Isabel Wank1, Silke Kreitz1, and Andreas Hess1
1Institute of Pharmacology and Toxicology, University of Erlangen-Nuremberg, Erlangen, Germany
Synopsis
Pain is a warning
sign and a highly potent modulator of behavior. This naturally very useful
mechanism evolves into a central healthcare problem, when pain becomes chronic and
highly impacting the patient's daily life.
By means of
fMRI and modern graph theoretical analyses, we surveyed dynamic changes of
functional connectivity within the mouse brain evoked within 7 sessions of
noxious thermal stimulation of the hind paw. With no evidence of peripheral
hyperalgesia, we found noticeable alterations of connectivity especially within
cognitive and associative-evaluative brain structures. We hypothesize that
these findings reflect profound changes that central sensitization impresses on
the brain.Introduction
Chronic
pain is a highly debilitating condition, which afflicts almost 30% of the
population worldwide. The burden for the healthcare systems as well as for the
suffering patients is high. Therefore, new insights into the processes of pain
chronification and the formation of a pain memory are urgently needed.
By means of
fMRI, we established a first mouse model to study the initial processes of pain
chronification, and hereby assessed the changes of brain functional
connectivity during this early induction phase.
Materials and Methods
All
measurements on 12-week old male C57Bl/6N mice (controls: n=8; chronification
group: n = 22) were conducted on a 4.7T Bruker Biospec (200mT gradient system,
quadrature mouse head coil) using BOLD fMRI (GE EPI sequence: TEef 25.035ms; TR
2000ms NEX 2; FOV 15x15mm; matrix 64x64; slice thickness 0.5mm; 22 slices
axial, 750 repetitions).
To initiate
potential chronification processes, the right hind paw of the animals was
stimulated during the fMRI-session with three sets of consecutive - two non-noxious
(40°C and 45°C) and two noxious (50°C and 55°C) - thermal stimuli, (controls only
45°C, repeated 12 times) lasting 20 seconds.
The experiment
lasted 14 days, consisting of fMRI measurements every other day, resulting in seven
measurements per animal. To exclude peripheral sensitization effects, the
Hargreaves Plantar Test was performed the day after each fMRI measurement. For
analysis, we first used the general linear model approach to detect voxels that
coupled significantly (FDR corrected) to the stimulation protocol. Next, an in-house
3D brain atlas was used to identify the significantly activated voxels of 196
brain structures. BOLD activation volume and peak amplitude were determined and the
mean time course of the BOLD-Signal was extracted for each structure.
Graph-theoretical
analyses based on cross-correlations of these time courses (after removal of
global signal) were used to construct stimulus specific networks. To ensure
ideal topological comparisons, the resulting networks were thresholded to
contain the same number of connections. Significant changes in connectivity1-3
between all brain structures were identified using Student's t-test.
Computation of hub properties4 and Blondel-Communities5 were used to
identify changes of interaction and the network parameters path length,
cluster-coefficient and small-world-index were used to characterize changes in
flow of information over the time course of the experiment.
Results and Discussion
First, no significant
changes in paw withdrawal latency and therefore no peripheral sensitization could
be shown for either the controls or the chronification group.
Activated
volume and peak amplitude showed a significant transient decrease around the
fourth measurement in most brain structures. Hence we assumed that the
repetitive noxious stimulation does not just affect a subset of brain
structures.
The
networks of both groups were shown to be of small-world-topology. Differences
in the small-world-index resulted from changes in the average path length,
where the controls and temperatures 40, 50 and 55°C of the chronification group
were relatively static, in contrast to the 45°C of the chronification group,
which showed great undulations over time. This may reflect changes in
temperature discrimination between non-noxious and noxious stimuli. The overall higher
cluster-coefficient of the chronification group indicated an enhanced and more
efficient information processing.
The
evaluation of changes in interactions between the structures (Blondel Communities) revealed highly
relevant alterations again of many structures like thalamus and hippocampus as
well as sensory and motor cortices.
Most strikingly, the emotional-affective
component of pain processing was changed: a profound and lasting dissociation
of cingulate, limbic and frontal association cortex as well as the septum from
the sensory and motor cortices, and an association
towards structures of the reward system (Nucleus accumbens and the olfactory
tubercle) could be shown for the chronification group, but not for the controls (Fig. 1).
Summary
Our results
therefore demonstrate that pain chronification might indeed start in the brain,
even before peripheral or behavioral symptoms can be
detected.
Acknowledgements
BMBF NeuroimpaReferences
1. Sporns O,
Chialvo DR, Kaiser M, Hilgetag CC (2004). Organization, development and
function of complex brain networks. Trends
in cognitive sciences 8(9): 418-425.
2. Hess A,
Axmann R, 2. Rech J, Finzel S, Heindl C, Kreitz S, et al. (2011). Blockade of TNF-alpha rapidly inhibits pain
responses in the central nervous system. Proceedings
of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 108(9): 3731-3736.
3. Neely GG,
Hess A, Costigan M, Keene AC, Goulas S, Langeslag M, et al. (2010). A genome-wide Drosophila screen for heat
nociception identifies alpha2delta3 as an evolutionarily conserved pain gene. Cell 143(4): 628-638.
4. Kleinberg
JM (1999). Authoritative sources in a hyperlinked environment. Journal of the ACM (JACM) 46(5): 604-632.
5. Blondel
VD, Guillaume J-L, Lambiotte R, Lefebvre E (2008). Fast unfolding of
communities in large networks. Journal of
Statistical Mechanics: Theory and Experiment 2008(10): P10008.