Jonathan Y Lu1, Thomas Grafendorfer2, Tao Zhang1, Kamal Aggarwal1, Fraser Robb3, John M Pauly1, and Greig C Scott1
1Electrical Engineering, Stanford University, Stanford, CA, United States, 2Advanced Coils, GEHC Coils, Stanford, CA, United States, 3GE Healthcare, Aurora, OH, United States
Synopsis
We examine different power depletion
mode GaN HEMT devices for use in low power MRI Q-spoiling at 3T. These devices
range in their on-resistance and off-capacitance, yielding different blocking
impedances. We prototyped FET based Q-spoiling surface coils and compared SNR
performances with conventional PIN diode Q-spoiling coils. Our coils enable Q-spoiling
when unpowered providing a good safety feature. We tested the robustness of the
FET devices in the coils by running fast spin echo sequences at 3T. The SNR
performances of our FET based coils are comparable with conventional PIN diode
coils without the high current draw.Introduction
In this work, we demonstrate a low power Q spoiling circuit that uses
Gallium Nitride (GaN) depletion mode HEMT devices at 3T field strength. In
contrast to conventional Q-spoiling using PIN diodes, a depletion mode FET Q
spoiling circuit is in the blocking mode when the FET is unpowered, providing a
useful safety feature. Moreover, conventional PIN diode Q-spoiling requires 50-100
mA forward bias current, but GaN FET switches require negligible bias current. As coil array counts increase, the
substantial reduction in drive currents becomes an important advantage, and in
particular if wireless receive arrays are to be developed.
In the past, various groups have examined and implemented FET devices 1-3 or
MEMs 4-5 for switching. While MEMs devices are promising, they need a high
control voltage and are less commercially available. The use of GaN FET
switches has been discussed and explored 1-3 in MRI. In our prior work 3,
we demonstrated Q-spoiling at 1.5T for a Gradient Echo (GRE) 60° flip angle
sequence using GaN power switches with high off-state capacitance and a low on-resistance.
Here we report performance improvements and SNR for operation to 3T and with
higher power Fast Spin Echo imaging, both of which increase the voltage and
current stress on the devices.
Materials
and Methods
We constructed four 11 cm by 14 cm coils
with different Q-spoiling circuits, and tuned them to ω
0=127.7 MHz
(3T). All of the Q-spoiling networks used ~140 nH inductance across ~10 pF
capacitance. One coil employed conventional Q spoiling, in which we used a
nonmagnetic MAP7441F-1091 PIN diode (Figure 1a). We constructed three FET based
coils (Figure 1b) using 25W, 40W and 75W GaN HEMT devices as outlined in Table
1. These devices varied in on-resistance and off-capacitance to achieve
a range of blocking impedances given a chosen inductor and capacitor. We
designed the circuit such that during receive mode, the scanner imposes a
negative voltage onto the FET gate deactivating the Q-spoiling. During transmit
mode, a positive 0.6V is imposed on the FET gate, turning on the device to
Q-spoil the coil. To avoid magnetic packaging, we
acquired the GaN HEMT in die form and gold wire bonded it to a PCB board
(Figure 2). We measured S
11 to determine the blocking network
impedances with an HP E5071C network analyzer. We tested the final coils in a
General Electric 3T MR 750 scanner. Each of the four receive coils was tested
individually on a loaded Nickel Chloride doped phantom with a fast spin echo
(FSE) sequence (TE=10 ms, TR=500 ms, FOV=24 cm x 24 cm, 4 echoes).
Results
and Discussion
We measured the GaN switch blocking impedance circuits to be 5.8kΩ, 5.9kΩ,
6.5kΩ using the 25W, 40W, and 75W FET devices respectively (Table 2). This
makes sense since the higher power parts have smaller on-resistance (but larger
off capacitance). The PIN diode required 34mA, 40mA, and 76mA of bias current
to achieve the blocking impedance of the three previously mentioned FET coils
respectively. The MRI scanner provides a bias current of 100mA - the PIN diode
blocking impedance at this current was 6.7kΩ.
The coils were matched so that |S11|<= -20dB. In the scanner,
great care was made so that the location of each coil and the phantom was the
same for each scan. Even slight differences in position as small as a
centimeter could potentially cause ~1dB difference in SNR measurements. After
performing a fast spin echo sequence and examining the images, we found that
the SNR quantities for the PIN diode coil and the three power GaN FET coils are
similar (PIN=43.3dB, 25W=43.4dB, 40W=43.9dB, 75W=43.7dB) (Figure 3). The
agreement of the SNR quantities implies that additional noise sources intrinsic
to the FET devices (ie shot noise) do not appear to have a substantive effect
on image quality.
Conclusion
We successfully demonstrated a range of
different power depletion mode GaN FETs for low power Q-spoiling switches at 3T
and with a fast spin echo (FSE) sequence.
FSE sequences at 3T induce larger
voltages on receive coils, which convert to large circulating currents in the
blocking circuit. This necessitates microwave RF power FETs capable of
supporting high currents but have low off-capacitance. We achieved SNR comparable with conventional
PIN diode Q-spoiling with each device. Depletion mode GaN switches, because of
their default on-state, enable RF safe arrays under loss of power. In particular, the negligible supply current
needs will be highly compatible with low-power on-coil electronics and wireless
coil array development.
Acknowledgements
Stanford Graduate Fellowship, National Science
Foundation, NIH Grant R01EB019241, R01EB008108, P01CA15999, GE Healthcare
research supportReferences
1. Burl M, et al., General Electric
Company, "Transmit mode Coil Detuning For MRI Systems US Patent 6850067 B1", February
1, 2005
2. Twieg M, et al., "Enhancement Mode GaN on
Silicon (eGaN FETs) for Coil Detuning", Proc Intl Soc Mag Reson Med. #0926, 2014
3. Lu J, et al., "Q-spoiling method using depletion mode Gallium
Nitride (GaN) HEMT devices at 1.5T", Proc Intl Soc Mag Reson Med. #2150, 2015
4. Spence D, et al., "Custom MEMs Switch for MR
Surface Coil decoupling", Proc Intl Soc Mag Reson Med. #0704, 2015
5. Fuentes M, et al., "Micro-Electromechanical Systems
(MEMs) Based RF-Switches in MRI-A Performance Study", Proc Intl Soc Mag Reson
Med. #0422, 2010