Kousaku Saotome1, Akira Matsushita1, Koji Matsumoto2, Yoshiaki Kato3, Kei Nakai4, Yoshiyuki Sankai5, and Akira Matsumura4
1Center for Cybernics Research, University of Tsukuba, Tsukuba, Japan, 2Department of Radiology, Chiba University Hospital, Chiba, Japan, 3Medical Technology Department, Kameda General Hospital, Kamogawa, Japan, 4Department of Neurosurgery, University of Tsukuba, Tsukuba, Japan, 5Faculty of Engineering, Information and Systems, University of Tsukuba, Tsukuba, Japan
Synopsis
Our purpose is to develop the novel brain phantom including low contrast and
to verify its potential to emphasize the motion correction effects in
PROPELLER.
Our proposed phantom set would allow not only to add the ability to low
contrast objects but also to provide exact rotations instead of a healthy volunteer.
The making process of the phantom
consists of making profile curves, transforming to depths of the convexo-concave, printing using 3-D
printer, and pouring agarose. This is the
novel phantom making process.PURPOSE
A fast spin echo sequence based on the Periodically
Rotated Overlapping ParallEL Lines with Enhanced Reconstruction (PROPELLER)
technique with motion correction algorithm is the powerful tool against head
motion.
1 In the past studies, a high contrast geometric phantom was
used to evaluate the PROPELLER technique. However, it is not enough to evaluate
its ability to clinical image including low contrast area.
2 Our
purpose is to develop the novel brain phantom including low contrast and to
verify its potential to emphasize the motion correction effects in PROPELLER.
METHODS
[The process of making the phantom] A
transverse of fast spin echo T
2-weghted image (T
2WI) in
basal ganglia (model image) was acquired in a subject (female, 36 years) using
3.0T MRI unit (Achieva 3.0T-TX, Philips, the Netherlands). To achieve low
contrasts similar to the brain, profile curves were made in all line on the
model image (Fig. 1). Then, the profile curves were flipped vertical and the
signal intensities were transformed to depths between 0 to 6 mm, which were
rebuild to cross sections of the phantom (Fig. 2). The rebuild data was sent to
the 3-D printer (Objet Eden350V, Stratasys, USA), and printed by the plastic
(FullCure810 Vero Clear). Then, agarose gel was poured onto the convexo-concave
surface on the printed material. Furthermore, a fast spin echo T
2WI of
a single slice (6 mm thickness) that was planed to the convexo-concave of the
phantom was acquired. The correlation coefficient between the model image and
the phantom image was estimated using MATLAB 8.1.604/R2013a (Mathworks Inc., Natick, MA,
USA).
[Assessment of motion correction
effect] The phantom was set on the
driver system, which is the MR-compatible homemade turntable, to produce roll
rotations. Then, following two trials were conducted using PROPELLER
acquisitions (fast spin echo T
2WI: TR = 4000 ms, TE = 111 ms, slice
thickness = 6 mm, MultiVane percentage = 160%, total scan duration = 72 s,
number of blades = 18). 1) The phantom was rolled once (10, 30, 60, 90-degrees)
at half of acquisition time to show the angular dependency of motion
correction. 2) The phantom was rolled back and forth between 0-degree and
30-degree during acquisition to show the frequency dependency of motion
correction (1 to 18 times).
RESULTS
Figure 3 shows (A) the appearance
of the phantom without agarose, (B) theT
2WI of the phantom. The correlation coefficient between the
model image and the T
2WI of the phantom was 0.937. Figure 3A shows the images in the angular
dependent trial that indicate the difference of two images overlap depending on
the angle. The ability to overlap in motion correction algorithm does not work
when rolled angle is larger. Figure 3B shows the images in 2, 4, 8, and 16 times in
the frequent dependent trial that indicate the difference of image blurring
depending on the frequent. As the frequency increased, the blurring increased.
DISCUSSIONS
Our proposed phantom
could achieve signal intensities close to the T
2WI of the human brain including
low contrast using partial volume effect in a slice plane. In previous works, basic studies for PROPELLER have been
quantitatively and visually evaluated using a high contrast geometric phantom
and healthy volunteers who were given instructions to shake their head
throughout PROPELLER acquisition. However, there are limitations to healthy
volunteers to repeatedly move their heads in almost exactly the same way. This is incredibly inconvenient for
understanding the utility of PROPELLER technique in clinical use. Therefore, the phantom
with the driver system would allow not only to add the ability to low contrast
objects but also to provide exact rotations instead of a healthy volunteer. The making process of the phantom consists of making
profile curves, transforming to depths of the convexo-concave, printing
using 3-D printer, and pouring agarose. This is the novel phantom making process. T
2WIs of the phantom could
demonstrate the potential of showing the angular and frequent dependency of
PROPELLER technique. Further investigations using our phantom would help the
comparison of different PROPELLER techniques and different scanners (e.g., in
multicenter studies) and to improve the robust motion corrected PROPELLER.
CONCLUSION
We developed the novel
brain phantom and indicated its potential for the PROPELLER with motion
correction.
Acknowledgements
This work was supported by the “Center
for Cybernics Research (CCR) – World Leading Human-Assistive Technology Supporting
a Long-Lived and Healthy Society” granted through the “Funding Program for
World-Leading Innovative R&D on Science and Technology (FIRST Program)”
initiated by the Council for Science and Technology Policy (CSTP). In addition, this
work was supported by the Japan Authorize Organization for Magnetic Resonance
Technological Specialist (JMRTS). Finally, the author is grateful to Yoshihiro Ozaki,
Tomoyuki Hasegawa and Hiroki Tsuchiya for assistance with experiments. References
[1] Pipe JG, et al. Magn Reson Med, 42(5): 963-9 (1999)
[2]
Liu Z,
et al. J Magn Reson Imaging 39: 700-707 (2014)