
activity of LDH (lactate dehydrogenase, enzyme that interconverts pyruvate and
lactate) were quantified.
All
data are expressed as mean ± std.error. Two tailed student’s t-test was used with
a significance level of p<0.05.
Results and Discussion
Fig.1 shows a representative
31P
spectra of a ccRCC with elevated PMEs (phosphomonoesters, which comprises of
phophosholine,PC, and
phosphoethanolamine, PE) similar to prior work
5. The
inset shows stable bNTP concentrations of the
tissue slices maintained in the bioreactor for over 24 hours, which provides evidence
of metabolic viability during the course of HP MRS bioreactor study. A
representative HP
13C MR spectra acquired at 50 sec after infusion
of HP pyruvate in a grade 2 ccRCC, and the kinetics of lactate production are
shown in
fig.2A. Benign tumor tissue produced 2.5 fold higher HP lactate
(p<0.005) than normal renal tissue (
fig.2B). The observed HP lactate
of ccRCC is, however, lower than that of benign renal tumors despite significantly
higher LDH expression and activity in ccRCCs (
fig.3). This likely reflects rapid
lactate efflux in ccRCC. In the bioreactor with a continuous flow of medium, rapidly
exported lactate is expected to flow away from the active region of the MR coil,
and would not contribute to the observed hyperpolarized lactate signal. The
rapid lactate efflux in ccRCC is supported by significantly higher mRNA
expression and immunohistochemical stain of MCT4, which exports lactate out of
the cell (
fig.4). We further confirmed the increased lactate efflux in
ccRCC via thermal labeling of renal tissues with [3-
13C] pyruvate
and measuring [3-
13C]lactate in the media. We observed three fold
higher rate of lactate efflux in ccRCC compared to the normal kidney and benign
tumor tissue (
fig.4C).
Conclusion
We
have shown that rapid lactate efflux is a characteristic feature of ccRCCs.
This feature can be used to differentiate ccRCCs (which comprise the majority
of all RCCs) from benign tumors using HP
13C pyruvate MR. Because of
the implication of lactate efflux in tumor invasiveness and the prognostic
value of MCT4 expression in ccRCC
6, HP pyruvate MR has the potential to provide noninvasive
metabolic biomarkers of renal tumor aggressiveness.
Acknowledgements
Sukumar Subramaniam, Dave
Korenchan, Ailin Hansen, Bertram Koelsch, Jessie Lee, Robert Bok, Romelyn DeLos
Santos and Rosalie Nolley.
Grants: P41 EB013598 (JK),
Department of Defense Peer Reviewed Visionary Postdoctoral Fellowship CA110032
(RS), Department of Defense Peer Reviewed Cancer Research Concept Award (ZJW), Radiological Society of North
America Scholar grant (ZJW).
References
1 H.
Zhao, R. Nolley, Z. Chen and D. M. Peehl, Am J Pathol, 2010, 177,
229–239.
2 K.
R. Keshari, D. M. Wilson, M. Van Criekinge, R. Sriram, B. L. Koelsch, Z. J.
Wang, H. F. VanBrocklin, D. M. Peehl, T. O'Brien, D. Sampath, R. A. D. Carano
and J. Kurhanewicz, Prostate, 2015.
3 K.
R. Keshari, R. Sriram, M. Van Criekinge, D. M. Wilson, Z. J. Wang, D. B.
Vigneron, D. M. Peehl and J. Kurhanewicz, Prostate, 2013, 73,
1171–1181.
4 A.
E. Thong, H. Zhao, A. Ingels, M. P. Valta, R. Nolley, J. Santos, S. R. Young
and D. M. Peehl, Urol. Oncol., 2014, 32, 43.e23–30.
5 B.
Ross, D. Freeman and L. Chan, Kidney Int, 1986, 29, 131–141.
6 P.
Fisel, V. Stühler, J. Bedke, S. Winter, S. Rausch, J. Hennenlotter, A. T. Nies,
A. Stenzl, M. Scharpf, F. Fend, S. Kruck, M. Schwab and E. Schaeffeler, Oncotarget,
6, 30615–30627.