Christopher Sica1, Sebastian Rupprecht1, and Qing X Yang1
1Radiology, Penn State College of Medicine, Hershey, PA, United States
Synopsis
Prior work has suggested that a dielectric insert can reduce the SAR in the brain at 3T. These previous results were obtained via electromagnetic simulations. Here, we present an experimental evaluation of SAR reduction in a phantom with a dielectric insert.Purpose
Prior
work has demonstrated SAR reduction with a high dielectric constant (HDC) ring
surrounding the human brain [1]. This SAR reduction was achieved while
maintaining the same mean excitation flip angle throughout the brain as
compared to a baseline case without the dielectric insert, with the associated
interpretation that for the same B
field, the E field (and SAR) has
been reduced in the brain. This result was supported with a simulation of SAR
in the brain and global power measurements experimentally. Global power measurements do not offer insight
into the behavior of the electric fields locally within the region enhanced by HDC.
It is possible to examine this behavior experimentally, with PRFS temperature
mapping in an agar phantom [2]. In this experiment, the local heating is
directly proportional to the local SAR and electric field.
Methods
A
spherical Siemens quality assurance phantom (diameter 160 mm) was drained and
then filled with a mixture of water, agar, and NaCl, yielding material with an
approximate permittivity of 78 and conductivity of 1.7 S/m. The phantom was
then wrapped to provide thermal insulation. Heating experiments were conducted
without (Fig. 1a) and with (Fig. 1b) a ring of HDC material present. The
experiment with HDC was repeated twice, altering the configuration of material
to generate a different enhancement pattern the second time. This material has
an approximate permittivity of 900 and block dimensions of 105 x 88 x 20 mm. B1
mapping was first performed with the Bloch-Siegert technique [3,4] to acquire a
transmit efficiency map (units uT/Volt) over the transverse and coronal
orientations. This was followed by a multi-echo GRE acquisition to acquire
baseline phase data, a heating scan that utilized the volume body coil to apply
heating, and another multi-echo GRE acquisition to acquire phase data. The
multi-echo GRE acquisition utilized 6 monopolar echoes ranging from 6 – 29 ms,
a TR of 35 ms, 2 averages, flip angle of 15 degrees, a resolution of 2 x 2 x 10
mm, scan time of 6.3 seconds, and were acquired in the coronal orientation. Temperature
maps were formed as described in Ref 2, using an off-resonance field map
instead of a phase image at a single echo time. The heating scan applied a
series of hard pulses (duration 1 ms) with a TR of 55 ms, for a duration of 1 minute
and 53 seconds. The two cases (with and without HDC) were normalized such that
the heating sequence achieved the same mean B1+ over the
whole central transverse slice of the phantom. All
scans were performed on a Siemens 3T PrismaFit. Reception utilized a Siemens 20
Ch head matrix. Transmission utilized the 2 Ch Body coil driven in a circular
polarization mode.
Results
Measured temperature maps and B1+ maps are
displayed in Figure 2. The B1+ maps of the case with HDC
exhibit more inhomogeneity due to the strong and uneven field enhancement near
the edges, but the mean field value over the transverse slice in all cases is
14 uT. This normalization lead to a heating pulse voltage of 379.09 volts for
the case without dielectrics and 232.06/225.14 volts for the two cases with
dielectrics, and a measured system power reduction of 57.4/59.4%. The
temperature map of the case without HDC exhibits a strong asymmetry along the
upper right quadrant. The first case with HDC (“Case 1”) exhibits a heating
pattern similar to the case without HDC, but the overall level of heating is
significantly reduced. In the second case with HDC (“Case 2”), the B1+
enhancement in the coronal slice becomes asymmetric. The temperature map shows
a similar pattern, with the peak heating rotated slightly relative to the peak
B1+ enhancement. Overall heating levels are also
significantly reduced (by 50 – 66%) relative to the case without HDC.
Discussion
The results appear to support the conclusion that a ring configuration
of dielectric material can reduce the E
field and the SAR for the same nominal B
field, observed through a reduction in the heating. These results also suggest
that the E and B fields may not be fully coupled, as they are enhanced unequally
by the dielectric material. The measured global power reduction, taken as the
peak forward – reflected power, was 57.4/59.4% for the two cases with HDC.
Normalizing over the central portion of the transverse B1+
map only would lessen the overall power reduction and heating reduction compared
to the case without HDC. An understanding of these temperature & SAR
patterns could help guide development of dielectric inserts to further reduce
SAR in the brain.
Acknowledgements
No acknowledgement found.References
1.
Sica et al. ISMRM 2014 P0405
2. Oh et al. MRM 63:218–223 (2010)
3. Sacolick et al. MRM 63:1315–1322 (2010)
4. Jankiewicz et al, ISMRM 2012 P4265