Robert J Loughnan1,2, Damien McHugh1,3, Hamied A Haroon1, Douglas Garratt2, Rishma Vidyasagar1,4, Hojjatollah Azadbakht1, Penny H Cristinacce1, Geoff JM Parker1,5, and Laura M Parkes1
1Centre for Imaging Sciences, Faculty of Medical and Human Sciences, The University of Manchester, Manchester, United Kingdom, 2School of Physics and Astronomy, The University of Manchester, Manchester, United Kingdom, 3CRUK & EPSRC Cancer Imaging Centre in Cambridge & Manchester, Manchester, United Kingdom, 4Melbourne Brain Centre, The Florey Institute of Neuroscience and Mental Health, Melbourne, Australia, 5Bioxydyn Limited, Manchester, United Kingdom
Synopsis
Diffusion imaging has been used to probe microstructure and
to investigate perfusion via the IVIM
model. However,
the
contribution of microvasculature structure to the diffusion
signal has largely been overlooked. Presented here is a novel
method for imaging blood velocity and capillary segment length using diffusion-weighted images. We apply a model for extracting perfusion parameters from diffusion-weighted images from 23
people with a range of diffusion times (∆=18,
35 and 55ms) and b-values (0-100s/mm2). Mean blood
velocity was significantly slower (P<0.005)
in white matter (0.92±0.03mm/s) compared to
grey matter (0.95±0.04mm/s). Mean vessel segment length was
significantly shorter (P<0.0001) in white matter (7.97±0.13µm) than in grey
matter (10.35±0.20µm). Target Audience:
Clinicians and MRI
physicists interested in probing microvascular structure and diffusion MRI.
Purpose
Diffusion
imaging has been used to probe microstructure and, to
a lesser degree, investigate perfusion. However, the contribution
of microvasculature structure to the diffusion signal has largely been overlooked.
LeBihan’s Intravoxel Incoherent Motion (IVIM) is perhaps the most
well-known approach for modeling microvascular flow[1]. Although its practical
application has been encouraging, there is no clear
link between IVIM measurements and
microvascular structure[2]. Velocity Autocorrelation Theory (VAT) presented by
Kennan et al.[3] shows promise for quantification of microvascular structure
and function using diffusion-weighted images:
$$\frac{S}{S_0}=exp\Big(-\gamma^2 G^2 \frac{\langle \bar{v}^2\rangle}{3}T_0\Omega \Big)\quad\quad(1)$$
Where $$$S/S0$$$ is the signal with/without diffusion weighting, $$$G$$$
is the gradient amplitude, γ is the gyromagnetic ratio, $$$v$$$ is blood velocity, and $$$T_0$$$ is the auto-correlation time. $$$Ω$$$ is a function
of gradient pulse width $$$δ$$$,
spacing $$$Δ$$$ and $$$T_0$$$.
By
collecting a series of scans at varying diffusion times and gradient amplitudes
one can estimate blood velocity ($$$v$$$)
and velocity auto-correlation time ($$$T_0$$$)
on a voxel-wise basis using equation (1). The mean segment length of the
vascular system ($$$L$$$) can also be
computed, as blood velocity ($$$v$$$) and
velocity auto-correlation time ($$$T_0$$$)
are related by equation (2):[3]
$$L=2T_{0}v_{0}\quad\quad(2)$$
where
$$$v_0$$$ is estimated as $$$\sqrt{\langle \bar{v}^2 \rangle}$$$ . The aim of our study was to test this model
on diffusion MRI data in the human brain. The parameter estimates are compared
to the known morphology of the microvasculature.
Methods
Two datasets
were collected on a 3T Philips Achieva scanner using a SE-EPI sequence with
2.4mm isotropic resolution. Eddy current correction was done for all the scans
using FSL.
