Tanushri Chatterji1, Dr. Suruchi Singh2, Dr. Manodeep Sen1, Dr. Ajai Singh3, Prof. Raja Roy2, and Dr. J.K Srivastava4
1Microbiology, Dr. Ram Manohar Lohia Institute of Medical Sciences, Lucknow, India, 2Centre of Bio-Medical Research, Lucknow, India, 3Neurology, Dr. Ram Manohar Lohia Institute of Medical Sciences, Lucknow, India, 4Amity Institute of Biotechnology, Amity University, Lucknow, India
Synopsis
This study explored diagnostic utility based on the
analysis of CSF, serum and urine for differential diagnosis of bacterial (BM)
and tubercular meningitis (TBM) in adults using 1H NMR metabolic
profiling.This may render rapid diagnosis of meningitis resulting to the
decline of mortality by appropriate and timely treatment regimen. The Discriminant
Functional Analysis (DFA) identified acetate, alanine, malonate and choline
containing compounds as significant metabolites among case and control. The
Orthogonal Signal Correction Principal Component Analysis (OSC-PCA) of
significant metabolites clearly differentiated case vs control group in serum
and urine samples, while a clear classification could not be obtained for CSF
samples.PURPOSE
The proposed study had been performed in order to
explore metabolic profiling in CSF, serum and urine for differentiation of BM, TBM (meningitis cases) and controls in adults using NMR spectroscopy.
INTRODUCTION
Meningitis is a serious disease accompanied by acute
inflammation of the meninges, associated with raised intracranial pressure
linked with serious neurological sequelae. BM is the most common form of
meningitis constituting about 80%
1 of all infected cases while, TBM
is the most severe form of extra pulmonary tuberculosis. The differential
diagnosis is quandary with low sensitivity and specificity as it depends on
clinical/microbiological (CSF)/pathological/radiological parameters and hence
it results to high risk of morbidity and mortality. This study therefore
intends to explore metabolic profiling of serum and urines samples also for
differentiating meningitis.
METHODS
Patients
with confirmed clinico- radiological/ pathological and/ or microbiological
evidence of bacterial and tubercular meningitis (n=51) were admitted in
hospital with a prior approval from Institutional Ethical Committee. The CSF, serum and urine were collected using
standard protocol and stored in -80ºC. The NMR spectra were acquired using Avance
III 800 MHz NMR spectrometer (BrukerGmBH, Germany). One-dimensional NOESY-preset
and CPMG experiments were recorded in all the samples. The metabolites were quantified
using QUANTAS (QUANTification
by Artificial Signal)
2 and subjected to multivariate stepwise Discriminant Functional
Analysis (DFA) using SPSS version 21 software. The case vs control study was
performed using healthy controls (n=32) for serum and urine samples and
neurological disease controls for CSF samples. The Orthogonal Signal Correction
using two components followed by Principal Component Analysis (OSC-PCA) of
significant metabolites of CSF, serum and urine samples were carried out using ‘The Unscrambler X’ Software package (Version 10.0.1,
Camo ASA, Norway).
RESULTS
83
subjects were enrolled for the study, out of which there were 51 cases of
meningitis and remaining 32 were controls. Among 51 cases BM (pyogenic
meningitis) and TBM were 21 and 30 respectively. Twenty one metabolites were
quantified in CSF (Figure1c), showed varied alterations along with the
upregulation of lactate, pyruvate, and citrate, and downregulation of glucose
in cases (Figure 1a). Similarly among BM and TBM group significant increase of
2-hydroxyisovalerate, isobutyrate and formate in BM cases was observed (Figure
4a). DFA provided correct classification of 78.0% in both the groups viz. case
vs. control group and BM vs. TBM. Among the twenty three metabolites quantified
in serum, valine and acetate were found to be elevated among case vs control
groups (Figure 2c). Metabolites viz. ethanol, acetoacetate and succinate were
observed in serum samples of cases only (Figure 2a). Comparatively, BM and TBM showed a
depletion of alanine in BM cases (Figure 4b).
The DFA of cases and controls afforded correct classification of 93.5%, and
of BM and TBM 60.0%. Twenty six metabolites were quantified in the spectra of
urine samples (Figure 3c). Quantified metabolites resulted into clear
distinction among cases and controls. Elevated metabolites in meningitis cases
were ketonic bodies and GPC with depletion of creatine/creatinine and malonate (Figure 3a).
Decrease in valine and acetone levels in BM, differentiated BM vs TBM group (Figure
4c). The multivariate DFA afforded correct classification, 89.7% in case vs
control and 89.1% in BM vs TBM group. The 3D score plot of PCA using
significant metabolites of DFA showed clear distinction among case vs control groups.
DISCUSSION
The
OSC-PCA of significant metabolites obtained through DFA in CSF samples could
not clearly differentiate meningitis cases into separate clusters. However,
clear classification between case vs. control group was obtained in alternative
bodyfluids i.e. serum and urine samples respectively. This may be because
neurological disease control subjects were used instead of healthy controls for
the comparison of metabolic profile in CSF samples.
The
metabolic profile of serum and urine correlates with infection and inflammation.
The elevation of acetate in both the biofluids of cases, can be accounted for
due to infection in which plasma free fatty acids concentration have been reported
to be variably increase or decrease in human and experimental animals. The increase
of alanine levels in serum samples of TBM cases may represent changes in the
source of excitatory amino acid synthesis3,4. The elevation of
choline levels in urine may be due to the breakdown of membrane phospholipids
leading to neuro-degeneration. Depletion of malonate may be due to its
utilization by mycobacterial species for their growth as reported earlier
during tissue hypoxia in children with tuberculosis5.
Acknowledgements
The authors are thankful to Dr. Ram ManoharLohia
Institute of Medical Sciences for Intramural funding (IEC 14/11) to carry out
our study and Centre of Biomedical Research, Lucknow where the 1H
NMR spectroscopy was conducted. We are grateful to Dr. S. K. Mandal (Consultant and
Bio-statistician) at Centre of Biomedical Research, Lucknowfor cross-checking
the statistical results.References
1. Shrestha RG, Tandukar S, Ansari S, et al. Bacterial meningitis in children
under 15 years of age in Nepal. BMC Pediatr. 2015; 19: 94.
2. Farrant RD, Hollerton JC, Lynn SM, et al. NMR quantification using
an artificial signal. Magnetic Resonance in Chemistry. 2010; 48:
753-762.
3. Subramanian
A, Gupta A, Saxena
S et al. Proton MR CSF analysis and a new software
as predictors for the differentiation of meningitis in children. NMR Biomed. 2005;
18:213-225.
4. Van Cappellen Van Walsum AM, Jongsma HW, Nijhuis JG, et al. 1H- NMR spectroscopy of cerebrospinal fluid of fetal sheep during hypoxia-induced acidemia and recovery. Pediatr Res. 2002; 52:56-63.
5. Stenina MA, Voevodin DA, Stakhanov VD, et al. Tissue hypoxia and intestinal dysbiosis
in children with tuberculosis.
Bull Exp Biol Med. 2003; 135:178-80.