Ross W. Mair1,2, Martin Reuter2,3, and Andre J. van der Kouwe2
1Center for Brain Science, Harvard University, Cambridge, MA, United States, 2A.A. Martinos Center for Biomedical Imaging, Massachusetts General Hospital, Charlestown, MA, United States, 3Department of Mechanical Engineering, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, MA, United States
Synopsis
The
multi-echo MPRAGE (MEMPRAGE) sequence was implemented to reduce signal
distortion by acquiring at a higher bandwidth and averaging multiple echoes to
recover SNR while providing additional T2* information that can enhance
cortical segmentation. A rapid 2-minute MEMPRAGE protocol has been implemented
for large multi-center studies. Here, we investigate the impact on morphometric
results for the cortex by systematically varying all the parameters modified
between the rapid 2-minute scan and a conventional 6-minute structural scan.
Small but significant differences in cortical
thickness and gray matter volume result from a combination of the use of
partial fourier acquisition and lowering the spatial resolution to 1.2mm.Introduction
Automated MRI-derived measurements of human
brain volumes from anatomical scans provide novel insights into normal and
abnormal neuroanatomy, but few studies have probed the effects of
sequence-dependent parameters on these measurements.
1 The multi-echo MPRAGE
(MEMPRAGE) sequence reduces signal distortion by using a higher bandwidth and
averaging multiple echoes to recover SNR while using variable
T2* decays to enhance
contrast, and hence, cortical segmentation.
2 For maximal efficiency, a rapid
2-minute MEMPRAGE protocol has been implemented for large multi-center studies.
3 This yields quantitatively repeatable morphometric information on
sub-cortical/white-matter structures in comparison to scans employing a
higher-resolution MEMPRAGE protocol with lower image acceleration.
4 However,
small but significant differences in cortical thickness and gray matter volume
were observed between the two protocols.
5 Here, we investigate the impact on
morphometric results for the cortex by systematically varying all the
parameters modified between the rapid 2-minute and the conventional 6-minute MEMPRAGE
scans.
Methods
All measurements were performed using a 3.0 T
MRI scanner (Siemens Tim Trio). 10 subjects (mean: 28.9 years, 5 male) were
scanned using the 12-channel coil. Each session included a standard MEMPRAGE
(6:03 min, TR/TI = 2530/1200 ms, matrix 256×256×176, resolution = 1 mm iso (no
partial fourier), parallel imaging (PI) acceleration = 2 (p2)); and a rapid MEMPRAGE
(2:12 min, TR/TI = 2200/1100 ms, matrix 230×230×144, resolution = 1.2 mm iso
(6/8 partial fourier), PI = 4 (p4)). TR/TI; matrix/resolution/partial fourier;
and PI acceleration were systematically varied between standard and rapid
scans, resulting in a total of eight MEMPRAGE scans for each subject (See Fig.
1). Images were analyzed using FreeSurfer,
6 after the eight scans from each
subject were aligned using the FreeSurfer robust registration tool.
7 An
automated parcellation of the cortex, subcortical and white matter structures
was performed. The 33 cortical regions
of the Desikan-Killiany atlas were combined into five principal cortical lobes.
8 Correlation and Bland-Altman difference plots were made for the thickness and volume
of each principal cortical lobe determined from each scan.
Results
Three difference-analyses were performed: all 1.0mm
scans for all subjects vs. all corresponding 1.2mm scans for all subjects; all
p2 scans for all subjects vs. all p4 scans; and all TR2530 vs. all TR2200 scans.
Example Bland-Altman plots are shown in Fig. 2. The difference analyses are
summarized in Fig. 3. The resolution change resulted in significant differences
in cortical thickness and volume, similar to those observed previously.
5 TR/TI
variation had no effect, while PI acceleration had no significant effect. Bland-Altman slopes were ~ -0.2 – 0.2, indicating no
bias with measurement value. Correlation coefficients are summarized in Fig. 4.
Discussion
Small but significant differences in cortical
thickness and gray matter volume were previously seen between 6-min and 2-min
MEPRAGE scans.
5 This could result from either slight blurring of the GM/WM
boundary in the rapid scan from the use of partial fourier acquisition, or from
the resampling of the 1.2mm data to 1.0mm by the standard Freesurfer processing
stream. Surprisingly, the reduced TR/TI
from the Freesurfer recommended values had no effect on cortical data, while PI
acceleration had no significant effect. It has recently been shown that motion
by subjects can result in reduced estimates of cortical thickness.
9 While
longer scans are more likely to be impacted by subject motion, it is the
shorter scans here which show a reduced cortical thickness, indicating motion
is likely not responsible for the effects seen in this study. Rather, blurring of the GM/WM boundary must happen at the expense of pure GM, resulting in cortical thinning in the case of the faster scans. For a rapid MEMPRAGE with no impact on
cortical thickness compared to conventional scans, a 1.0 mm spatial resolution scan employing the other
techniques to speed the acquisition is optimal. Such a scan would take 3 mins 13 sec.
Acknowledgements
NIH Grants P41-RR14075, U24-RR021382.References
1. Wonderlick, J.S. et
al., ‘Reliability of MRI-derived cortical and subcortical morphometric
measures: Effects of pulse sequence, voxel geometry, and parallel imaging’, NeuroImage, 2009:44;1324-1333.
2. van der Kouwe, A.J.W.
et al., ‘Brain morphometry with multiecho MPRAGE’, NeuroImage, 2008:40:559–569.
3. Holmes, A.J. et al., 'Brain Genomics Superstruct Project
initial data release with structural,
functional, and behavioral
measures', Scientific Data, 2015;2:150031.
4. Mair, R.W. et al., ‘Quantitative Comparison of
Morphometric Data from Multi-Echo MPRAGE Variable Acceleration and Different
Head Coils’, Proceedings ISMRM, 2013;21:947.
5. Mair, R.W. et al., ‘Validation of Cortical Thickness/Volume Data from Multi-Echo MPRAGE
Scans with Variable Acceleration in Young and Elderly Populations’, Proceedings ISMRM, 2014;22:1795.
6. Fischl, B, ‘Measuring
the thickness of the human cerebral cortex from magnetic resonance images’, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA, 2000;97:11050-11055.
7. Reuter, M., ‘Highly
Accurate Inverse Consistent Registration: A Robust Approach’, NeuroImage, 2010;53;1181-1196.
8. surfer.nmr.mgh.harvard.edu/fswiki/CorticalParcellation
9. Reuter, M. et al. (2015), ‘Head motion during MRI acquisition reduces gray matter volume and
thickness estimates’, NeuroImage, 2015;107;105-115.