Uma Sharma1, Deepti Upadhyay1, Govind Makharia2, Prasenjit Das3, Siddharth Datta Gupta3, and Naranamangalam R Jagannathan1
1Department of NMR and MRI Facility, All India Institute of Medical Sciences, New Delhi, India, 2Department of Gastroenterology and human Nutrition, All India Institute of Medical Sciences, New Delhi, India, 3Department of Pathology, All India Institute of Medical Sciences, New Delhi, India
Synopsis
The
present study demonstrated dietary induced variations on the metabolic profile
of blood plasma of CeD patients. Increased valine was seen in CeD
non-vegetarians compared to CeD vegetarians. Both CeD vegetarians and
non-vegetarians showed increased concentrations of gluconeogenic amino acids
like alanine and glycine compared to healthy subjects. Increased pyruvate and
creatine in CeD vegetarians compared to healthy vegetarians indicates impaired energy
supply. Decreased creatinine in CeD vegetarians and non-vegetarians compared to
healthy subjects is due to protein malabsorption in CeD. The study illustrates the
nutritional status of CeD patients and healthy subjects on the basis of their
dietary intake.Purpose
To
understand the dietary influences on blood plasma metabolome of Celiac disease
(CeD) patients using proton (
1H) nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy and multivariate
analysis methods.
Methodology
CeD
is caused by dietary ingestion of gluten containing products which lead to villous
atrophy and consequently affects the gut microflora. Diet is one of the
important physiological factors which affect the metabolism of human body.
Therefore, it is important to understand dietary effect on human metabolomes so
that the metabolic changes due to physiological variation are not confounded with
the biomarker/s of diseases. Thus, in the present study, the influence of diet
on metabolic profile of blood plasma of CeD patients in comparison to controls
was evaluated using NMR spectroscopy. Thirty treatment-naïve patients with CeD
(mean age 25.3±10.9 years; vegetarians, n=17 and non-vegetarians, n=13) and 26
healthy controls (mean age 27.8±4.5 yrs; vegetarians, n=10 and non-vegetarians,
n=16) were recruited. Vegetarian category included those subjects who have
taken only vegetarian diet and they do not even take egg. While non-vegetarians
were those who take non-vegetarian meals on regular basis, twice or thrice in a
week. An informed consent was taken and study
was approved by Institute Ethics Committee. All patients treated according to
standard regimen. Diagnosis of CeD
was made on the basis of European Society of Pediatric Gastroenterology
Hepatology and Nutrition. Blood samples were collected in morning pre-prandial
and centrifuged and plasma were separated and stored at -80 °C until NMR
analysis.
1H one-dimensional
Carr-Purcell-Meiboom-Gill Sequence (CPMG)
and two
dimensional total correlation spectroscopy (TOCSY) NMR experiments were
performed at 700 MHz (Agilent, U.S.A.). Unpaired student t-test/Wilcoxon rank
sum test were used for comparison of concentration data between two groups and
probability <0.05 was considered significant. Partial least
squares-discriminant analysis (PLS-DA) was performed using Unscrambler 10.2 (CAMO Software, Oslo, Norway).
Results
The
concentration [(μM (mean ±SD)] of metabolites was determined in patients with
CeD and healthy controls are presented in Table 1. Significantly different
metabolic profile was observed in CeD patients when categorized on the basis of
diet (Table 1). PLS-DA
showed clear distinction between CeD vegetarians and CeD
non-vegetarian patients (Fig.
1); CeD vegetarians and healthy vegetarians (Fig. 2); and CeD non-vegetarians
and healthy non-vegetarians (Fig.
3).
Discussion
The
present study demonstrated the dietary induced variations on the metabolic
profile of blood plasma of CeD patients. Our study revealed a significantly
lower concentration of essential amino acid valine in the plasma of vegetarian
as compared to non-vegetarian CeD patients. Valine is an essential amino acid and
is obtained through diet. Since, non-vegetarian diet is rich in protein and
fat, hence, high level of valine seen in non-vegetarian CeD patients may be
related to diet
1. Further, our results showed increased level of
glycine in CeD vegetarians compared to CeD non-vegetarians and this was also
higher compared to healthy vegetarians. It may be noticed that alanine was
significantly higher in non-vegetarian CeD compared to healthy non-vegetarian
subjects. Since, glycine and alanine are
both utilized in gluconeogenesis, enhanced levels of these amino acids in the
blood plasma of CeD patients may probably suggest reduced gluconeogenesis in
both vegetarian and non-vegetarian CeD patients. However, gluconeogenesis pathway
may be more compromised in vegetarians as compared to non-vegetarian CeD
patients. Further, our results showed an increased concentration of acetate in
CeD (vegetarians and non-vegetarians) patients as compared to healthy subjects
which may be attributed to the preference for utilization of fatty acids as
energy fuel in CeD patients. Further, we
observed a significantly higher concentration of pyruvate and creatine in CeD
vegetarians compared to healthy vegetarians, while these differences were not
seen in CeD non-vegetarians compared to healthy non-vegetarians. These findings
suggested that the nutritional and energy status may be more compromised in CeD
patients on vegetarian diet. The concentration of creatinine was significantly
lower in both vegetarian and non-vegetarian CeD patients compared to healthy
subjects which indicated malabsorption of proteins in CeD. However in this
study, the metabolic profile of healthy vegetarians and non-vegetarians was
similar, except that lactate was higher in healthy vegetarians. This may be due
to the fact that healthy subjects included in this study belonged to the same
socio-economic status, which resulted in similar nutritional status.
Conclusion
The
results suggested the influence of diet on the metabolic profile of blood
plasma in CeD patients, hence, may have implications in interpretation of
biomarkers for CeD diagnosis. The study
showed that nutritional and energy status was comparatively compromised in
vegetarian compared to non-vegetarian CeD patients while nutritional quality of
vegetarian and non-vegetarian diet was similar in healthy subjects.
Acknowledgements
The authors thank the Department of Biotechnology,
Government of India for the financial assistance.References
(1) Deriemaeker
P, Alewaeters K, Hebbelinck M, et al. Nutritional status of Flemish
vegetarians compared with non-vegetarians: a matched samples study. Nutrients
2010;2(7):770-780.