Nicolas Geades1, Amal Samaraweera2, William Morley1, Matthew Cronin3, Nikos Evangelou2, Penny Gowland1, and Olivier Mougin1
1Sir Peter Mansfield Imaging Centre, University of Nottingham, Nottingham, United Kingdom, 2Division of Clinical Neuroscience, Queen’s Medical Centre, University of Nottingham, Nottingham, United Kingdom, 3Brain Imaging and Analysis Centre, Duke University, Durham, NC, United States
Synopsis
This study presents a method of acquiring quantitative MT and NOE
concentration percentages of MS lesions over a period of 30 weeks. MT and NOE
mean percentages were compared for WM lesion ROIs and NAWM ROIs, showing a
clear drop of both MT and NOE when a lesion appears, followed by a gradual
increase in concentrations in the following weeks, indicating remyelination.
The fitting results are backed by a parallel repeatability study which shows
the repeatability of the method and its noise levels. The results indicate that
NOE fitting is very robust against variations in B1 compared to fitting MT.Purpose
In Multiple Sclerosis (MS), an abnormal immune system response produces
inflammation in the central nervous system which causes damage to the
underlying nerve fibre in the form of demyelination. Focal lesions have long been observed with MRI, for instance using the Fluid Attenuated Inversion
Recovery (FLAIR) sequence. Previous studies have attempted to quantify the demyelination process with estimation of the macromolecular proton fraction [1]
or quantitative MT (qMT) [2] but recent advances in Magnetization Transfer (MT)
and Chemical Exchange Saturation Transfer (CEST) have provided [3,4] robust methods
of quantifying processes that are thought to be strongly linked to myelination,
in particular MT and the Nuclear Overhauser Effect (NOE).
Aim
to track MS lesion evolution quantitatively using MT, NOE [4] in a
longitudinal study
Methods
Acquisition: With appropriate ethics
approval, 4 patients with Multiple Sclerosis were scanned using a 7T
Philips Achieva system with a 32 channel receiver coil. Each patient was
scanned 6 times with 6 weeks between scans (30 weeks total, scanning is ongoing).
For each subject z-spectra scans were acquired at 2 different B1 saturation
powers together with B0 and B1 maps, a PSIR used as a pseudo T1 map, a T2* map and a high resolution FLAIR for accurate
tracking of the lesions. All scan parameter details can be found in [4].
Fitting: For each subject visit, B0
corrected z-spectra were fitted pixel-wise for the amplitude of 3 pools (MT,
NOE and APT) relative to water, calculating the sum of squares difference
between the measured spectra and the spectra in a database of Bloch simulated
spectra. The B1 and T1 maps were used to correct B1 and T1 effect on the spectra.
FLAIR images were used to track MS lesions and create masks for ROI processing.
Mean percentage MT and NOE pool sizes in an ROI drawn where white matter lesions
appeared during the 30 weeks were compared to regions of normal appearing white
matter close to the lesion site.
Validation: A separate parallel study was
conducted where three healthy volunteers were scanned three times each, at 3
powers to assess the accuracy and repeatability of the fitting method.
Results
Figure 1 shows an example of an MS lesion that appears in visit 4 and
gradually shrinks in the next two visits. Both MT and NOE ROI results show an
initial reduction followed by a gradual increase of signal indicating either
remyelination or reduction of oedema. This effect is seen in both
the centre of the lesion core and periphery which is also seen on the FLAIR
image. Figure 2 shows the results from four more lesions. Figure 2a and b show lesions
that appears in visit 3 and 2 respectively and then shrinks. Figure 2c shows an
existing lesion that shrinks and completely disappears by visit 4. Figure 2d
shows a pre-existing lesion with very little change between visits. The quantitative
MT and NOE ROI results concord with the changes seen in the anatomical images.
Figure 3 shows a GM lesion that gradually shrinks. The results show some
increase in concentration particularly for MT but they are within noise,
probably because of the low concentrations of NOE and MT in healthy GM.
These GM results show that the method is sensitive enough to pick up
changes in small GM lesions. Figure 4 shows the results from the repeatability study. The ROIs used
here are the splenium (back), genu (front) and truncus (top) of the Corpus
Callosum (CC). There is significant inter subject variability in these data,
but the intra subject variability validates the results of figure 1 and indicates
the level of noise in the fingerprinting fit.
Discussion
The repeatability study shows intra subject variability of less than 1%
NOE and around 1.5% for MT. The data also demonstrated that NOE fitting is very
robust against variations in B1 compared to fitting MT.
These results give confidence to the longitudinal study findings which
show a concentration change of up to 5% for NOE and up to 10% for MT during
lesion formation and repair or resorption (figure 1c). Figure 2c is
particularly interesting as it shows full remyelination of an MS lesion, with
MT concentrations rising from 4% back to a standard level of around 10%. Mismatches between NOE and MT (for instance
in figure 1) might allow us to separate demyelination from oedma.
Conclusion
Quantitative
z-spectrum analysis can provide quantitative information on the evolution of MT and NOE
proton pool concentrations in MS lesions. Such quantitative studies might allow
us to separate changes in myelination and oedema.
Acknowledgements
Supported by the Initial
Training Network, HiMR, funded by the FP7 Marie Curie Actions of the European
Commission (FP7-PEOPLE-2012-ITN-316716) and the Medical Research CouncilReferences
1. Davies GR et al., Estimation of
the macromolecular proton fraction and bound pool T2 in multiple sclerosis, Mult
Scler. 2004 Dec;10(6):607-13.
2. Ives R. Levesque et al., Quantitative
Magnetization Transfer and Myelin Water Imaging of the Evolution of Acute
Multiple Sclerosis Lesions, Magnetic Resonance in Medicine 63:633–640 (2010)
3. Zaiss M. et al., Inverse
Z-spectrum analysis for spillover-, MT-, and T1 -corrected steady-state pulsed
CEST-MRI--application to pH-weighted MRI of acute stroke, NMR Biomed. 2014
Mar;27(3):240-52. doi: 10.1002/nbm.3054
4. Geades N. et al., CEST analysis
via MR fingerprinting, Proc. Intl. Soc. Mag. Reson. Med. 23 (2015), 0780