Byeong-Yeul Lee1, Xiao-Hong Zhu1, Sebastian Rupprecht2, Michael T. Lanagan3, Qing X. Yang2,4, and Wei Chen1
1Center for Magnetic Resonance Research, Radiology, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, MN, United States, 2Center for NMR Research, Radiology, The Pennsylvania State College of Medicine, Hershey, PA, United States, 3Engineering Science and Mechanics, The Pennsylvania State College of Engineering, University Park, PA, United States, 4Neurosurgery, The Pennsylvania State College of Medicine, Hershey, PA, United States
Synopsis
Compared to 1H MRS, X-nuclei
MRS for human application faces two challenges: higher requirement of RF power
(thus, higher SAR) for achieving the same RF pulse flip angle due to a
relatively lower gyromagnetic ratio, and still limited SNR even at high/ultrahigh field. In this
report, we demonstrate that up to 200% SNR gain was achieved with ultra high
dielectric constant (uHDC) materials incorporated into the RF volume coil for 31P
MRS at 7T. Concomitantly, the RF power optimized for acquiring the spectra was significantly
reduced by 200%. Our data demonstrated that incorporating uHDC with RF coil can
significantly boost SNR and reduce RF transmission power X-nuclei MRS
applications on top of using high field strength magnet that has approached to
its technologic limits.Purpose
In
vivo 31P MRS
provides an important neuroimaging tool for studying high-energy phosphate
metabolisms, neuroenergetics and NAD redox state
[1-2]. However, its
sensitivity is still limited for addressing challenging scientific questions
even at ultrahigh field. This study was to investigate the efficacy and utility
of ultra-high dielectric constant (uHDC) technology for significantly improving
SNR and reducing RF power requirement for
in
vivo 31P MRS at ultrahigh field of 7T.
Introduction
The demands of ultrahigh field have been growing
rapidly due to its substantial improvement of the spatial/temporal/spectral
resolution with increased signal-to-noise ratio (SNR), which are essential for
studying and understanding brain function, connectivity and neuroenergetics.
Despite the advantages, increased RF power deposition or specific absorption
rate (SAR) has become a major safety concern and technical hurdle at ultrahigh
field. As one of engineering solutions, the
introduction of high dielectric constant (HDC) material in MR field has shown
some benefits for improving both the transmit efficiency (|B
1+|)
and receive sensitivity (|B
1-|)
[3-5].
However, further development is still needed to maximize the B
1 efficiency
and the performance of the HDC material. Thus, our research aim was to 1)
develop and optimize the ultrahigh HDC (uHDC) materials based on computer
simulation and advanced material science for MR imaging application, and 2) to quantitatively
investigate the B
1 efficiency and sensitivity gain of the optimally
designed uHDC material for
31P MRS application at 7T based on both
phantom and
in vivo validation.
Methods
Design of uHDC: First, optimal
dielectric constant of permittivity for the target operation frequency
(120.3MHz for 31P at 7T) with 31P volume coil configuration
was determined by numerical simulation of the B1 fields using xFDTD
(REMCOM, USA). Subsequently, a monolithic block made of lead zirconium titanate
(PZT) (TRS, State College, PA, USA) was used to reach the ultrahigh permittivity
constant (εr).
31P MRS: All 31P MRS measurements
were performed at 7.0T/90 cm bore human scanner (Siemens/Magnex) with 31P-1H
double-tuned RF volume coil; 1H channel for anatomic imaging and B0
shimming, and 31P channel for acquiring 31P MRS. 31P
MRS data were collected on phantom (a rectangular bottle filled with inorganic
phosphate (Pi: 50 mM) and NaCl (50 mM), and gadolinium contrast agent for shortening the T1
value of Pi to 300
ms) and on the leg muscle in vivo from
a healthy volunteer. All 31P measurements for the phantom study were
made using a 3D chemical shift imaging (CSI) with Fourier Series Window (FSW)
technique [6] (TR= 1s, FA= 90°, phase encode= 9×9×7, bandwidth= 5 kHz, FOV= 15×15×20
cm3, and hard excitation pulse width = 750 μs). In vivo 31P CSI data were acquired with slightly
different parameters of TR= 1.5s with an Ernst flip angle and pulse width of
500 μs. Finally, spatial maps of relative B1+ (i.e.,
inversely proportional to the RF transmit voltage to reaching a 90° RF pulse flip angle) and
B1- (proportional to the maximum signal at 90° flip angle) were
calculated using fitting algorithm for determining the integrals of phosphorous
creatine (PCr) signal for in vivo data
and Pi signal for phantom data and their dependence on the variable RF pulse voltages.
Results and Discussion
Based on the simulation results, we employed four
uHDC pads with dielectric constant,
εeff ≈ 1000, surrounding the phantom or human leg for
31P
MRS studies at 7T. Both RF transmission field (B
1+) and reception
field (B
1-) for acquiring 3D
31P CSI at 7T demonstrate
large improvements with the uHDC pads for Pi phantom (Fig. 1) and human leg
muscle
in vivo (Fig. 2). Strikingly, the
improvements of B
1 in both phantom and
in vivo cases with the uHDC pads increased the SNRs for more than
200% in some tissue region of interest (see Fig. 3) and reduced RF power requirement
(more than 200% voltage reduction) in comparison to that of no uHDC pads. Moreover,
Figure 3 also shows localized
31P MR spectrum by a small RF surface
coil (diameter = 5cm) placed close to the targeted muscle. Comparing the
spectra from the head volume coil, using uHDC pads could provide equivalent or
even slightly better sensitivity. These results provide experimental evidence that
uHDC materials improved B
1 efficiency, leading to SNR enhancements and
SAR reduction. Based on the field-dependent SNR of the PCr metabolite
[7],
a 200% SNR gain with the uHDC technique observed at 7T is equivalent to a
similar performance and SNR expected at > 15T with no added concerns for SAR.
Conclusion
We have demonstrated experimentally that uHDC
materials significantly improved both |B
1+| and |B
1-| for
in vivo 31P MRS. Therefore, utilizing uHDC
materials could be an important and cost-effective engineering solution for overcoming
high specific absorption rate (SAR) and significantly gaining SNR at ultrahigh
fields, which will provide enormous benefits for
in vivo human applications including
brain research.
Acknowledgements
NIH
grants: R24 MH106049, RO1 NS070839, S10 RR029672, P41 EB015894 and P30 NS076408References
[1] Du et al, PNAS
105:6409-14 (2008); [2]
Zhu et al, PNAS 112:2876-81 (2015); [3] Yang et al, JMRI 38:435-440 (2013); [4]
Lee et al., Proc. ISMRM; 23: 4718
(2014); [5] Rupprecht et al., Proc.
ISMRM; 23: 403 (2014); [6] Garwood et al.,
JMR 75:244-261 (1987); [7] Lu et al, NMR Biomed 27:1135-41
(2014)