Ali Caglar Özen1, Jan Korvink2, and Michael Bock1
1Dept. of Radiology - Medical Physics, University Medical Center Freiburg, Freiburg, Germany, 2Institute of Microstructure Technology, Karlsruhe Institute of Technology, Karlsruhe, Germany
Synopsis
Concurrent Excitation and Acquisition (CEA) enables MRI with true zero echo times, and full signal acquisition efficiency. However, frequency sweep along readout gradients results in sequential excitation of spins at different locations, thus a unique TR is experienced by each spin at each radial acquisition spoke. In this work, implications of modulations in transverse magnetization as a function of T1, flip angle and TR were investigated for 2D and 3D radial acquisition schemes with equidistant point trajectory, segmented ordering and golden angle ordering. Resulting changes in point spread function (PSF) of a point source located at the edge of the field of view (FOV) were analyzed and discussed.Introduction
Concurrent
Excitation and Acquisition (CEA) was shown to be feasible in MRI at a
preclinical field strength [1] as well as a 3T clinical MR system with transmit
array [2], but the signal acquisition features and contrast mechanisms have not
been addressed comprehensively. In MRI with CEA, frequency modulated
radiofrequency (RF) excitation pulses are applied. Thus, magnetization across
the sample is excited sequentially by the combined action of the magnetic field
gradients and the RF pulse. Gradient directions change during data acquisition
which results in TR variation across the sample (Fig. 1), leading to changes in
transverse magnetization. This signal modulation causes a non-ideal point
spread function (PSF), and is a potential source of artifacts.
In this work,
the T1-modulation effects were investigated for frequency-swept
excitation schemes in CEA, and changes in PSFs of 2D and 3D virtual point
sources were analyzed for various acquisition schemes. Our findings lead to an
optimal approach in designing pulse sequences for CEA, and can be generalized
to other pulse sequences such as SWIFT [3].
Methods
CEA sequences
with a radial inside-out acquisition scheme was simulated for 3 different
k-space ordering methods: (1) Equidistant spokes based on the algorithm
developed in [4], (2) segmented equidistant trajectory with 16 segments, and
(3) the golden angle trajectory. A point source was defined on a 2D grid, and for
each radial acquisition, the effective TR, TReff, was calculated as
a function of distance from isocenter, dn and the default TR (here: 4.2 ms),
assuming a chirp excitation with a sweep range of fo - Δf to fo + Δf over 2 ms along with a constant gradient. Note that
TReff changes from one radial spoke to the next for all off-isocenter
positions. Transverse magnetization (Mxy) was prepared to reach steady state after 200
dummy scans, then, modulations in Mxy
were calculated iteratively as a function of TReff, T1
and the flip angle, α:
$$ M_{n}=M_{n-1}
cos(\alpha) e^{-TR_{eff}(n-1)/T_{1}}+(1-e^{-TR_{eff}(n-1)/T_{1}}) $$
$$ M_{xy}=M sin(\alpha)
$$
Using the central
slice theorem [5], 2D k-space is formed by weighting each radial spoke signal
by the modulation in the magnitude of the Mxy as a result
of the variation in TR. Image reconstruction with zero-order gridding was used
to obtain PSF of the point source located at the edge of FOV on a 512x512 grid. In extension to 3D calculations, similar steps were
followed and PSFs were calculated. Segmentation and golden angle ordering was
applied only along the azimuthal angle. Resulting k-space data was
reconstructed using gridding with Kaiser-Bessel interpolation. PSF comparison
was based on scaling and subtracting the reconstructed data obtained with
T1-modulated magnetization values and the data which was reconstructed under constant TR
assumption.
Results and Discussion
In Fig. 2, TReff
for the three different trajectories and the resulting modulations in Mxy are
shown using a 2D sequence with α=10° for a point source with T1 = 100 ms placed at (x,y)=(150,150) on a 512x512 grid. The oscillations in Mxy is more evident for golden angle trajectory. In
Table 1, resulting amount of change in TReff, Mxy, and the PSF for appoint
source at the edge of the field of view (FOV) are summarized for all 2D and 3D
trajectories for T1 values of 10 and 100 ms and α values of
10° and 30°.
T1-modulation
effects for sequential ordering of equidistant points were below 0.2% for all
conditions. However, with segmented ordering, changes up to 1.8% are calculated
in PSF. Golden angle trajectory resulted in the most extreme modulations in
TReff, Mxy and PSF for majority of the simulated
conditions. The maximum change in PSF of 5.2% was observed for 2D golden angle
trajectory (cf. Fig.3).
As a
result of sequentially satisfying the resonance conditions in frequency-swept
pulses, the k-space representation of the signal is also affected. Although in
most of the cases the PSF-related signal change is less than 5%, modulations can
cause blurring artifacts under extreme conditions (radial segmentation schemes
with lines far apart, short T1, and/or high α). To avoid PSF artifacts, readout gradients should preferably be
adjusted to follow sequential ordering of equidistant points in k-space, and
low flip angles are more preferable.
Acknowledgements
Grant supports from German Research Foundation (DFG) under grant numbers BO 3025/8-1 and LU 1187/6-1 are gratefully acknowledged.References
[1] Idiyatullin
D, Suddarth S, Corum CA, Adriany G, Garwood M (2012) Continuous SWIFT. J Magn
Reson 220:26–31
[2] Özen AC,
Bock M, Atalar E. Active decoupling of RF coils using a transmit array system.
MAGMA in press (2015)
[3] Idiyatullin
D, Corum C, Park JY, Garwood M. Fast and quiet MRI using a swept
radiofrequency. J Magn Reson 181(2):342–349 (2006)
[4] Saff EB,
Kuijlaars ABJ (1997) Distributing many points on a sphere. Math Intell
19(1):5–11
[5] Nishimura,
D. G. (1996). Principles of magnetic resonance imaging. Stanford, Calif:
Stanford Univ.