Leandro Beltrachini1 and Alejandro Frangi1
1The University of Sheffield, Sheffield, United Kingdom
Synopsis
In silico studies of diffusion MRI are becoming a standard
tool for testing the sensitivity of the technique to changes in white matter (WM)
structures. To perform such simulations, realistic models of brain tissue
microstructure are needed. However, most of the computational results are
obtained considering straight and parallel cylinders models, which are known to
be too simplistic for representing real-scenario situations. We present a
statistical-driven approach for obtaining random models of WM tissue samples
based on histomorphometric data available in the literature. We show the
versatility of the method for characterising WM voxels representing bundles and
disordered structures.Background
Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) has proven of enormous
value in the investigation of porous media. Its use allows studying pore-size
distributions, tortuosity, and permeability as a function of the NMR sequence
parameters [1]. This information plays an important role for characterising
white matter (WM) tissue in vivo and non-invasively. A complete NMR analysis in
silico involves the solution of the Bloch-Torrey equation over realistic
domains. However, analytically solving this equation becomes intractable for
all but the simplest geometries [1, 2]. To solve this limitation, numerical
algorithms (e.g. [3]) are used for obtaining simulated signals in arbitrary
domains. Nevertheless, geometrical models of WM are usually too simplistic for
representing the real nature of tissue microstructure (e.g. parallel cylinders),
raising doubts on the applicability of the results in live tissue.
Purpose
Develop statistical computational models of tissue blocks of
WM microstructure based on histomorphometric data.
Methods
We based our analysis in axonal structures only, which were
considered as generalised cylinders, i.e. non-straight cylinders with arbitrary
cross-sections [4]. To do so, we create random instances of their axes by means
of a random walk algorithm based on a multivariate von Mises-Fisher
distribution [5]. This allows to consider a global axonal direction (i.e. the direction
from one end of the axon to the other) and a local axonal dispersion (needed
for representing local changes in the direction, i.e. tortuosity). We model the
global axonal direction (i.e. the overall orientation considering all the axons
passing through the voxel) using either parametric (e.g. Watson) or an
arbitrary orientation density function (ODF), the latter described by the
corresponding spherical harmonic decomposition [8]. Such representation is
flexible enough to account for voxels belonging to different parts of the WM. Once
the axes are defined, we assign a mean radii value for each axon according to a
gamma distribution [6].
Then, we model each axon as a B-spline generalised cylinder
using swept surfaces over the simulated axes [4]. This is a general technique
providing flexibility for further generation of surface and volumetric meshes
needed for numerical simulations (e.g. [3, 7]). Once the cylinders are built,
we pack them avoiding intersections by random placement. The procedure is
repeated until reaching a specific volume ratio. All computations were
performed in MATLAB 2015a programming environment (The Mathworks, Natick, MA).
Results
We tested the algorithm in different scenarios represented
by the aforementioned probability distributions, requiring 3 minutes in average
to obtain final results. Figure 1 shows two examples considering the same
parameters but different global orientation density functions. In Figure 1a we
show a random trial with global orientation represented by an arbitrary ODF (i.e.
sampled from an arbitrary voxel extracted from the IIT atlas [8]), whereas in
Figure 1b we considered a uniform distribution on the unitary sphere. It is
noticeable the flexibility of the proposed technique for representing
completely different axon dispositions.
Conclusions
We
developed a method for generating random samples of WM tissue from statistical
data. The main advantage over existing methods is its ability to generate
random samples of WM voxels based on histomorphometric data extracted from
literature. This is a major step forward in representing axonal structures
realistically, which is crucial for testing state-of-the-art diffusion MRI
inverse models without being simplistic. Further work will be focused on
increasing the complexity of the models to consider other neurites and
intra-axonal structures. These models will then be used for simulating
diffusion MRI signals and study its sensitivity to WM changes.
Acknowledgements
The work has been supported by the project OCEAN (EP/M006328/1) funded
by the Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council.References
[1] Price, NMR studies of translational motion, Cambridge,
2009.
[2] Grebenkov, Pulsed-gradient spin-echo monitoring of
restricted diffusion in multilayered structures. J Magn Reson, 205:181-95,
2010.
[3] Beltrachini, Taylor, and Frangi, A parametric finite
element solution of the generalised Bloch Torrey equation for arbitrary
domains. J Magn Reson, 259: 126-34, 2015.
[4] Piegl and Tiller, The Nurbs book, Springer, 1997.
[5] Altendorf and Jeulin, Random-walk-based stochastic
modeling of three-dimensional fiber systems. Physical Review E 83, 041804,
2011.
[6] Perge, Koch, Miller, Sterling, and Balasubramanian, How
the Optic Nerve Allocates Space, Energy Capacity, and Information. The Journal
of Neuroscience, 29:7917-28, 2009.
[7] Hall and Alexander, Convergence and Parameter Choice for
Monte-Carlo Simulations of Diffusion MRI. IEEE TMI, 28:1354-1364, 2009.
[8] Varentsova, Zhang, and Arfanakis, Development of a High
Angular Resolution Di?usion Imaging Human Brain Template. NeuroImage, 91:177-186,
2014.