Steven P Allen1, Luis Hernandez-Garcia2, Charles A Cain1, and Timothy L Hall1
1Biomedical Engineering, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI, United States, 2fMRI Lab, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI, United States
Synopsis
We estimate the R2 relaxation rate and the
apparent diffusion coefficient at 7T in a variety of in vitro tissues and
tissue mimicking phantoms after they have been subjected to homogenization by
ultrasonic cavitation (histotripsy). The estimated R2 rate of these lesions decreases
with increased treatment so long as the lesions are made in materials with high
iron content. When lesions are made in brain tissue or phantoms with low iron
content, the R2 rate remains unperturbed by homogenization. The apparent
diffusion coefficient increases with increasing treatment for all tissues and phantoms.Introduction
Histotripsy is a non-invasive ablation surgery which uses
high intensity acoustic pulses to stimulate a cavitation cloud and homogenize a
tissue target
1. Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) is a useful tool for assessing lesions
made by this therapy. MR contrast parameters such as R2, and the apparent
diffusion coefficient (ADC) are sensitive to structural properties of cellular
tissue. Changes to these properties, such as homogenization by histotripsy,
should induce changes in MR image contrast. In this study we estimate R2 and
the ADC of histotripsy lesions made in ex vivo brain, liver, kidney, blood clot,
and various red blood cell (RBC) phantoms commonly used in histotripsy studies.
Methods
A 500 kHz, electronically steered, focused transducer (256
elements, f#: 0.5, focal distance: 15 cm, focal length: 3.5 mm, focal width:
1.5mm, PRF: 10 Hz) generated histotripsy bubble clouds in in vitro samples of
porcine liver, kidney, bovine liver, brain, and blood clot as well as agar gels
mixed with 3, 6, and 16%/wt red blood cells (RBC’s). Lesions were made by
electronically steering the focal zone through a grid of points
spaced 0.7 mm apart. For each steering point, the transducer emitted a single,
two-cycle acoustic pulse (~ 5 us long) with a peak negative pressure that
exceeded 35 MPa. This treatment pattern was repeated until 3, 30, or 300 pulses
were deposited per grid point. A total of 4 lesions for each pulse number were
formed in each tissue sample.
After treatment, each sample was placed in the bore of a 7-Tesla
small animal MR scanner (Agilent Technologies, Walnut Creek, CA) and imaged
using spin-echo sequences with various echo-times and diffusion-weighting
b-values. Contrast parameters R2, and ADC were estimated from the resulting images
by selecting a region of interest (ROI) within each lesion and performing a non-linear,
least-squares fit of the mean signal within the ROI.
Results
Example R2 and diffusion-weighted (DW) images of lesions
made in porcine liver and bovine brain are displayed in Fig 1. The R2 and ADC
parameters measured in each tissue type are plotted as a function of pulse
number in Fig 2. In liver, kidney, blood clot, and the red blood cell phantoms,
homogenization induced measurable decreases in the R2 rate. However, R2
did not change appreciably in brain with treatment. In the red blood cell phantoms, the magnitude
of change of the R2 rate decreases with decreasing RBC concentration. The ADC
for all samples increased measurably with treatment.
Discussion
For most samples, the R2 relaxation rate and the ADC changed
appreciably with increasing pulse numbers. Both contrast parameters
asymptotically approach a final value such that further pulses cause marginal
changes in the contrast parameters. R2 weighted imaging may be a good indicator
of homogenization in samples with high iron content such as liver and RBC
phantoms. However, for samples with low iron content such as brain, R2 changes
little with increased pulse number.
These results match well with theory by Brooks et al.2, Gillis
et al.3, and Ye et al.4: R2 relaxation enhancement occurs when water is able to drift through magnetic field
gradients induced by aggregations of paramagnetic materials such as hemoglobin or ferritin packed into a cell. Homogenization by histotripsy breaks up these aggregations and thus reduces the field gradients they impose. This effectively removes the enhancement
effect and R2 appears to decrease. Because there are very few iron products in brain tissue, these field perturbations do not exist and homogenization does not result in a more uniform magnetic field.
The ADC
appears to change with pulse number in all materials reported here, likely because homogenization removes cellular membranes. These results suggest that diffusion-weighted imaging is a good assessment tool for histotripsy
therapy. However, R2-weighted imaging may suffice for histotripsy therapy in the
body, where tissues contain more iron content and respiratory motion makes
diffusion-weighted imaging difficult.
Acknowledgements
Authors T.L. Hall and C. A. Cain have equity, royalty, and consulting interests in HistoSonics Inc.References
1. Xu Z, Ludomirsky A, Eun LY, Hall TL, Tran BC, Fowlkes JB,
Cain CA. Controlled ultrasound tissue erosion. IEEE Trans. Ultrason.
Ferroelectr. Freq. Control 2004; 51:726–736.
2. Brooks RA, Di Chirro G. Magnetic resonance imaging of stationary blood:
A review. Med. Phys. 1987; 14:903.
3. Gillis P, Roch A, Brooks RA. Corrected Equations for
Susceptibility-Induced T2-Shortening. J. Magn. Reson. 1999; 137:402–407.
4. Ye FQ, Allen PS. Relaxation enhancement of the transverse magnetization
of water protons in paramagnetic suspensions of red blood cells. Magn. Reson.
Med. 1995; 34:713–20.