Xin Xu1, Jia Liu2, and Qiyong Gong2
1Department of Psychiatry, Huaxi MR Research Center(HMRRC),West China Hospital of Sichuan Universityl, Chengdu, China, People's Republic of, 2Department of Radiology, Huaxi MR Research Center(HMRRC),West China Hospital of Sichuan Universityl, Chengdu, China, People's Republic of
Synopsis
To our knowledge, this is the first study
to pool VBM studies for a meta-analysis of grey matter differences among the treatment-sensitive depression (TSD), treatment-resistant
depression (TRD) and health control (HC) by using anisotropic effect-size
signed differential mapping (AES-SDM).
Although both TRD and TSD groups showed abnormal
grey matter in frontal and temporal cortex, the exact brain regions were mostly
different in both groups except the left inferior
frontal gyrus (IFG). Furthermore, grey matter volume reductions in the
bilateral cingulate cortex were only observed in the TRD group.Purpose
To investigate grey
matter differences among the treatment-resistant depression (TRD) treatment-sensitive
depression (TSD) and health control (HC).
Methods
A systematic search was conducted up to 2015 to
identify studies focus on TSD patients or TRD patients. Grey matter differences
between the patients and HC were analyzed by using anisotropic effect-size
signed differential mapping (AES-SDM). AES-SDM is a voxel-based meta-analytic
approach (Radua J, et al, 2014) that uses the reported anisotropic kernels to re-create maps of the
effect size of group differences in grey matter. Moreover, AES-SDM also allows meta-analytic
group comparisons (Radua J, et al, 2013) , which provide an indication of where computed effect sizes
differ significantly between groups. So the similarities and differences between
the TSD and TRD groups were also identified by effect size comparison and
conjunction analysis.
Results
A total of 10 datasets
met the inclusion criteria (see Figure 1 for details). Results were combined to identify grey matter
abnormalities in TRD group compared with HC across 6 datasets (140 patients vs.
152 control subjects) and TSD group compared with HC across 8 datasets (183 patients
vs. 292 control subjects). A group comparison of TRD patients with HC (see Figure 2 for details) revealed
grey matter volume reductions in the bilateral median cingulate cortex (MCC),
anterior cingulate cortex (ACC), the left inferior frontal gyrus (IFG), superior
temporal gyrus (STG), middle temporal gyrus(MTG) and the right superior frontal
gyrus (SFG). And grey matter increase was identified in the left lingual gyrus
(LG) in TRD group compared to HC. In TSD group, grey matter increase was
observed in the bilateral STG, insula, the left MTG, the right IFG, supramarginal
gyrus(SMG), heschl gyrus (HG), rolandic operculum and postcentral gyrus. Moreover,
when compared with HC, the TSD group shows reduced grey matter in left IFG,
insula and gyrus rectus. In addition, comparison of effect sizes revealed that
TRD patients showed greater reductions in grey matters in left IFG in comparison
with TSD participants. And conjunction analysis confirmed it.
Discussion
To our knowledge, this is the first study
to pool VBM studies for a meta-analysis of grey matter differences among TRD,
TSD and HC. Although both TRD and TSD groups showed grey matter alteration in
frontal and temporal cortex in comparison with HC group, only grey matter volume
reduction in the left IFG was revealed in both TRD and TSD groups. The
decreased grey matter in the right SFG was only detected in the TRD group and
increased grey matter in the right IFG was only observed in the TSD group. Meanwhile,
grey matter volume of left STG and MTG were decreased in the TRD group while
they were increased in the TSD group. Furthermore, grey matter volume
reductions in the bilateral MCC, ACC and grey matter increased in the lingual
gyrus were only observed in the TRD group. In addition, abnormal grey matter in
insula was only demonstrated in the TSD group.
Conclusions
Both TRD and TSD groups
showed grey matter alterations in the cortical-limbic circuit. Although both TRD and TSD groups showed abnormal grey matter in
frontal and temporal cortex, the exact brain regions were mostly different in
both groups except the left IFG. Furthermore, grey matter volume reductions in
the bilateral cingulate cortex were only observed in the TRD group and abnormal
grey matter in insula was only demonstrated in the TSD group.
Acknowledgements
No acknowledgement found.References
Radua J, et al (2013): A general approach for combining voxel-based meta-analyses conducted in different neuroimaging modalities. Curr Med Chem 20:462–466.
Radua J,
et al (2014), Anisotropic
kernels for coordinate-based meta-analyses of neuroimaging studies. Front
Psychiatry. 2014 Feb 10;5:13.