Jyothika Kumar1, Emma L Hall2, Siân E Robson2, Carolina Fernandes2, Elizabeth B Liddle1, Matthew J Brookes2, Lena Palaniyappan1, Peter G Morris2, and Peter F Liddle1
1Centre for Translational Neuroimaging, Division of Psychiatry and Applied Psychology, University of Nottingham, Nottingham, United Kingdom, 2Sir Peter Mansfield Imaging Centre, School of Physics and Astronomy, University of Nottingham, Nottingham, United Kingdom
Synopsis
Various theories of neurochemical
dysfunction in schizophrenia have been proposed. Using 7T MR spectroscopy, we
aim to investigate abnormalities in the antioxidant and glutamatergic systems
in patients with schizophrenia and whether there is a relationship between the
two. We found reduced levels of glutathione in the anterior cingulate cortex (ACC)
in patients with residual schizophrenia indicating a reduction in the brain’s
antioxidant defences accompanied by reduced levels of glutamate and glutamine.
A positive correlation between glutathione and glutamate was observed in the
ACC in all participants indicating a mechanistic link between these two systems.
Background
Extensive research
has shown that schizophrenia is a complex disorder with multiple factors
contributing to its aetiology. Prominent among these are neurochemical
abnormalities and the two leading theories of neurochemical dysfunction are – 1)
the NMDAR hypofunction hypothesis which relates to an aberrant glutamate (Glu)/glutamine (Gln) system
1
and 2) the neuro-inflammation hypothesis which relates to altered redox balance
and glutathione (GSH) levels.
2 These two theories are now thought to
be related. However, studies investigating levels of Glu, Gln or GSH using MR
spectroscopy (MRS) in schizophrenia have reported conflicting results. There is
no clear evidence in humans as to how these two systems are related to each
other, or to clinical aspects of the illness. However, current evidence raises
the possibility that the nature of abnormalities in these neurochemicals might
change with advancing phase of illness.
2,3Aims
In this study we
specifically aim to investigate whether deficits in GSH, Glu and Gln are
more pronounced in patients with residual schizophrenia (defined in the ICD-10
as the chronic stage in the development of the illness in which there has been
a clear progression from an early stage (with psychotic symptoms) to a later
stage characterized by long-term negative symptoms).
4Methods
45 healthy
volunteers, 15 patients with residual schizophrenia and 13 patients with
non-residual schizophrenia participated in this study. All scans were conducted
on a Philips Achieva 7T MR scanner (Philips Healthcare, Best, Netherlands)
using a volume transmit head coil and a 32 channel
receive head coil. An MPRAGE sequence (isotropic resolution = 1 mm
3, TE/TR
= 3/7 ms, FA = 8°) was used for voxel positioning. 1
H
STEAM spectra were obtained from the anterior cingulate cortex (ACC) (20x18x25
mm
3) – the main region of interest and also from the visual cortex
(20x22x20 mm
3) and the left insula (40x12x18 mm
3) for
comparison. A sample spectrum is shown in Figure 1 and voxel placements are
shown in Figure 2. The following acquisition parameters were used: TE/TM/TR =
17/17/2000 ms, 256 averages, 4096 samples and BW = 4 kHz.
MRS data were reformatted, phase-corrected, averaged across coil-elements and
repeats and realigned to account for frequency drifts. The data were then
combined using the coil-averaging technique reported by Hall et al.
5 LCModel
6
was used for absolute metabolite quantification and concentrations were
corrected for partial volume effects.
7 Statistical analyses were
performed using SPSS (IBM). Three univariate ANOVAS were performed to explore
differences in GSH, Glu and Gln between the three groups. Partial correlations
with age and current medication intake as covariates were used to examine the
relationship between GSH and Glu in the ACC in the three groups.
Results
Patients with
residual schizophrenia had significantly less GSH, Glu and Gln in the ACC
compared to healthy volunteers (
p < 0.05) and less Glu compared to patients
with non-residual schizophrenia (
p < 0.05) (Figure 3). No significant
differences were found in the insula or the visual cortex. There was a strong
positive correlation between GSH and Glu in the ACC in healthy controls (
r = 0.68, p < 0.05) and in patients with residual schizophrenia (
r = 0.80, p < 0.05) (Figure 4). Although not statistically
significant, there was a trend toward positive correlation between GSH and Glu
in the ACC in patients with non-residual schizophrenia.
Discussion
Our
findings are consistent with two alternate hypotheses: in the first hypothesis
the primary problem in schizophrenia is a long standing deficit in GSH and an
associated tendency to NMDAR hypofunction; in the other, the primary problem is
an acute event that triggers glutamatergic over-activity, excitotoxicity,
neural damage and a subsequent deficit state. We also found a strong positive
correlation between GSH and Glu in healthy controls, consistent with a
mechanistic link between the antioxidant and glutamatergic systems in the human
brain. These findings, as well as correlations between these neurochemicals in
both patient groups in the stable state, support the hypothesis that under
steady state conditions, low levels of GSH are usually associated with low
levels of glutamatergic neurotransmission. This finding provides scope for further
investigations into the relationship between oxidative stress and NMDAR
hypofunction and brings together the neuroinflammatory and glutamatergic
excitotoxicity theories of schizophrenia.
Acknowledgements
We would like to thank the Dr Hadwen Trust, the Wellcome Trust and the Medical Research Council (MRC) for funding this research. JK holds a scholarship from the University of Nottingham and a studentship from Mental Health Research UK (MHRUK). References
[1] Krystal JH & Moghaddam B, Schizophrenia 3rd edn 433-461, 2011 [2] Wood et al, Ann Acad Med
Singapore 38(5): 396-6, 2009. [3] Marsman et al, Schizophrenia Bull 39(1):
120-9, 2013. [4] World Health
Organization, ICD-10 Classification of Mental and Behavioural Disorders, 1992. [5] Hall et al, Neuroimage 86: 35-42,
2014. [6] Provencher, Magn Reson Med 30(6): 672-9, 1993 [7] Gasparovic
et al, Magn Reson Med 55(6): 1219-26, 2006.