Joshua M Kuperman1, Nathan S White1, Hauke Bartsch1, Matthew Middione2, Kun Lu3, Thomas Liu3, Terry Jernigan4, Ajit Shankaranarayanan2, and Anders M Dale1,5
1Radiology, University of California, San Diego, La Jolla, CA, United States, 2GE Healthcare, Menlo Park, CA, United States, 3Center for Functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging, University of California, San Diego, La Jolla, CA, United States, 4Center for Human Development, University of California, San Diego, La Jolla, CA, United States, 5Neurosciences, University of California, San Diego, La Jolla, CA, United States
Synopsis
The benefits of the advanced MRI protocols used
in the Human Connectome Project have heretofore only been available on Siemens
MRI scanners. We have designed a Connectome-like protocol, called the Harmonized Human Connectome Protocol, which can utilize MRI scanners from additional vendors, specifically GE and Philips. This protocol is particularly relevant for the Adolescent
Brain and Cognitive Development Study, which aims to scan over 10,000 children
ages 9-10 and follow them longitudinally for ten years. This abstract details the protocol for the GE
MR750 scanner and outlines calibration and correction procedures which can be
used to further reduce unwanted site/scanner effects.Purpose
To design a robust, multi-site, multi-vendor protocol to acquire high resolution structural, functional and diffusion MRI data in a time efficient manner.
Introduction
Over the past several years, the Human Connectome Project
has pioneered a number of advanced MRI acquisition techniques, allowing for the
acquisition of high resolution structural and diffusion MRI scans, as well as
fMRI scans with high spatial and temporal resolution. Unfortunately, such advancements have to this
point only been available on Siemens scanners.
Therefore, we are attempting to extend the benefits of Connectome-style
acquisitions to other major scanner manufacturers. This goal is particularly relevant for the
recently funded Adolescent Brain and Cognitive Development Study (ABCD) which
aims to scan over 10,000 children ages 9-10 and follow them longitudinally for
ten years, with each subject getting scanned every 2 years. Creating a standardized acquisition protocol
that can be performed on multiple scanner platforms provides maximum utility
not only for this ambitious study, but for additional studies that wish to
benefit from the enhanced capabilities of these Connectome-like protocols but
lack the required Siemens hardware. This
abstract will focus on the implementation of what we are calling the Harmonized
Human Connectome Protocol for General Electric MRI scanners, specifically the Discovery
MR750 scanner, though a similar effort has been completed for Philips scanners. To ensure maximum applicability, this
protocol does not require any non-commercially available upgrades. The protocol consists of: 1) a 3D T1-weighted MPRAGE scan, using
prospective motion correction (PROMO)
1; 2) a 3D T2-weighted
variable flip angle fast spin echo scan, also using PROMO; 3) a high angular
resolution diffusion imaging scan, with multiple b-values, and integrated B0
distortion correction (EPIC)
2; 4) high spatial and temporal
resolution resting state and task fMRI scans, with integrated distortion
correction. These pulse sequence
parameters are virtually identical to those used in the Lifespan Human
Connectome Project, with the exception of the diffusion scan, which has been
modified with a larger FOV to minimize phase wrap, and also acquires data at an
additional b-value to better allow for the application of a broader set of post-processing
methods, including bi-tensor fitting and Restriction Spectrum Imaging. To ensure even greater compatibility across sites
and manufacturers for multi-site studies, sites can also participate in a rigorous
cross-site calibration procedure that allows for quantitative characterization
of the effect of sequence parameters, such as inversion time, echo time, flip
angle, and b-value, on imaging signals for each scan modality. This will allow fitting
of parameterized physics-based models for each scanner, and enable more
advanced cross-scanner (and cross-time) correction procedures, even in the
presence of technological change. Additionally, as with the ABCD study, sites can also be provided with the infrastructure to save raw
k-space data, which will allow for the application of future improvements in
reconstruction technology to previously acquired data.
Methods
Protocol development consisted of
iterative scan sessions on GE, Siemens and Philips MRI scanners. Using the Lifespan Human Connectome protocol
as a starting point, changes were introduced to improve image
quality, both in raw images as well as error-corrected post-processed
images. The Harmonized Human Connectome Protocol for GE (see Table 1 for detailed scan parameters) differs mostly in the diffusion scan, with the
expansion of the FOV and the inclusion of an additional b-value.
Quantitative models (Figure 2) were generated
based on multiple diffusion acquisitions on a GE Discovery MR750, with varying
TE and b-value. Diffusion data were fit
to a bi-tensor model, with separate pools for free and restricted diffusion,
each with its own R2.
Results and Discussion
Figure 1 shows multiband diffusion acquisitions for Siemens
(Prisma 3T) and GE (Discovery MR750) scanners in the same subject. These scans show good qualitative similarity,
despite being processed without any site normalization or calibration
techniques. However, in addition to this
qualitatively similar starting point, Figure 2 illustrates our quantitative cross-site normalization procedures as applied to diffusion
MRI, showing an excellent fit of observed data as a function of b-value and TE
with a multi-compartmental mixture model, and their predicted effects on the
derived ADC and FA parameters. The resulting quantitative signal models and
calibration parameters can then be incorporated into the image post-processing methods,
to minimize cross-site effects.
Conclusion
A robust, high-resolution multiband protocol,
similar to the Lifespan Human Connectome protocol, which was previously only
available on Siemens scanners, is possible on a GE MR750 with commercially
available hardware packages. In
addition, the continued development of quantitative calibration procedures
should further reduce site/manufacturer differences in derived diffusion
measures for large, multi-site, multi-vendor studies such as the Adolescent
Brain and Cognitive Development study.
Acknowledgements
This work was supported by NIH (NIDA
U24 DA041123-01) and by funding from General ElectricReferences
1. White, N., et al., PROMO: Real-time prospective motion correction in MRI using image-based tracking. Magn Reson Med, 2010. 63(1), p. 91-105.
2. Holland, D., et al.,
Efficient correction of inhomogeneous static magnetic field-induced distortion in
Echo Planar Imaging, 2010. 50, p. 175-183.