Casey Anderson1, Andrew Nencka2, Tugan Muftuler3, Kathleen Schmainda2, and Kevin Koch2
1Biophysics, Medical College of Wisconsin, Milwaukee, WI, United States, 2Radiology, Medical College of Wisconsin, Milwaukee, WI, United States, 3Neurosurgery, Medical College of Wisconsin, Milwaukee, WI, United States
Synopsis
Quantitative
susceptibility maps are routinely compromised by streaking artifacts.
Here, we present a technique called volume-parcellated quantitative
susceptibility mapping (VP-QSM), which performs independent susceptibility
inversion on multiple reduced field-of-view parcels over the entire tissue
field map. These parcels are combined to
form a composite susceptibility map. In
this algorithm, streaking artifacts are confined to individual parcels,
improving the quality of the susceptibility map without a dependence on the
underlying QSM inversion algorithm. In this study, VP-QSM is demonstrated on a 7T
human volunteer, as well as on 30 subjects participating in sports concussion
and brain cancer neuroimaging research protocols. Purpose
In quantitative susceptibility mapping (QSM), the relationship
between measured off-resonance shifts and underlying tissue susceptibility
possesses mathematical singularities. This complicates computational approaches to the QSM problem
1.
Currently, the gold standard for QSM utilizes multiple-orientation acquisitions
2 (where the patient moves to different angles with respect to the static
magnetic field direction). This approach
is robust to streaking artifacts, but is clinically impractical. Single-orientation datasets are the only
clinically viable QSM alternative, but remain vulnerable to streaking artifacts,
thus limiting the viability of QSM as a robust clinical imaging alternative.
Here, we present a technique, volume-parcellated quantitative susceptibility
mapping (VP-QSM), which performs QSM inversion on multiple reduced
field-of-view (FOV) off-resonance maps, henceforth referred to as parcels, to
create a composite susceptibility map with reduced streaking.
Methods
In VP-QSM, distal field information is neglected in the inversion
of a target parcel. An assumption of
VP-QSM is that sufficient parcel padding can be used to include relevant distal
field information to within the numerical accuracy of the applied inversion. To demonstrate the validity of this principle,
we can consider a spherically-approximated voxel of susceptibility, which has a
well-known analytic dipole dependence. The
distance at which this susceptibility source’s induced field perturbation contributes negligibly to
the field-offset measurement ultimately determines the amount of necessary
additional spatial information outside a target parcel that is needed to
account for all local susceptibility sources within the target parcel. This threshold is dependent on field map
noise, anticipated maximum tissue susceptibility offsets, and optimization
voxel sizes.
In addition to this analytic derivation, a numerical phantom was
developed to test the effect of removing distal information with varying
amounts of overlap and zero-padding (Fig 1). Optimal parameters derived from
these results are applied to multiple parcels covering the full FOV to create
multiple local susceptibility maps, which are combined to form a composite
susceptibility map. A small overlapping
boundary between adjacent parcels was utilized to reduce parcel-combination
artifacts (Fig 2).
In-vivo results are shown
from a healthy control dataset acquired on a 7T GE Healthcare Discovery 950
scanner. In addition, a cohort analysis of ten brain cancer patients, ten
recently-concussed patients, and ten controls scanned on a GE 3T Discovery 750 scanner
was performed to compare streaking artifact reduction with VP-QSM. Brains were
masked with brain extraction tool3, background field was removed with
projection onto dipole fields4, and susceptibility maps were generated with MEDI5.
Streaking artifacts were estimated by subtracting the absolute values of both
the volume-parcellated and full FOV susceptibility map. Computational
performances for different parcel amounts were performed in MATLAB with up to
12 cores.
Results
Analytic derivations
and numerical simulations both showed that roughly 1.0 cm of additional spatial information (red X, Fig
1e) is sufficient to retain quantitative accuracy with reduced FOV
regularization. This estimate is provided for the presented 3T imaging data,
using a maximum expected susceptibility of 0.70 ppm, 2mm
3 voxels, and field
noise of 0.1 Hz. This value can change
depending on static field strength, field map SNR, and voxel resolution. Computational performance (Table 1)
determined 512 equally-spaced parcels provided sufficient tradeoff for
computational expense and parcel size, which was used for VP-QSM with the
numerical phantom and
in-vivo datasets. For the numerical phantom,
volume-parcellation provided comparable RMSE to standard full FOV processing
(6.2E-6 to 5.9E-6, respectively). An example of streaking reduction feasible
with VP-QSM is shown in the 7T in-vivo dataset (red arrows, Fig 3). For
the cohort analysis, a noticeable reduction in streaking artifacts was observed
for all datasets (Figure 4).
Discussion
Volume-parcellation constrains streaking artifacts to individual
parcels, limiting their propagation throughout the volume and improving the
quality of the composite susceptibility map. In addition, improved spatial
field information within a parcel will improve convergence in the
regularization in the target parcel. With sufficient additional spatial
information and proper background correction methods, this provides a means to
create quantitatively accurate susceptibility maps with limited streaking
artifacts.
Conclusion
VP-QSM, which is
compatible with all existing susceptibility mapping algorithms, allows for improved
stabilization of QSM near regions of poor field estimates. In addition, VP-QSM is well-suited for use
with distributed computing algorithms for fast computation. Streaking artifacts are often encountered in
ultra-high field QSM, as well as in large-cohort studies of clinical or
untrained volunteer populations. In
addition, automated pipelines are often more vulnerable to streaking due to
intermittent errors in phase-unwrapping, background field removal, or brain
masking algorithms. VP-QSM offers a
mechanism to add robustness to existing QSM studies that are often compromised
by these systematic limitations.
Acknowledgements
This work was funded by NIH/NCI R01 CA082500; NIH/NCI U01 CA17611, Advancing a Healthier Wisconsin 5520265References
1) Wang, Mag. Reson Med. 2015;73:82–101. 2) Liu, Mag. Reson Med. 2009 Jan;61(1):196-204. 3) Smith, Hum Brain Mapp. 2002 Nov;17(3):143-55 4) Liu, NMR Biomed. 2011 Nov;24(9):1129-36 5) Liu, Mag. Reson Med. 2011;66:777–783