Tom A Roberts1, Giulia Agliardi1, Andrada Ianus2, Ben Jordan1, James O Breen-Norris1, Rajiv Ramasawmy1, Angela D'Esposito1, Valerie Taylor1, Bernard Siow1, Eleftheria Panagiotaki2, Daniel C Alexander2, Mark F Lythgoe1, and Simon Walker-Samuel1
1Centre for Advanced Biomedical Imaging, London, United Kingdom, 2Centre for Medical Image Computing, London, United Kingdom
Synopsis
Vascular Extracellular and Restricted Diffusion for
Cytometry in Tumours (VERDICT) is a diffusion MRI technique which uses a
3-compartment model to characterise the vascular (V),
extracellular-extravascular (EES) and intracellular (IC) compartments in
tumours. VERDICT allows for quantitation of tumour morphology including
vascular fraction (fv), intracellular fraction (fic) and cellular radius, hence
providing a non-invasive ‘biopsy’ that can be performed longitudinally. Previously,
VERDICT has been applied to subcutaneous mouse tumours1 and human
prostate cancer2. For the first time, we apply VERDICT in a mouse
model of glioma, examine it in the context of other multi-compartment models
and optimise it based on comparison with histological analysis.Purpose
A novel application of the VERDICT diffusion imaging
technique in a mouse brain glioma model for the estimation of cell density and
cell size, and comparison with histological analysis
Synopsis
Animal model: C57BL/6
mice (n=5) were injected with 2x104 GL261 mouse glioma cells into
the right striatum. Imaging was initially carried out 12-14 days post injection
(Day 0) with repeat scanning three days later (Day 3) to examine any
microstructural changes with tumour growth.
MRI: Imaging was
carried out on a 9.4T MRI scanner (Agilent, USA). Ear bars were used to secure
the mice and image without respiration gating. For DWI, a pulsed-gradient spin
echo echo planar imaging (EPI) sequence was used with the following parameters:
TR = 2s, TE = min, DM = 642, FOV = 20mm2, slice thickness
= 0.5mm, slices = 5, shots = 3, averages = 2. In total, 46 diffusion weightings
in 3 directions were acquired in addition to a 42 direction DTI acquisition (b
= 1000 s/mm2), as detailed previously1. Total imaging
time for VERDICT was 60 minutes. After VERDICT, mice were injected with
gadolinium contrast agent and slice-matched T1-weighted spin echo EPI images
were acquired for drawing tumour ROIs (Fig 1c).
Image analysis: Image
processing was carried out using MATLAB. DW images were normalised to their
corresponding B0 image to eliminate T2 effects with variable echo times. For
modelling, the signal across the tumour ROI was averaged and then fitted. The
following models, based on the taxonomy of Panagiotaki et al.3, were
fit to the tumour region delineated on T1-weighted post-Gd images: Ball (ADC), BallBall
(IVIM), Tensor (T), ZeppelinZeppelin (ZZ), ZeppelinCylinder (ZC), BallSphere
(BS), BallBallSphere (BBS), BallSphereAstrosticks (ABS), BallSphereStick (BIS).
All parameters were fitted with constraints detailed by Bailey et al.4.
To assess the best model fits to the data, mean AIC values were calculated
across the five mice, including both Day 0 and Day 3 imaging sessions.
Histology:
Immediately after imaging, mice (n=4) were perfuse-fixed with paraformaldehyde.
Brains were sliced and stained with H&E and NeuN, a neuronal antigen (Fig
2). For histological analysis, intracellular volume fraction (fic) was
estimated by segmenting the tumour in an H&E slice and applying a k-means
clustering threshold: effectively, fic = stained volume/total tumour volume.
Cell radius was estimated by manual segmentation of cells at 40x magnification
(Fig 2a).
Results
In DWI images, contrast between the tumour and normal brain
was subtle (Fig 1b), so post-Gd T1-weighted images were used for tumour ROI
segmentation (Fig 1c). Histology showed a large tumour region within the mouse
brains (Fig 2b). NeuN staining showed very little neuronal presence within
tumours, suggesting that VERDICT would be an appropriate model to fit to this
region. Model comparison (Fig 3) showed that VERDICT (BIS: Ball =
extracellular, Sphere = intracellular, Stick = vascular compartments) with all
parameters unfixed had the lowest AIC value across the cohort. However,
comparison (not shown) of the fitted parameters fic and cell radius with
histological analysis resulted in large discrepancies. Fixing the diffusivities
in the BallSphereStick model (to dBall = 3x10
-9, dSphere = 1.5x10
-9,
dStick = 8x10
-9 m
2/s) resulted in fic and cell radius
values which more accurately reflected the histological analysis (Fig 5 –
purple points). All VERDICT parameters were broadly similar (no significant
differences, Fig 5 – black points) following tumour growth between Day 0 and
Day 3.
Discussion
We present a novel application of the VERDICT MRI technique for
the characterisation of the tumour microenvironment in a mouse model of glioma.
The BallSphereStick model with fixed diffusivities – BIS(f) – best captured the
cellular density and cellular radius of the tumour when compared with
histological analysis, although fixing the extracellular diffusivity (dBall) to
3x10
-9 m
2/s seems unusually high. Future experiments
using a glioma therapy to induce cellular apoptosis and alter the tumour microenvironment
will provide further validation of this model.
Acknowledgements
SWS
is supported by a Wellcome Trust Senior Research Fellowship (grant
WT100247MA).References
(1) Panagiotaki & Walker-Samuel et al. Cancer Res (2014).
(2)
Panagiotaki et al. Invest. Radiol. (2015).
(3)
Panagiotaki et al. Neuroimage. (2012).
(4)
Bailey et al. Abstracts 1082 & 1148. Proc. Intl. Soc. Mag. Reson. Med. 23. (2015).