Bridgette Webb1, Thomas Widek1, Bernhard Neumayer1, Rudolf Stollberger2, and Thorsten Schwark1,3
1Ludwig Boltzmann Institute for Clinical Forensic Imaging, Graz, Austria, 2Institute of Medical Engineering, Graz University of Technology, Graz, Austria, 3Institute of Legal Medicine, Medical University of Graz, Graz, Austria
Synopsis
MRI evaluation of a
post-mortem reperfused cardiovascular system requires a complete filling of
vessels, acceptable contrast/image quality and consideration of temperature influences. Assessment of the temperature dependence of
viscosity, T1 and T2 of candidate perfusates (n=10) found 3 to be suitable for
application in post-mortem MR angiography. Bloch equation simulations were
applied to investigate contrast between these liquids and post-mortem
myocardium at 1, 8.5, 16 and 23°C. For a FLASH sequence, optimal flip angles
were affected by temperature variation and a decrease in contrast (max. 6-12%) was
observed when flip angles optimised for one of the other temperatures were
applied.Purpose
Post-mortem evaluation of
ischemic heart disease involves an examination of the coronary arteries, for
occlusions, and myocardium, for signs of ischemia.
1The
technical feasibility of post-mortem MR angiography (PMMRA) was previously demonstrated
in a small cohort.
2 Its
quality relies on a complete filling of the vessels of interest, as well as on
attainable contrast and image quality in MRI.
Perfusate suitability therefore depends on viscosity and relaxation
parameters under the additional consideration of cadaver temperature. To
develop an approach to PMMRA, this work investigated the viscosity, T1 and T2
of different liquids considered potentially suitable for achieving post-mortem
reperfusion of the vascular system over a relevant temperature range. Additionally,
simulations to explore contrast with post-mortem myocardium were performed.
Methods
Relaxation parameters and dynamic
viscosity of candidate liquids (n=10) were characterised at different
temperatures between 1 and 23°C. For measurements in MRI, samples were placed
in a water bath with regulated temperature (1, 8.5, 16 and 23°C) and scanned at
3T (Skyra, Siemens AG) using TIR and multi-echo SE sequences (Table 1). For
data analysis (T1, T2) mono-exponential models were fitted. Temperature was
monitored using a real-time fibre optic temperature sensor. Dynamic viscosity
values were obtained through conversion of density and kinematic viscosity
measurements (Ubbelohde viscometer) performed at 8, 10 and 20°C. Temperature dependence
of T1, T2 and dynamic viscosity was modelled using quadratic fits. Bloch
equation simulations (FLASH) were performed for selected liquids using the
characterised relaxation times and literature values for post-mortem myocardium
3 at
1, 8.5, 16 and 23°C. At each temperature, contrast between selected liquids and
post-mortem myocardium was examined for flip angles between 0-90° (integer
values) using three different repetition times (TR=50, 100 and 150ms). For the TR
with best overall contrast (150ms), flip angles maximising contrast between a
given liquid and post-mortem myocardium were calculated for each temperature. For
each liquid, these flip angles were then applied across the entire temperature
range to explore the effect of temperature on contrast differences due to
selection of an optimal flip angle corresponding to one of the other
investigated temperatures.
Results
The temperature dependence
of sample relaxation times and viscosity was successfully described by the
established quadratic models, with all fits producing excellent adjusted R² values
(Table 2, Figure 1). Mineral oil, paraffin oil, Angiofil® and the paraffin
oil/Angiofil® mixture showed only a slight to moderate positive correlation
between temperature and T1. All samples except silicon showed a similar, positive
correlation between temperature and T2. Dynamic viscosity of the liquids was
negatively correlated with temperature, with mineral oil, paraffin oil,
Angiofil® and the paraffin oil/Angiofil® mixture demonstrating moderate
temperature dependence. Due to these
results, mineral oil, paraffin oil and a paraffin oil/Angiofil® mixture were
selected for the simulations.
Bloch
equation simulations demonstrated that maximum contrast with post-mortem
myocardium would be achievable using mineral oil (Figure 2). As seen in this
figure, paraffin oil and a mixture of paraffin oil and Angiofil® performed
similarly, with contrast in the worst case 6.5% less than mineral oil (TR=150
ms at 23°C). The simulated results additionally demonstrated the influence of
temperature on the optimal flip angle required to achieve maximum contrast
between liquids and post-mortem myocardium (Figure 3). Optimal flip angles were
found to be higher at lower temperatures and varied by up to 10° across the
investigated temperature range for a given liquid. Differences in contrast due
to the selection of a flip angle corresponding to the optimal flip angle at a different
temperature were moderate (max. 6-12%, depending on the sample (Figure 4)).
Discussion
The established models
reliably describe the behaviour of dynamic viscosity, T1 and T2 for potentially
PMMRA-suitable liquids over a forensically relevant temperature range. The
dynamic viscosity of a liquid is a critical determinant for the calibre of the
vessels which can be filled in post-mortem angiography.
4 Dynamic
viscosities in the range of 15mPa.s
5 to
65mPa.s are preferred at 20°C. Adaption of post-mortem MRI protocols depending
on cadaver temperature is facilitated by a minimal temperature dependence of
perfusate relaxation parameters (Table 2). Additionally, a generally short T1 was
preferred. Based on these criteria,
mineral oil, paraffin oil and the paraffin/Angiofil® mixture were deemed
suitable. Simulations indicated a moderate decrease in contrast when flip
angles optimised for other temperatures were applied, meaning that for a given
perfusate, consideration of temperature is recommended when selecting the flip
angle to avoid loss of contrast.
Conclusion
The temperature-dependent
characterisation of physical and MRI properties of candidate liquids performed
in this work provides essential information for the simulation and development
of MRI protocols in post-mortem MR angiography research.
Acknowledgements
Bridgette Webb is the recipient of a DOC Fellowship of the
Austrian Academy of Sciences at the Ludwig Boltzmann Institute for Clinical
Forensic Imaging.References
1. Fineschi V , Silver M and Baroldi G, Pathology of the Heart and
Sudden Death in Forensic Medicine. 2006: CRC Press. 255-270.
2. Ruder T, Hatch G, Ebert L, et
al., Whole Body Postmortem Magnetic
Resonance Angiography. Journal of Forensic Sciences. 2012; 57: 778-782.
3. Zech W.-D., Schwendener N, Persson A, et
al., Temperature dependence of postmortem
MR quantification for soft tissue discrimination. European Radiology. 2015;
25(8): 2381-2389.
4. Grabherr S, Grimm J, Baumann P, et
al., Application of contrast media in
postmortem imaging (CT and MRI). La radiologia medica. 2015; 120(9): 824-834.
5. Jackowski C, Bolliger S, Aghayev E, et
al., Reduction of postmortem
angiography-induced tissue edema by using polyethylene glycol as a contrast
agent dissolver. Journal of Forensic Sciences. 2006; 51: 1134-1137.