Laurens D. van Buuren1, Daniel Polders1, Maaike T. Milder1, Floris J. Pos1, Stijn W. Heijmink1, Baukelien van Triest1, and Uulke A. van der Heide1
1Department of Radiation Oncology, The Netherlands Cancer Institute, Amsterdam, Netherlands
Synopsis
Echo-planar
imaging is widely used to obtain diffusion images within acceptable time
limits. These images suffer from geometric distortions. Additionally, the
diffusion signal intensity can be obscured by signal pile-up, when strong
variations of the magnetic field occur, for example near gas pockets. We
demonstrate in a water phantom that both the signal pile-up and geometric
distortions can be corrected by combining the information from EPI images
obtained with opposite gradients and a magnetic field map. We applied this
method in two patients and show a reduction in signal pile-up and geometric
distortions near gas pockets in the rectum.Objective
Diffusion weighted (DW) MRI is
increasingly used in diagnostics.1 Echo-planar imaging (EPI) is
often employed to minimize scan time, but variations in the magnetic field (B0)
geometrically distort EPI images due to a low pixel band width in the
phase-encoding (BWPE) direction. More importantly, information is
lost, when signals from distinct, possibly non-neighboring, voxel locations are
reconstructed into the same voxel resulting in signal pile-up. Geometric
distortions can be corrected using a measured B0 map or by combining EPI images
obtained with opposite gradients.2 However, these methods do not
correct for signal pile-up. Our objective is to fully correct DW-EPI images
using a combination of the above methods.
Methods
On a 3T MRI, we acquired two EPI
series with opposed PE gradients in RL direction and a 3D dual spoiled gradient echo sequence
(SPGR) to map B0. Both EPI images were corrected for geometric distortions by
the standard correction method derived from B0 and BWPE.3
Using this information, we created distortion maps, which show how the EPI signals
are distributed in PE direction by B0 variations (figure 1).4 Signal
pile-up occurred when distinct locations or several neighboring voxels were
mapped onto the same distorted voxel. The distortion-corrected images were
averaged into a single image rejecting voxels with signal pile-up. These voxels
contain data from only one EPI image.
First, the correction method was
demonstrated on an ice-water phantom consisting of six tubes with sucrose
solution around an air cavity. The fully corrected images were compared to the
raw EPI images and the images corrected with the standard method. The maximum
signal intensity in ROIs inside the tubes originated from the voxel with
largest signal pile-up, whereas the undistorted signal was approximated by the median
value. Additionally, the change in signal homogeneity was determined by the
coefficient of variation (CoV defined as standard deviation divided by signal
mean). ADC values were determined from the raw and fully corrected EPI images.
We applied the correction method in
two patients with prostate and rectal cancer and visually inspected the raw and
corrected images. In regions with clear signal pile-up, the maximum signal
intensity was compared to the maximum value in the fully corrected image.
For the EPI sequences, BW
PE
differed from 5.9 Hz/mm in the phantom measurement (SENSE=1), to respectively 9.6
Hz/mm and 13.3 Hz/mm in the rectum and prostate protocols (SENSE=2). The
phantom was scanned with b-values of 0 and 200 s/mm
2 to determine
ADC maps. For the patient data, the SPGR sequences were adjusted to remain in
reasonable scan times, resulting in different voxel sizes and FOV.
Results
The SPGR data of the phantom are
presented in figure 2. Figure 3 shows the raw and corrected EPI images. Most
distortions and intensity variations within the tubes were removed using the
standard correction method. However, in regions with signal pile-up this method
did not suffice. This is shown by signal variations within the tubes, for
example in the indicated ROI. Here, the maximum
signal intensity reduced from 7.4 105 in the raw image to 4.9 105
in the B0 corrected image and 3.9 105 in the fully corrected
one, accompanied by only a minor change in median values from respectively 3.1
105 to 2.7 105 and 2.8 105. The increase in
homogeneity was quantified by the change in CoV in this ROI. While the CoV was similar
for the raw EPI image and B0 corrected image (0.34 and 0.35), it decreased to
0.12 after applying the full correction. The ADC maps in figure 4 demonstrate
the retrieval of the geometry after correction. Here, the effect from signal
pile-up is limited, since most piled-up intensities originated from locations within
the tubes.
In the patient data (figure 5), an
apparent intensity asymmetry in RL direction around the rectum was seen in the
raw EPI images. Its sign changed in the image with opposed gradient, indicating
its origin was signal pile-up. After applying the full correction, signal
pile-up was removed. This is illustrated by the change of the maximal signal
intensity in the region of the rectum. Here, the maximum was lowered from 1.0
104 to 6.4 103 and from 6.1 103 to 3.7 103
for the rectal and prostate cancer cases.
Conclusions
We demonstrated a method
to fully correct EPI images. It does not only correct for geometric
distortions, but also for possible signal pile-up near gas pockets, which
obscures the real diffusion signal. Corrected DW-EPI images can improve the
identification of healthy and abnormal tissue near these
regions.
Acknowledgements
No acknowledgement found.References
1. Le
Bihan D. Apparent diffusion coefficient and beyond: what diffusion MR imaging
can tell us about tissue structure. Radiology. 2013;268(2):318–22.
2.
2. Jezzard,
P. Correction of geometric distortion in fMRI data. Neuroimage. 2012;62(2):648–651.
3. Jezzard P, Balaban
RS. Correction for Geometric Distortion in Echo Planar Images from B0 Field
Variations. Magn
Reson Med. 1995;34:65–73.
4. In M-H,
Posnansky O, Beall EB, Lowe MJ, Speck O. Distortion Correction in EPI Using an
Extended PSF Method with a Reversed Phase Gradient Approach. PLoS One.
2015;10:e0116320.