Jessica Steventon1, Catherine Foster1, Daniel Helme2, Monica Busse3, and Kevin Murphy1
1CUBRIC, Cardiff University, Cardiff, United Kingdom, 2School of Medicine, Cardiff University, Cardiff, United Kingdom, 3School of Healthcare Sciences, Cardiff University, Cardiff, United Kingdom
Synopsis
Here
we examine the acute effects of a single exercise session on cerebrovasculature
using a multi-TI arterial spin labelling (ASL) sequence to measure cerebral blood flow (CBF), and
a dual-echo ASL sequence with hypercapnia to
measure cerebrovascular reactivity (CVR). We show
that contrary to previous smaller studies, 20-minutes of aerobic exercise does
not affect CBF or CVR in the 60-minute period after exercise. Despite this, changes
in CBF after exercise were related to individually-determined systemic
physiological changes associated with exercise intensity, informing on moderators
of cerebral autoregulation.Purpose
Emerging research suggests that exercise has
beneficial effects on brain health, and its role as a therapeutic is under
investigation in various neurological conditions. In order to determine the optimal dose-response of exercise
for different patient populations, the dynamic mechanisms by which exercise exerts
affects the brain must be understood.
Whereas previous work has investigated
exercise effects on the brain in isolation1, in this
work we consider a range of exercise-induced
systemic effects which may determine cerebrovascular changes. Thus, we examine
group-level effects of a single session of aerobic exercise along with the
interaction between systemic and cerebral physiology after exercise using multi-modal
fMRI techniques.
Methods
22 healthy participants (11 males, 26.6 ± 4.7
years old) had an MRI scan on a 3T GE HDx system. The baseline MRI session included a multi-TI (mTI)
arterial spin labelling (ASL) sequence (TIs: 300,400,500, 600,700,800, 1100, 1400, 1700, 2000ms, TE = 0.27ms; slice
delay = 52 ms, QUIPSS II2 cutoff at TI>700 ms)
to measure cerebral blood flow (CBF), a hypercapnia gas challenge (targeted +5 mmHg PETCO2)
with a dual-echo gradient echo spiral readout sequence (TR = 2.2s; TE1
= 2.7s;
TE2 =29ms; 64
x 64; 15 slices; resolution = 3.1 × 3.1 × 8.4 mm3)
to measure cerebrovascular reactivity (CVR) in a subset of participants (n=12),
and a structural FSPGR (1mm3 resolution) sequence.
Participants
then completed 20-minutes of moderate intensity aerobic exercise on a cycle
ergometer. Immediately after, participants had a repeat MRI scan with the
multi-TI sequence repeated 3 times (see Fig.1) and the hypercapnia dual-echo sequence repeated at post
30-minutes. Perfusion quantification was performed on a voxel-by-voxel basis
using a two-compartment model3. For the mTI ASL, physiological noise
(RETROICOR4, PETCO2, respiration volume (RVT) and
heart rate (HR)) were regressed out. For BOLD and CBF CVR, following surround
averaging and subtraction respectively, PETCO2 was used
as a regressor in a general linear model5.
Exercise-related physiological
parameters of interest were: [1] HR recovery (difference between HR at peak exercise and 1 minute after cessation), with
attenuated HR recovery a presumed index of reduced parasympathetic activity6, [2] average blood lactate concentration during exercise, as a measure of
exercise-induced physiological strain, [3] mean arterial pressure following
exercise.
Results
Age and body mass index were found to
significantly correlate with CBF post exercise, and were added as covariates in
the CBF mTI analysis. A repeated-measures ANOVA found a significant main effect
of time on GM CBF after accounting for age and BMI (F 3,54 = 2.85, p
< 0.05); however post-hoc analyses showed this was driven by differences
between post-exercise sessions which did not survive multiple comparison
correction. Neither BOLD CVR nor CBF CVR were significantly altered by exercise
when measured 30-minutes post exercise cessation (Fig.2, CBF CVR p = 0.072).
Despite the lack of an effect of
exercise on cerebrovascular measures on a group level, the
exercise intervention resulted in prolonged systemic physiological changes
which endured for up to 40-minutes post exercise (Fig.3) which were significantly associated with the MR
cerebrovascular measures (see Table 1). Average blood lactate concentration (mmol/L) measured during the exercise intervention significantly
predicted the change in CBF 40-minutes after exercise (Fig.2D); a higher
lactate concentration, indicative of higher physiological load, was associated
with a reduction in CBF after exercise, whereas a lower lactate concentration
was associated with increased CBF. Mean arterial pressure predicted CBF 20-minutes
post exercise, whilst HR recovery from exercise was associated with baseline CVR
(CBF CVR r= -0.609; BOLD CVR r = -0.595, both p < 0.05 uncorrected) and change
in CBF post-20minutes, with a quicker recovery associated with less change.
Discussion & Conclusion
Despite enduring systemic physiological recovery in the
1-hour period following exercise cessation, absolute CBF and
hypercapnia-induced CVR were not significantly changed from baseline when
assessed at the group level. Crucially, this demonstrates robust cerebral
autoregulation in a healthy young population and contradicts previous smaller studies1,7 showing altered
cerebrovasculature post exercise without accounting for systemic physiology. The
lack of a main effect of exercise on cerebrovascular MR measures may suggest that
unlike cardiovascular health, the cerebrovascular health benefits associated
with exercise are driven purely by chronic adaptive mechanisms rather than a
combination of both acute and chronic mechanisms in a healthy population. Notably,
the change in CBF after exercise was sensitive to systemic physiological
factors related to exercise intensity, with the change in CBF found to be dependent
on a physiological index of metabolic load.
This understanding, of systemic physiological predictors of the
cerebrovascular response to exercise, will ultimately bring us closer to
individually-tailored exercise prescription.
Acknowledgements
We wish to acknowledge our funders the Wellcome Trust and Waterloo Foundation.References
1. MacIntosh, B.J., et
al. Impact of a single bout of aerobic exercise on regional brain perfusion and activation responses in healthy young adults. PLoS
One.
2014 8;9(1).
2. Wong, E.C., et al. Quantitative imaging of perfusion using a single subtraction (QUIPSS and QUIPSS II). MRM 1998; 39: 702–708.
3. Chappell, M.A., et al. Separation of macrovascular signal in multi-inversion time arterial spin labelling MRI.
MRM. 2010; 63: 1357–1365.
4. Glover, G. et al., Image-based method for retrospective correction of physiological motion effects in fMRI: RETROICOR. MRM. 2000;44(1):162-7.
5. Bright, M., et al. Reliable quantification of BOLD fMRI cerebrovascular reactivity despite poor breath-hold performance. Neuroimage, 2013, 83, 559-568.
6. Imai K., et al. Vagally mediated heart rate recovery after exercise is accelerated
in athletes but blunted in patients with chronic heart failure. J Am Coll Cardiol. 1994; 24:
1529–1535.
7. Smith, J., et al. Detecting changes in human cerebral blood flow after acute exercise using arterial spin labeling: implications for fMRI. J. Neuroscience Methods, 2010, 191,258.