Nicholas R. Payne1, Lionel M. Broche1, and David J. Lurie1
1Bio-Medical Physics, University of Aberdeen, Aberdeen, United Kingdom
Synopsis
RF coil ringing following an excitation pulse is particularly
problematic at low frequency and can prevent the measurement of signals from
short-T2 samples or tissues; this issue can be addressed by Q-switching. A
Q-switch circuit, designed to operate at 2.5 MHz and reduce the dead-time of an
RF coil following an RF pulse, is described. The resulting reduction in coil
dead-time allows signal to be detected earlier and RF pulses to be spaced
closer together. MOSFETs are used in our design to isolate RF from the DC
control system and the circuit can be inductively coupled to any RF coil. The
device was found to reduce the duration of coil ringing by a factor of five.Introduction
RF coils are often desired to have a high Q-factor due to
the related increase in SNR. However, at low frequencies there are two factors
which limit the usefulness of an ever higher Q-factor; the bandwidth of the
coil and the dead-time after an RF pulse. Residual energy stored in the
coil circuitry following an RF pulse dissipates with a time constant $$\tau=\frac{2Q}{\omega_{0}}\ln\frac{V_{p}}{V_{n}}$$ giving a dead-time that lasts on the order of twenty
time constants to get from a peak voltage, $$$V_{p}$$$, to the noise floor,
$$$V_{n}$$$ [1] (where $$$\omega_{0}$$$ is the resonant angular frequency). If
it is necessary to be able to acquire signal or apply additional pulses soon
after an RF pulse then techniques must be found to reduce the dead-time.
Several methods, covering a range of complexity and efficacy, have been
developed to reduce ringing including over-coupling the coil to the
preamplifier [2], application of a second, short RF pulse with the opposite
phase [3], and using additional circuitry to vary the Q-factor of the RF coil
[1, 2, 4-7]. The work presented here belongs to the last category; an active
circuit, known as a Q-switch, which acts to greatly reduce the Q-factor of the
RF coil for a short period following an RF pulse. This permits the RF coil to
have a high Q-factor for both transmit and receive but reduces the ring-down
time with a low Q-factor while the coil recovers from a pulse. Q-switching is a
well-used technique in low-frequency RF coils and the circuit described here
represents a very simple design which can be implemented on all forms of RF
coil.
Circuit design
In order to ensure that the RF coil maintained a high Q-factor
when the Q-switch was inactive the additional circuitry was inductively coupled
to the main RF coil. This was achieved by co-winding the main coil with a
secondary coil forming an air-core transformer with a 1:1 turns ratio, each
winding comprising a 10-turn solenoid with a 11 mm radius and a 70 mm length. The
main RF coil was tuned to 2.5 MHz and capacitance matched to 50 Ω.
The designed system (Fig. 1) is able to greatly reduce the
Q-factor of the RF coil by selectively grounding the secondary windings of the
transformer through two MOSFETs. By rectifying the
induced RF voltage, using four BYT52M small-signal diodes in a diode-bridge
configuration, the positive and negative sides of the cycle could be
controlled by an N-channel MOSFET (STP15N95K5) and a P-channel MOSFET
(IXTX32P60P) respectively.
When both MOSFETs are “closed” the Q-switch side of the circuit
shunts the oscillatory circuit, efficiently removing the stored energy
responsible for the coil ringing. However, when the MOSFETs are “open”, no
current flows through the Q-switch circuit and the Q-factor of the RF coil
remains high. The Q-switch is triggered by a TTL input to a MOSFET driver
(LTC1693-1IS8) which provides the gating voltages for both MOSFETs. The gating
voltage seen by each MOSFET is shaped by the resistance through which its
internal capacitance is charged and discharged. A diode is used to allow the
MOSFET to be quickly charged through a small resistance but discharged more
slowly due to the larger resistance presented. This causes the MOSFETs to
“open” more slowly, reducing the secondary-ringing which can otherwise occur.
Results and conclusions
The unloaded Q-factor of the 2.5 MHz RF coil was found to have a
value of 110 with the Q-switch off, which was reduced to a value of 3 when the
Q-switch was activated. Figure 2 shows the impact of the Q-switch on reducing
the duration of ringing. With the Q-switch in operation, the ring-down time was
reduced from ~160 μs to ~30 μs. The Q-switch presented in this paper has
been seen to function well at 2.5 MHz. It is hoped that this device will enable
detection of samples with short $$$T_2^*$$$ values which would have
otherwise not have been possible. The Q-switch’s simple design and
implementation means that pre-existing RF coils will also be able to be easily
converted into fast-recovery systems.
Acknowledgements
The author
acknowledges funding from the EPSRC through the Centre for Doctoral Training in
Integrated Magnetic Resonance.References
[1] Andrew,
E.R. and Jurga, K., “NMR Probe with Short Recovery Time” J. Magn. Reson. 73,
268-276. (1987)
[2] Miller,
J. B. et al., “Interplay among
recovery time, signal, and noise: series- and parallel-tuned circuits are not
always the same” Concepts Magn. Reson.
12, 125 – 136. (2000)
[3] Hoult,
D.I. “Fast recovery, high sensitivity NMR probe and pre-amplifier for low
frequencies” Rev. Sci. Instrum. 50, 193 – 2000. (1979)
[4] Sulivan,
N.S. et al., “Efficient fast-recovery
scheme for NMR pulse spectrometers” Revue
Phys. Appl. 18, 253-261. (1983)
[5] G.-Y.
Li, et al. “A novel probe design for
pulse nitrogen-14 nuclear quadrupole spectrometer” Rev. Sci. Instrum. 67,
704-706. (1996)
[6] Rudakov,
T.N. et al., “Suppression of
Transient Processes in the Oscillatory Circuit of the NQR Spectrometer” Instrum. Exp. Tech. 43, 78-81. (2000)
[7] Peshkovsky,
A.S. et al., “RF probe recovery time
reduction with a novel active ringing suppression circuit” J. Magn. Reson. 177,
67-73. (2005)