Melvyn B Ooi1,2, Dinghui Wang2, Ashley G Anderson III2, Zhiqiang Li2, Nicholas R Zwart2, Ryan K Robison2, and James G Pipe2
1Philips Healthcare, Cleveland, OH, United States, 2Imaging Research, Barrow Neurological Institute, Phoenix, AZ, United States
Synopsis
Spiral
MRI enables long sampling durations but at the cost of increased sensitivity to
B0-field fluctuations. For example, scanner B0-drift will be observed in spiral
MRI as a time-varying component of image blurring. A spiral deblurring strategy
is presented where a reference B0 map is acquired at the start of the spiral
exam; F0 navigators then quickly measure B0 drift over the course of the spiral
exam, and are used to calculate B0-drift corrected B0-maps for deblurring of
the current scan. F0-navigator accuracy is verified with independent B0-map
acquisitions, and improved spiral deblurring is shown for a structural brain
scan.Purpose
Spiral
MRI acquisitions1,2 can achieve a long sampling duration τ vs. standard Cartesian methods, allowing them to concurrently decrease
scan time while also increasing image SNR3.
However, increasing τ comes at the expense of increased sensitivity to B0-field
inhomogeneities, which cause image blurring. This sensitivity is further
compounded by the scanner's inherent B0 drift, which can be observed as a
time-dependent change in center-frequency ΔF0(t)
under gradient loading. Nevertheless, if an accurate B0 map is known at the time
of the spiral scan, this may be used to remove the blurring artifact during image reconstruction4.
The current work is part of a larger spiral project
whose goal is to achieve a comprehensive, routine brain exam with spiral MRI.
For this spiral exam, we propose a two-stage deblurring strategy: (stage 1) a reference B0 map, B0ref,
is acquired at the start of the exam. However, due to B0 drift, B0ref may not accurately
reflect the B0 field observed by a later spiral scan; deblurring using B0ref would then result in
residual blurring artifact. It would be time prohibitive to acquire a B0 map
prior to every spiral scan, therefore (stage 2) F0 navigators (F0-nav) are used
to quickly measure the DC component of B0 drift over time in order to estimate a corrected B0 map, B0corr, for deblurring of the
current spiral scan.
Methods
The F0-nav (~ 3 s) consists of STIR fat
suppression, RF excitation, followed by four adiabatic refocusing
pulses (two each in two orthogonal directions5) to volumetrically excite and measure the water
resonance frequency. Experiments were performed on a Philips Ingenia 3T scanner.
Experiment 1 was designed to
validate F0-nav measurements in the presence of B0 drift. A block of 3 scans (B0
map, s1, s2) was repeated 9 times on a Philips resolution phantom, with an F0-nav
inserted at the end of each scan. B0 maps (3D-FFE mDIXON, res
= 2 mm3, acq = 3, ΔTE = 0.7 ms, T = 86 s) were used to independently verify the accuracy of the F0-navs,
while s1, s2 were spiral scans used to establish heavy gradients duty cycle
conditions. Gradient temperature was also recorded in real-time via temperature
probes at 6 locations.
Experiment 2
demonstrates F0-navs for improved deblurring in a typical spiral
brain exam. B0ref was
acquired at the start of the exam, followed by a series of anatomical spiral
scans based on spherically-distributed spiral (SDS) trajectories6, with an F0-nav inserted at the end of each
scan. For each scan t, ΔF0(t) = F0(t) –
F0ref, where F0(t) is
the F0-nav measurement at the end of scan t,
and F0ref is the center
frequency for B0ref. We
then have B0corr(t) = B0ref + ΔF0(t), where B0corr(t) is the B0-drift corrected B0-map. B0corr(t) is then used in a conjugate-gradient
algorithm4 for deblurring and water/fat separation of scan
t.
Results
Data from experiment 1, 2 are shown in Fig. 1,
2, respectively. In Fig. 1, B0
drift measured by F0-navs (ΔF0) and B0-maps (ΔB0) are
in good agreement, with error = 2.4±2.0 Hz (mean±std). Increase in gradient temperature and B0 drift directly correlate with
gradient activity (green bars), while the time to return to resting values is
on the order of ~ 10 min for gradient temperatures and ~ 1 hr for B0 drift. In Fig. 2, an example spiral scan is
shown ~ 30 min into the spiral exam where ΔF0 = 32 Hz. Image quality is significantly
improved with spiral deblurring using B0corr
(bottom) vs. B0ref (top).
Conclusion
Short
F0-navs successfully track B0 drift over time (Fig. 1), enabling a spiral deblurring
strategy where only an initial B0 map needs to be acquired. B0 maps showed only small spatial
variations over time, suggesting that B0 drift can largely be characterized by
the F0-nav’s DC measurement alone. We observed a B0 drift ~ 2.2 Hz/min under
the max gradient load evaluated (Fig. 1, 0–25 min), which is consistent with
other MR vendors7, and necessitates compensation especially for
spiral MRI due to its sensitivity to off-resonances.
A B0 map with B0 drift correction, B0corr, is shown to improve spiral deblurring (Fig. 2) using data from an F0-nav at the end of the scan. This
strategy may be extended by inserting an F0-nav at both scan start and end, and interpolating between them to estimate the F0 for each spiral arm; intra-scan correction may then be
performed by demodulating each spiral arm by its corresponding F0. These B0 drift correction methods will be
particularly beneficial for long τ
scans, and heavy gradient duty-cycle applications.
Acknowledgements
This
work is funded by Philips Healthcare.References
1. Ahn CB, Kim JH, Cho ZH.
High-speed spiral-scan echo planar NMR imaging-I. IEEE Trans Med Imaging
1986;5(1):2-7.
2. Meyer
CH, Hu BS, Nishimura DG, Macovski A. Fast spiral coronary artery imaging. Magn
Reson Med 1992;28(2):202-213.
3. Pipe
JG, Robison RK. Simplified Signal Equations for Spoiled Gradient Echo MRI.
Proceedings of the 18th Annual Meeting of ISMRM. Stockholm, Sweden2010. p 3114.
4. Wang
D, Zwart NR, Li Z, Schar M, Pipe JG. Analytical three-point Dixon method: With
applications for spiral water-fat imaging. Magn Reson Med 2015.
5. Shen
J, Rycyna RE, Rothman DL. Improvements on an in vivo automatic shimming method
[FASTERMAP]. Magn Reson Med 1997;38(5):834-839.
6. Turley
DC, Pipe JG. Distributed spirals: a new class of three-dimensional k-space
trajectories. Magn Reson Med 2013;70(2):413-419.
7. Benner
T, van der Kouwe AJ, Kirsch JE, Sorensen AG. Real-time RF pulse adjustment for
B0 drift correction. Magn Reson Med 2006;56(1):204-209.