Maxime Chamberland1,2,3, Benoit Scherrer3, Sanjay Prabhu3, Joseph Madsen3, David Fortin4, Kevin Whittingstall2,5, Maxime Descoteaux1, and Simon K Warfield3
1Computer science, Université de Sherbrooke, Sherbrooke, QC, Canada, 2Nuclear Medicine and Radiobiology, Université de Sherbrooke, Sherbrooke, QC, Canada, 3Boston Children's Hospital, Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA, United States, 4Division of Neurosurgery and Neuro-Oncology, Université de Sherbrooke, Sherbrooke, QC, Canada, 5Department of Diagnostic Radiology, Université de Sherbrooke, Sherbrooke, QC, Canada
Synopsis
Streamline tractography algorithms infer connectivity by following directions which are maximally aligned
at every voxel. This rule has even been the
definition of the probability of connectivity, with the difference in current
and next orientation being defined as uncertainty in connectivity. However, our experiments demonstrate that in regions where multiple fiber pathways interdigitate (e.g. temporal lobe), this heuristic is inadequate and does not necessarily reflect the underlying human
brain architecture. Furthermore, we demonstrate that inference
of connectivity can be improved by incorporating anatomical knowledge of the
expected fiber orientation in regions where this information is known. We
applied this heuristic through a new tractography region of interest (ROI) and
demonstrate that it provides improved delineation of the expected anatomy. Purpose
Connections of white matter are typically
inferred from diffusion MRI using deterministic or probabilistic tractography
algorithms
1-4. These algorithms operate by taking as input orientation
distributions functions, or a set of peaks, and by connecting adjacent voxels based
on peaks that are maximally aligned
1. However, not all fascicles are
organized so that peaks along their course in the brain are maximally aligned.
A perfect example of such caveat is the Meyer’s loop (ML), a highly curved fascicle known to exhibits a narrow turn,
kissing/crossing regions, and changes in fascicle dispersion
5. This fascicle
is well understood from conventional
Klinger dissection and histological
analysis, and yet, the virtual reconstruction of the ML with tractography
typically remains incomplete. Common methods encode our knowledge of the
anatomy by solely using Boolean ROIs
6 to include or exclude
streamlines. We hypothesise that a new magnetic-ROI can help incorporate a priori information about the course of
the pathway and lead to an improved delineation of the ML. The
main goals of MAGNEtic Tractography (MAGNET) are thus to 1) increase the accuracy of tractography by selecting a specific direction
based on a prior anatomical knowledge, and
2) reduce the total streamline calculation
burden by avoiding an exponential search of all possibilities (i.e.
computationally infeasible and inaccurate as it increases the amount of false
positive
4, 7).
Methods
The idea is to provide a preferential direction
given by Vmagnet when a streamline enters a predefined
magnetic-ROI. The most popular tracking equation1 is of the form: Vnext = argmink α(Vin ,Vk) (eq. 1), where Vnext is the next direction to propagate and α is the angle
between the incoming direction Vin and the orientation of the
kth peak Vk in the voxel. Instead, when tracking inside the new magnetic-ROI, we propose to follow the
Vk
that is most aligned with Vmagnet. The propagation
equation becomes then: Vnext = { argmink α(Vmagnet,Vk)
if inside the magnetic-ROI; eq. 1 otherwise }. If a
voxel contains a single direction, the propagation naturally resumes with eq. 1.
To measure the effect of our new evolution equation, MAGNET was applied on
simulated data and on in vivo data
obtained from 15 control subjects (10.2±3.1 years).
Synthetic dataset: A noiseless synthetic
dataset consisting of 2 bundles crossing at 45° was generated using Phantomas8.
A seed-ROI (Fig. 1a, purple box) and a magnetic-ROI (Fig. 1a, red box) were
positioned in the peaks field. Streamline propagation was then qualitatively
observed by activating MAGNET in real-time9.
Human datasets: Diffusion
scans were performed using a multi-direction (90) and multi-b-value (range:
400-3000) scheme (TR/TE: 5700/89 ms, 1.7 × 1.7 × 2 mm3, CUSP9010)
on a Siemens 3T Trio MRI. Multi-fiber model estimation was done using Diffusion
Compartment Imaging (DCI)11, resulting in up to 3 main peaks per
voxel. Tractography of the left optic radiation was performed using the
following parameters: step size: 1 mm, θmax: 45°, maximum consecutive
steps in the cortex: 5, min/max length: 60/200 mm. White matter/grey matter
masks extracted from subject-specific anatomical T1-weighted images (1 mm
isotropic) were used as tracking masks4. 3375 seeds were
interactively9 placed anterolaterally to the left
lateral geniculate nucleus (LGN)5,
with initial seed direction oriented in the left direction (Fig 2a, "S"). An
inclusion (AND) planar-ROI positioned at the midbody of the optic radiation and
an exclusion (NOT) sagittal plane acted as filtering regions. To maximize the
extent and coverage of the ML, magnetic-ROIs were then placed around the
medial, anterior and lateral tip of the ML (Fig. 2a, b). These magnetic-ROIs favored
the selection of DCI peaks that were oriented toward the visual cortex.
Results
Fig. 1 shows the effect of MAGNET on synthetic
data. Activating the magnetic-ROI enabled specific selection of DCI peaks oriented
toward the 45° pathway (Fig. 1c). Fig. 2 illustrates the magnetic-ROIs
positioning for a single subject, as well as a conventional view of ML
tractography. Fig.3 qualitatively shows that MAGNET successfully recovered a
larger extent of ML for 15 subjects compared to traditional Boolean ROIs.
Corresponding quantitative results are summarized in Tab.1. Finally, Fig. 4
shows an accurate comparison between MAGNET-based delineation of ML and
histological drawing.
Conclusion
We showed that MAGNET can accurately reconstruct
ML in all subjects. It effectively improved streamline coverage, and significantly
reduced the ML-temporal pole and ML-inferior horn distances, crucial
information for preoperative planning of temporal lobe surgery
12. In
future work, we plan to apply the magnetic operator inside automatically
segmented anatomical structures (e.g. parcels). Our MAGNET technique is
expected to enable unprecedented delineation of neural circuits not visible with
conventional tracking algorithms.
Acknowledgements
The authors thank Chantal M. W. Tax for useful discussions.
Maxime Chamberland is supported by the Alexander Graham Bell Canada Graduate Scholarships-Doctoral Program (CGS-D3) from the Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada (NSERC).
References
1Conturo
et al. (1999) PNAS, 2Parker
et al. (2003) JMRI, 3Sherbondy et al. (2008) J.Vis, 4Girard et al. (2014) Neuroimage, 5Martinez-Heras
et al. (2015) PLoS ONE, 6Wakana
et al. (2004) Radiology, 7Côté
et al. (2013) Medical Image Analysis,
8Caruyer et al. (2014)
ISMRM Milan, 9Chamberland et
al. (2014) Frontiers in Neuroinformatics, 10Scherrer et al. (2012) PLoS ONE, 11Scherrer
et al. (2015), Magnetic Resonance in
Medicine, 12Tax et al. (2014)
PLoS ONE.