Benjamin A Walter1,2, Prasath Mageswaran1,3, Hazem Mashaly1,4, William Thoman 1,4, Daniel Boulter5, Luciano Prevedello 5, Xuan Nguyen 5, Mo Xiaokui 6, Ehud Mendel 1,4, William Marras1,3, and Arunark Kolipaka1,2,5,7
1Spine Research Institute, The Ohio State University, Columbus, OH, United States, 2Biomedical Engineering, The Ohio State University, Columbus, OH, United States, 3Integrated Systems Engineering, The Ohio State University, Columbus, OH, United States, 4Neurological Surgery, The Ohio State University Wexner Medical Center, Columbus, OH, United States, 5Radiology, The Ohio State University Wexner Medical Center, Columbus, OH, United States, 6Biomedical Informatics, The Ohio State University, Columbus, OH, United States, 7Cardiovascular Medicine, The Ohio State University Wexner Medical Center, Columbus, OH, United States
Synopsis
Magnetic
resonance elastography (MRE) was used to assess intervertebral disc (IVD) shear
properties in order to develop an objective biomarker for the IVD degeneration
process. This study characterized the
frequency response and repeatability of MRE assessment of IVD shear stiffness
and how the shear stiffness of the nucleus pulposus (NP) region of the IVD
changes during degeneration. Results suggest that MRE derived NP shear
stiffness is a repeatable technique that can provide a relative and objective
measurement of IVD degeneration that is independent of age.Purpose:
Intervertebral disc (IVD) degeneration is
characterized by progressive changes in matrix orientation and composition [1]. Therefore, in-vivo
measurements of IVD mechanical properties, which are a product of both
structure and composition, could provide an objective classification of the
degeneration process. Magnetic resonance elastography (MRE) is a non-invasive
imaging technique that allows the measurement of shear properties by tracking
wave propagation through soft tissues and has been used to aid diagnosis of
cardiac and liver diseases associated with increased tissue stiffness [2,3].
This study aimed to (i) investigate the relationship between in-vivo shear stiffness (m) and IVD degeneration and its reproducibility and (ii) characterize how
the diurnal change in IVD height (due to daily creep) influence in-vivo shear stiffness
Methods:
Thirty nine subjects with no prior history of
chronic low back pain (Ages: 20-65) were scanned in the morning (AM) and in the
evening (PM) with an average of 6.4 hours
between scans. All protocols were approved
by institutional review board. All images (Sag: T2, Ax: T1 & MRE) were
obtained using a 3T MRI scanner (Tim Trio, Siemens). For MRE scans, vibrations
were applied to the lower back via a pneumatic driver system and the in- and
through- plane displacements were encoded. The first harmonics of the
displacement fields were processed using a multimodel direct inversion (MMDI)
algorithm to estimate the weighted stiffness of the IVD. A 4x4 median filter
was applied to all stiffness maps and the nucleus pulposus (NP) region was
traced on the T1 axial scan and copied on the stiffness map to report the mean
shear stiffness.
Frequency Response:
The L34 IVD of five subjects was scanned at three different excitation
frequencies (60, 80 and 100Hz). For the
reproducibility and degeneration studies MRE vibrations were applied at 80Hz.
Reproducibility: The L34 IVD of eight subjects was scanned
three times, with the subject and driver repositioned in between scans. The
average NP shear stiffness from scans 1 through 3 was compared with repeated
measures ANOVA.
Diurnal & Degeneration:
Five scorers (three radiologists and 2 neurosurgeons) were blinded and
assigned a Pfirrmann degeneration score three times to every IVD. The average of the 15 scores per IVD was
rounded and assigned to each IVD. Stiffness values were not normally distributed
and diurnal stiffness values were log transformed to obtain a normal
distribution. A one-way ANOVA was used to determine if there were significant
differences in NP shear stiffness between the different degrees of IVD
degeneration and a paired t-test compared AM and PM stiffness. The effect of age was assessed via a Spearman
correlation.
Results
Frequency Response: There was
a linear increase in NP shear stiffness with frequency (Fig 1). 80Hz was chosen
because it gave an NP shear stiffness (12.2±4.1 kPa) similar to the
rheologically derived NP shear modulus (7.4±11.6 kPa)[4].
Reproducibility: There were no significant differences between the
NP shear stiffness between the three repeat scans (Fig 2).
Diurnal & Degeneration: There was a significant decrease in NP
shear stiffness between a Pfirrmann degeneration grade 2 and grade 4 &5
(Fig. 3). There was a weak correlation between NP shear stiffness and age for
levels L23 (R2=0.156, p=0.004) and L45 (R2=0.167,
p=0.0002) and no correlations for L12, L34 & L5S1. No differences were
observed between AM and PM shear stiffness (Table 1).
Discussion:
Results suggest that MRE analysis can provide a
repeatable measurement of NP stiffness that may serve as an objective biomarker
of the degeneration process that is independent of age. The magnitude of the shear
stiffness of non-degenerated NP tissue measured in this study is similar to
previous in-vitro shear stiffness
measurements [4]; and confirms in-vitro
MRE findings that shear stiffness is reduced with degeneration [5]. Due to the
non-linear creep response, ~50-60% of the daily height loss was expected
between scans; however this did not induce a detectable difference in NP shear
stiffness. Underestimation of the shear stiffness of the annulus fibrosus (AF)
was due to insufficient wave numbers generated withi n this region because
of its high shear stiffness. However, this does allow a visualization of the NP
area which may provide a measure of NP inhomogeneity.
Conclusion:
MRE analysis of
IVD shear stiffness allows an objective and non-invasive assessment of IVD
degeneration that is independent of age.
Acknowledgements
Acknowledgements:
Funded by NIH R01HL124096 and the
Spine Research Institute at The Ohio State University.References
References: [1] Adams &
Roughley 2006 [2] Kolipaka+ JMRI 2012 [3] Chamarthi+ Magn Res Imag 2014
[4]
Iatridis+ J Biomech 1997 [5] Cortes+
Mag Res Med 2014