Chengcheng Zhu1, Bing Tian2, Florent Seguro1, Joe Leach1, Qi Liu2, Jianping Lu2, Luguang Chen2, Michael Hope1, and David Saloner1
1Radiology, University of California, San Francisco, San Francisco, CA, United States, 2Radiology, Changhai Hospital, Shanghai, China, People's Republic of
Synopsis
Computed Tomography angiography (CTA) is the gold
standard for abdominal
aortic aneurysm (AAA) imaging, but requires radiation and iodinated
contrast. We previously developed an isotropic 3D black blood technique (DANTE-SPACE) for AAA imaging. In
this study we validated 3D MRI against CTA for AAA diameter and volume
measurement, and found excellent accuracy and reproducibility. Features of intra-luminal
thrombus (ILT) composition that are possibly related to faster AAA growth can
be identified on 3D MRI but not on CTA. 3D black blood MRI can be used as a non-invasive tool for AAA serial
monitoring and ILT evaluation and has the potential to improve patient risk
stratification. Purpose
Current management of abdominal
aortic aneurysm (AAA) disease is based on the maximal diameter of the aneurysm,
and intervention is recommended when the AAA has a diameter larger than 5.5 cm. Computed
Tomography angiography (CTA) is the gold standard for AAA imaging, but requires
radiation and iodinated contrast, and is therefore not the preferred modality
for serial monitoring. Black blood MRI is a promising tool for AAA monitoring as
it does not require radiation or iodinated contrast agent and has excellent
soft tissue contrast that allows characterization of the aortic wall and
intra-luminal thrombus (ILT). However the accuracy and reproducibility of
BB-MRI has not been established. A previous study suggested AAAs with fresh ILT
(hyper-intense on T1-weighted MRI) were likely to progress two times faster
compared with those without fresh ILT
1. We have
previously developed an isotropic 3D
black blood technique for AAA imaging which showed good image quality and the
potential to identify ILT age
2. This study aims to 1) validate 3D MRI for quantifying AAA dimensions
using CTA as a reference standard, and evaluate its inter-observer reproducibility;
2) compare MRI and CTA for evaluating ILT composition.
Methods
Study
population: 26 patients (22 male, age 73±9) with AAA disease were
recruited in two centres (UCSF and Shanghai). All patients underwent high
resolution MRI and CTA scans within an average interval of 11 days.
Scanning
protocols: MRI scans were
undertaken in Siemens Skyra 3T scanners. Two T1-weighted 3D sequences were acquired. 1) Blood suppressed
fast-spin echo with variable flip angle train (DANTE-SPACE) 2: TR/TE: 800ms/20ms, 1.3mm isotropic resolution 2) 3D GRE (VIBE): TR/TE 4.2ms/1.2ms, 1.3x1.3x2.6mm. CTAs were acquired
using clinical protocols with ~0.8mm isotropic resolution.
Image analysis: Two
experienced radiologists measured the maximal diameter of the AAAs using multi-planar
reconstruction (MPR) on both the black blood MRI images and the CTA images. ILT
and psoas muscle signal
intensities were recorded at the location of maximal diameter of the AAA on MRI
images. ILT signal ratio (ILTr) was calculated as SignalILT/SignalMuscle.
ILTs were characterized as fresh (hyper-intense) or old (iso-intense). Another
reviewer manually segmented the lumen and outer wall boundaries of the AAAs
using both MRI and CT images, and the overall AAA volume and lumen volume were quantified.
Statistics:
Bland Altman plots, coefficient of variance (CV) and intra-class
coefficient (ICC) were used to compare between methods.
Results
Good
quality MRI and CTA images were successfully acquired in all patients.
Quantitative comparison results are shown in Figure 1 and Table 1, and representative
patients images are shown in Figure 2-4. There is an excellent agreement
between black blood MRI and CTA for diameter and volume measurements
(ICC>0.99, CV<5%). Both MRI and CTA are highly reproducible for diameter quantification
(ICC>0.99, CV<2.5%). ILT shows homogeneous signal at CTA, but heterogeneous signal on MRI.
Three types of ILT composition
were classified: (I: predominantly
fresh ILT; II: predominantly old ILT; III: mixture of both.) There was good
agreement for identifying fresh ILT using DANTE-SPACE and VIBE, however, only
moderate agreement was found for the ILTr quantification (Pearson
r=0.31).
Discussion
To our knowledge, this is the first study comparing
3D black blood MRI against CTA for AAA imaging. DANTE-SPACE is shown to be
accurate and reproducible for AAA dimension measurements. The advantage of the
proposed technique over CTA is that it is totally non-invasive and can differentiate
between different thrombus components, which can possibly be used to improve
the risk stratification of patients
1. A previous study used a T1-weighted GRE sequence to identify fresh
ILT (hyper-intense signal)
1. We
validated the T1 weighting of SPACE against a GRE sequence (VIBE) for fresh ILT
characterization (Figure 2). In addition, the higher resolution of SPACE
improves the visualization of ILT composition (Figure 2-4). Sub-fresh/old ILT is
hypointense on SPACE compared to VIBE (Figure 4), given its T2/T2* weighting induced
by the long echo train. Detailed composition and morphology of ILT was clearly
shown on SPACE images. However, the relationship of this information to AAA progression
needs to be investigated in larger scale longitudinal studies.
Conclusion
3D black blood provides accurate
and reproducible AAA dimension measurements as validated by CTA. In addition,
it provides additional information on the ILT age and composition that is
closely related to progressive AAA disease. 3D black blood MRI can be used as a
non-invasive tool for AAA serial monitoring and ILT evaluation, and has the
potential to improve patient risk stratification.
Acknowledgements
This study is supported by NIH grants R01HL114118 and R01NS059944.References
1. Nguyen,
V. L. et al. Abdominal aortic
aneurysms with high thrombus signal intensity on magnetic resonance imaging are
associated with high growth rate. Eur J
Vasc Endovasc Surg 48, 676-684,
(2014).
2. Zhu, C. et al. Isotropic 3D Black Blood MRI of
Abdominal Aortic Aneurysm Wall and Intraluminal Thrombus. Magn Reson Imaging, doi:
10.1016/j.mri.2015.10.002 (2015).