High-resolution DTI-based cortical connectome reconstructions match incompletely with true axonal projections in rat brain
Michel R.T. Sinke1, Willem M. Otte1,2, Annette van der Toorn1, R. Angela Sarabdjitsingh3, Marian Joƫls3, and Rick M. Dijkhuizen1

1Biomedical MR Imaging and Spectroscopy Group, Center for Image Sciences, University Medical Center Utrecht, Utrecht, Netherlands, 2Department of Pediatric Neurology, Brain Center Rudolf Magnus, University Medical Center Utrecht, Utrecht, Netherlands, 3Department of Translational Neuroscience, Brain Center Rudolf Magnus, University Medical Center Utrecht, Utrecht, Netherlands

Synopsis

The exact relationship between DTI-based tract representations and true axonal projections remains uncertain. We compared the accuracy of tensor-based and constrained spherical deconvolution (CSD)-based tractography, against neuroanatomical tracer data in rat brain. Our study with high spatial and angular resolution postmortem DTI data revealed low tractography accuracy, characterized by significant amount of false positive and false negative streamline connections. Accounting for crossing fibers by CSD did not significantly improve sensitivity and specificity. Because DTI-based tract reconstructions correlate incompletely with true axonal projections in rat brain, even when using an advanced algorithm like CSD, DTI-based connectomics should be interpreted with care.

Introduction

Diffusion tensor imaging (DTI)-based tractography is one of the cornerstones of the Human Connectome Project, by enabling in vivo mapping of anatomical connections within the brain [1]. However, the exact relationship between DTI-based tract representations (streamlines) and true axonal projections remains uncertain. To elucidate this relationship, we compared the accuracy of two tractography approaches in rat brain connectomics against gold standard neuroanatomical tracer data.

Methods

Perfusion-fixed postmortem brains – inside the skull – of ten healthy adult (12-13 weeks) male Wistar rats were positioned in a container filled with proton-free oil (Fomblin®). High spatial and angular resolution DTI (8-shot 3D EPI; TR/TE= 500/32.4 ms; field-of-view = 19.2 x 16 x 33 mm3; voxels = 150 x 150 x 150 µm3; 5 b0 images; diffusion-weighting in 60 non-collinear directions with b = 3842.23 s/mm2; four averages) was conducted on a 9.4T Varian MR scanner. After DTI acquisition, images were non-rigidly aligned to a 3D model of the Paxinos and Watson rat brain atlas. Whole-brain connectomes (50.000 streamlines) were obtained for each animal with conventional diffusion tensor-based tractography and constrained spherical deconvolution (CSD)-based tractography. CSD takes into account the presence of crossing fiber populations and uses 2nd order integration over fiber orientation distributions [2]. Tractography was repeated with different fractional anisotropy (FA) thresholds (0.15, 0.2) and varying maximum angle between tracking steps (10-90°). The overall presence or absence of connecting streamlines between specific cortical regions were compared to findings from a rat brain neuronal tracer database [3] (Figure, left). Reconstruction accuracy was expressed as sensitivity and specificity (i.e. the proportion of correctly identified present (true positive) and absent (true negative) connections; as mean ± standard deviation, at group level).

Results

Tensor-based tract reconstructions had low (between hemispheres) to moderate (within hemispheres) sensitivities to identify connections (Figure, middle). This increased with more liberal tracking angle and lower FA thresholds. Increasing sensitivity occurred at the expense of decreasing specificity. The sensitivity and specificity to identify neuronal projections with CSD were also relatively low, but much less affected by tracking angle and FA threshold (Figure, right).

Discussion

High-resolution DTI-based tractography in rat brains revealed a significant amount of false positive and false negative streamline connections when compared to neuroanatomical tracer data. Comparable degrees of sensitivity and specificity have been shown for standard DTI-based tractography in mice [4]. The current analysis shows that accounting for crossing-fibers – with CSD – does not significantly improve sensitivity and specificity of DTI-based reconstructed cortical projections.

Conclusion

High spatial and angular resolution DTI-based tract reconstructions correlate incompletely with true axonal projections in rat brain, even when using an advanced fiber reconstruction algorithm such as CSD. Similar findings have been reported for rhesus monkey brain [5], suggesting that DTI-based connectomics should be interpreted with care. We suggest that anatomically constrained tractography or global tractography may increase DTI-based connectome accuracy.

Acknowledgements

No acknowledgement found.

References

[1] Poldrack & Farah. Nature. 15 (2015). [2] https://github.com/MRtrix3. [3] Schmitt & Eipert. Neuroinformatics. 10 (2012). [4] Keiferet al; Neuroimage. 15 (2015). [5] Thomas et al; PNAS. 111 (2014).

Figures

Figure



Proc. Intl. Soc. Mag. Reson. Med. 24 (2016)
2037