Dataset 1: 3 Diffusion-Weighted MRI scans were collected
at 3 different diffusion times (∆) from 23 healthy volunteers (25±6.0years) (Table 1a). Voxel-wise maps of $$$v$$$, $$$L$$$ and $$$T_0$$$ were generated for each subject by simultaneously least-squares fitting equations
(1) and (2) across all images within MATLAB. Voxels with high sum-squared errors (mostly CSF)
were set to zero. Paired t-tests were made across all subjects to investigate differences between calculated values of $$$v$$$ & $$$L$$$ in white and grey matter. SPM12 was used to normalise each subject’s $$$v$$$, $$$L$$$ and $$$T_0$$$ map to MNI space to create mean images.
Dataset 2: Diffusion-Weighted MRI scans were collected at
3 different diffusion times and 5 b-values from 1 participant (Table 1b).
Voxel-wise maps of $$$v$$$, $$$L$$$ and $$$T_0$$$ were generated as in dataset 1.
In both datasets, the maximum b-value was 100 s/mm$$$^2$$$ in order to minimise the contribution of diffusion in the extravascular space.
SPM12 was
used for both datasets to segment brain regions into white matter (WM), grey matter (GM)
and CSF to investigate mean values and goodness of fit in each region.
Results
Dataset 1: Across subjects WM had significantly slower (P<0.005) mean blood velocity and significantly shorter (P<0.0001) mean vessel segment length compared to GM. Figure 1 shows the mean capillary segment length image across all 23 subjects normalised to MNI space in dataset 1.
Dataset 2: Figure 2 shows the mean signal attenuation in WM, GM and CSF for
a) ∆=18ms and b) b=100s/mm2 – the lines
indicate the best fits of equation (1). As CSF contains no vascular flow, the model should not fit well here, hence serving as a useful negative control. The plots demonstrate a good fit for WM and GM, but a poor fit in CSF
– sum squared errors were 3.0x10-4, 3.2x10-4 and 0.02 for WM, GM and CSF respectively.
A summary of mean values for both datasets can be found in Table 2.
Discussion
By collecting diffusion-weighted images at a range of
b-values and diffusion times it is possible to obtain images of microvascular
features: blood velocity, auto-correlation time and capillary segment length.
Calculated capillary segment length values are in good agreement with
literature: a confocal microscopy study measured the distribution of capillary segment lengths in
human grey matter
[4] presented a mode of ~10µm, in good agreement with our mean capillary segment lengths in
grey matter of 10.3±0.2µm and 8.89±5.10µm for
datasets 1 and 2 respectively. Acquisition times for data presented here are
fast with dataset 2 taking ~6 minutes to acquire. Quantification of microvascular properties could
be important in diseases that affect vascular microstructure such as
Alzheimer’s disease and cancer. Alzheimer’s disease has been linked to longer
distances between branch points in capillary networks
[5] and tumours with
greater microvascular proliferations and increased heterogeneity of microvascular structure and function
[6]. The imaging presented here may be
sensitive to these changes.
Acknowledgements
This work is supported by the EPSRC Sensing and Imaging for Diagnosis of Dementias grant (EP/M005909/1) and the Cancer Imaging Centre in Cambridge & Manchester, which is funded by the EPSRC and Cancer Research UK.
References
[1] D. Le Bihan and R. Turner, The capillary network: a link between IVIM and classical
perfusion. Magn. Reson, Magn. Res. Med. 27, 171-178 (1992).
[2] R. M. Henkelman,
Does IVIM measure classical perfusion?, Magn. Res. Med. 16, 470 (1990)
[3] R. P. Kennan, J-H. Gao, J. Zong and J. C. Gore, A general model of microcirculatory blood flow effects in gradient sensitized, MRI Med. Phy. 21, 539 (1994)
[4] F. Cassot, et al. A Novel Three-Dimensional Computer-assisted Method for a Quantitative Study of Microvascular Networks of the Human Cerebral Cortex, Microcirculation, 13, 1-18 (2006)
[5] S. J. Baloyannis, I. S. Baloyannis, The vascular factor in Alzheimer’s diseas: A study in Gogli Technique and electron microcopy Journal of Neurological Sciences, 322, 117-121 (2012)
[6] J. A. Nagy, S-H Chang, A. M. Dvorak, H. F. Dvorak, Why are tumour blood vessels abnormal and why is it important to know? British Journal of Cancer, 100, 865-869 (2009)