Cemre Ariyurek1,2, Safa Ozdemir1,2, Arif Sanli Ergun3, Yusuf Ziya Ider1, and Ergin Atalar1,2
1Department of Electrical and Electronics Engineering, Bilkent University, Ankara, Turkey, 2National Magnetic Resonance Research Center (UMRAM), Ankara, Turkey, 3Department of Electrical and Electronics Engineering, TOBB-University of Economics and Technology, Ankara, Turkey
Synopsis
Experimental validation of modes of shear waves in
MR elastography (MRE) is demonstrated. For the first time, frequency response
of the actuator is investigated and actuator displacement is measured. Normalizing
shear wave displacement to the actuator displacement removes the effect of
actuation system and isolates shear wave resonance. It is demonstrated that 10-20
times greater shear wave displacement than applied displacement by the actuator
can be observed at resonance. Thus, safety issues in MRE should be
reconsidered. Presenting repeatability of determining mode frequency validates feasibility
of detecting stiffness changes by observing any shift in mode frequency.Purpose
Previously,
it was demonstrated by simulations that modes of the shear waves can be observed
in the brain during MR elastography (MRE) with high shear wave displacement
values at mode frequencies and change in stiffness causes shift in mode
frequency
1. Purpose of this study is to validate experimentally that
greater shear wave displacement than applied displacement at mode frequency can
be observed and mode frequency shifts when stiffness alters. Thus, observing
shift in mode frequency may mean change in stiffness. In addition, safety
issues in MRE are evoked due to high shear wave displacement at resonance.
Methods
Three
homogeneous phantoms were prepared in spherical flasks having 1L volume using
the same agar-agar powder and following the preparation steps described in a
previous study
2, with agar-agar powder concentrations of 0.65%,
0.75% and 0.85%. From measurement results
2, the shear modulus values of these phantoms are estimated as 6, 7.7 and 10 kPa, respectively. Experiments were conducted in
a 3T Siemens Tim Trio MRI scanner. Using an actuator coil driven by sinusoidal
current under the B
0 field,
phantoms were rotationally vibrated about the y-axis, as shown in Figure 1. The
motion was induced continuously and the frequency of excitation was swept from
25 to 45.5 Hz, with 0.5 Hz steps. Peak-to-peak current applied to the actuator
coil was kept constant during all experiments in the range of 1.75-1.85A. Two
acquisitions were made in each scan using a GRE pulse with motion encoding
gradient (MEG), by switching polarity of the zeroth and first moment nulled MEG,
having same frequency with excitation frequency, in an interleaved fashion. The shear wave displacement images were
formed by taking root of sum of squares (RSS) of two phase difference images at
steady state of shear waves having π/2 phase difference obtained from two scans
for each frequency. Peak of the RSS image was used as a measure of shear wave
displacement magnitude. Detector coils were mounted on the actuator system to
measure the amount of displacement applied by the actuator to the phantoms
3.
As shown in Figure 1, setup was placed approximately 30° tilted with respect to B
0 direction to measure the induced voltage on the
detector coil properly
3. Shear wave displacement was normalized by the
actuator displacement, which was obtained from the measured induced voltage on the detector coil. Central transversal slice of the phantoms were selected for
imaging and MEG was in the slice selection direction. All experiments were repeated
three times in 1-6 weeks to test the repeatability.
Results
To demonstrate an example, results for measurements
of shear wave displacement in the phantom with 0.85% agar-agar concentration,
induced voltage on detector coil, computed displacement of actuator and normalized
shear wave displacement are shown in Figure 2. Normalized displacement images
for the same phantom experiment can be seen in Figure 3. In Figure 4, normalized
displacement plots for all phantoms are depicted. It is expected to observe
peak normalized displacement at mode frequencies, which were found to be 27.5,
29.5 and 34 Hz for 0.65%, 0.75% and 0.85%, respectively, and repeated experiments
yielded the same mode frequencies except third experiment for 0.85% which resulted
with a mode frequency of 34.5 Hz. It can be stated that results are coherent
with previous findings in simulations
1.
Discussion and Conclusion
To the
best of our knowledge, this study analyzes, for the first time, the frequency
response of the actuator coil by sweeping the excitation frequency in MRE. From
Figure 2, it is observed that frequency response of actuator system is not
constant although current applied to actuator coil is kept almost constant. We
argue that this is due to interaction of shear wave and actuator system
resonances. Consequently, output displacement is a combination of two peak
displacements, which correspond to mode of phantom and mode of actuator system
loaded with phantom. At the mode frequency of shear wave, displacement of
actuator is minimum, hence creating a high shear wave displacement for small
input displacement, whereas second peak output displacement is due to peak
displacement applied by the actuator. Using normalization, we were able to
isolate shear wave resonance by removing the effect of actuation system. An important
outcome of this study is that the safety issues in MRE should be reconsidered
4,
as we can observe 10-20 times shear wave displacement of applied displacement in
Figure 4. Repeatability of determining mode frequency has been validated, thus tracking
any shift in mode frequency due to possible stiffness changes is feasible. Our
future work will include applications of our findings to human brain studies.
Acknowledgements
No acknowledgement found.References
[1] Ariyurek C, Ider YZ, Gurler N, Ozdemir S, Emek A, Ergun AS,
Atalar E. Modes of Shear Waves in Brain MR Elastography. In Proceedings of the
22nd Annual Meeting of ISMRM, Milan, Italy, 2014. p. 4270.
[2] Hamhaber U, Grieshaber FA, Nagel JH, Klose U. Comparison of
quantitative shear waves MR-elastography with mechanical compression tests.
Magn Reson Med 2003;49:71–77.
[3] Plewes
DB, Luginbuhl C, Macgowan CK, Sack I. An inductive method to measure mechanical
excitation spectra for MRI elastography. Concept Magn Reson B 2004;21B:32–39.
[4] Ehman EC, Rossman PJ, Kruse SA, Sahakian AV, Glaser KJ.
Vibration safety limits for magnetic resonance elastography. Phys Med Biol
2008;53:925–935.